Why is Christmas a national holiday in the USA? I mean what is the logic? No other Christian holiday is a federal holiday. Easter Monday is a holiday in Canada. But not here. The Feast of St. John the Baptist? St. Swithin’s Day?
And what about other religions FTM? Passover? Ramadan? The Hindu Festival of Lights?
And since this is GD, I also have to ask. Should it be a national holiday?
As for how it should be dealt with… there are many possible religious holidays; one proposal is not to make any of them compulsory, instead to let each individual pick their own, up to a certain maximum, that way offices should be able to stay open most of the time if there are enough diverse personnel.
It’s a relatively recent change as well - for a long time, Christmas was not an official holiday at all in Massachusetts for example (that changed in 1856)
It is of course not a national holiday in Thailand. But when I worked at the Bangkok Post, but the were so many Western staff that the newspaper treated it as a paid holiday if it fell during the week. That was a nice gesture.
It’s so popular that most non-Christians I know celebrate it in one form or another. My high school was about 60% Jewish, and Yom Kippur and Rosh Hoshanah were always official school days off.
Pretty much every culture has a holiday around the winter solstice time.
The Romans had Saturnalia, ancient Egypt had Birth of Heru (Horus), ancient Greeks had the Great Dionysia Festival, Jews had Hanukkah, Druids had the Winter Festival, the Celtic tribes had Yuletide, etc.
And many new religions just carried on the holidays, renaming them or re-defining them to honor the latest god they were celebrating. Christianity just kind of did the same; Christ was not actually born at Christmas time, for example, it is just celebrated then. (Rather like the British Empire has a Queen’s Birthday celebration in June, months away from Queen Elizabeth’s actual birthday.)
I like Christmas. I don’t worship the Baby Jesus (or any other mythical creature), but the secular Christmas spirit is a nice thing to have around once a year. Besides, we don’t have enough holidays, and shopping is always better afterwards.
Just to add Thanksgiving has been established nationally to give thanks to our Heavenly Father. So Christmas is not the only national holiday directly that has to do with God.
It’s surprisingly recent for people who imagine that Christmas was a governmentally sanctioned holiday back to the colonial days (and I suspect there are a lot of those). In 1856, my great-grandfather was alive, so it’s not that far away for me, either.
At any rate, I have no objection to Christmas being a national holiday - people aren’t going to show up to work anyway (I grew up in Pennsylvania, where the first day of deer season was a school holiday for much the same reason).
There are exactly zero national holidays in the United States. Congress can create federal holidays—days that federal government offices are closed. But that means nothing for private employers or state government offices. They can choose whether to give their employees the same days off or not.
Nothing is so sacred in Australia as the sanctity of a holiday long weekend and so we have Good Friday and Easter Monday as gazetted public holidays in all states.
I am very surprised to learn that Easter isn’t celebrated in the US given it’s arguably a more significant day in the Christian calendar than Christmas.