The way I see it, there are all kinds of scam medical practitioners in Chinese medicine as in Western medicine. However, from personal experience and from testimonies of other satisfied clients, the genuine traditional Chinese medicine that is predominantly herbal is quite efficacious for a good number of complaints.
Of course a lot of Chinese medical practices have been proven to be efficacious on exclusively auto-suggestion mechanism; but there are materiae medicae and treatments that are really efficacious on their intrinsic merits.
What I like to hear from fellow dopers here, who are critical and maybe even scientifically trained in medical researches, is how the serious Chinese medicine works, assuming it truly works?
If you ask my opinion, for those who are spending money and time and trouble with Western medicine and getting nowhere, and you are not in any kind of terminal disease which you yourself know you are, and perhaps even in that situation, try Chinese medicine.
Here are my tips on how to find a good Chinese medicine practitioner and what to expect:
-
Get someone from China and who used to practice there, not anyone who grew up in the U.S. or elsewhere.
-
Get someone who does not sell the medical materials which he also prescribes. You buy the prescribed herbs from the standard Chinese apothecary (that’s a druggist, OK, a pharmacist, but make sure the shop is owned and operated by an ethnic Chinese, one from China).
-
Get someone who does not charge except reasonably; how much? The one I see every now and then and people I know and others who refer him to me, I pay him the routine $20 per visit.
-
You might have to wait long, because there are a lot of others from the deprived neighborhoods waiting to see him. You don’t make any appointment, just go there early and wait.
-
If you get someone who does not speak except a few English words, you might be lucky, yes lucky; because then he’s the real MacCoy, not yet diluted with pretenses toward Western medicine. The Chinese also seeing him, maybe much fewer than guys from deprived neighborhoods, will help you and him to communicate.
-
Most probably no privacy during the consultation, you just tell him your complaints with a straight face in the presence of others waiting to see him.
-
He will take your blood pulse from each wrist - and sometimes he will call out in his own English: “All cellphones shut”, addressed not to you, but to the whole assembly; the guy can hear the slightest murmur of any cellphone turned on.
-
He will also ask you to open your mouth wide, direct a flashlight into your oral cavity and look in without moving his head near, maybe similarly ask you to put out your tongue or move it to the palate.
-
If necessary he will do some palpating, contact of fingers with slight pressure on your body surface for more exact probing - no, no stripping whatsoever on your part.
-
He will explain to you in his English what’s your trouble and where, in the lungs, in the stomach, in the heart, in the kidneys, in the bones, etc.
-
Now the prescription – and I forgot to tell you guys, make sure you get a guy who writes his prescription in Chinese, that’s the real Chinese medicine practitioner, not one of those aping Chinese doctors – he will ask you whether you prefer herbs or tablets, pills, capsules (there are such in the standard Chinese apothecary’s shop, OK, drugstore); if you tell him to decide for you, he will recommend herbs.
-
He will write the herbs you are to buy from the Chinese apothecary, the kinds, the quantity of each, and the times you are to take them.
-
He might also give you some papers on diet and simple directions for healthy life, prepared by himself with the help of some English writing Chinese; that’s included in the consultation fee of $20. (I don’t take those diet directives very seriously and not extensively or comprehensively, though.)
-
You proceed to the nearest or most convenient standard Chinese apothecary’s shop, and ask for the herbs described in the prescription; the guy there will get them together and pack them into separate bags each to be boiled for each serving. And surprise of surprises, at least for me and others of my acquaintance, the herbs cost so very very little compared to medicine from Western pharmaceutical manufacturers.
-
Instruction for brewing the herbs: use porcelain cooking vessel or glass, no metallic vessels. Why? chemical interactions between the herbs and the metals might spoil the virtue of the brew. Right? Elementary, Watson!
-
Take the brew once or twice a day, morning and evening. I brew my herbs two or more times until the flavor is already weak.
-
By the way, my Chinese doctor doesn’t keep any records. You go back to him with the prescription he gave you the last time; that’s how he keeps track of your complaints.
My general impression: Chinese medicine works slowly; for quick fast relief, if relief is available, you have got to go to Western medicine. In emergency cases, Western medicine is indispensable. When surgical intervention is needed, you have no choice but Western medicine; for example, a busted appendicitis.
But if your trouble is one that Western medicine or doctors don’t seem to be able to help, try the Chinese herbalists. Also in non-life-threatening situations, and you want to save money and keep away a lot of unwanted side effects known or unknown, try the Chinese herbalists. But watch out for quack Chinese drugs and quack Chinese scam doctors.
Are the healings obtained by Chinese medicine purely random beneficial occurrences? I think it would be a very biased person and definitely unscientific to keep to that kind of an attitude. What I would really like to see are genuine statistical studies of Chinese medicine successes and then very objective attempts at scientific explanations.
Susma Rio Sep