For those of you following along, you can comment here. That includes dead players.
No spoilers in here.
NO ACTIVE PLAYERS MAY READ THIS THREAD!.
What about sub list players?
And the first thing I’m going to do is an impassioned beg for subs.
C’mon. I need 2 now. Anyone? Anyone?
Any sub list players can post here.
Seriously?
Didn’t the game start two days ago?
Sheeesh.
Sorry maybe in another week or two I’ll be able to sub but in the mean time I’m hooked up. Still I’m following along, kind of.
If your only other option is a modkill, I’ll sub.
But I’m really short on time nowadays, so I will not be able to participate much.
We’ll see…I hate forcing people’s hands, it never goes well.
Thanks. I’m going to have to take you up on that offer.
You can take me off the sub list. I don’t think I quite grasp this game. I’m not comfortable playing a game without knowing the rules.
I’ll sub in if you need it.
The forbidden thread tells me nothing!!! I’m still dead.
Gotcha.
Before I officially get spoilered, I want to say that I’m not seeing the cases against Allwalker here. At all.
His statements are completely reasonable and are the way I would have interpreted things.
Meeko’s attacks scream newbie, regardless of alignment. And based on how he’s wording his attacks and some other comments he’s made, I’m not thinking newbie Town.
BillMC I don’t get an alignment read from, but his case against Allwalker is bad. I could see BillMC being scum, and Meeko overzealously aligning himself with a fellow scum before his mates could reign him in.
Thanks. I need a sub for GuyIncognitto; PM in transit.
No offense when you read this Meeko, but quit with the wild, baseless speculation and play the game. I’d be lynching you just to cut down on the noise. You’ve analyzed Pedescribe ten times more than you’ve analyzed anybody actually playing the game!
Picky picky. 
I couldn’t believe the level of rules analysis; I’m almost glad to be dead. There was a heavy level of “WTF” in that discussion. I’m hoping that it turns out to be an insidious scum plot to confuse the issue, as then it would at least make sense.
That’s the only logical explanation I could think of. So it would be ‘kill Meeko because he’s noisy or because he’s scum trying to be confusing’.
Some of those theories he’s bouncing around are quite bizarre.
I’m following along, I just have no feeling about who is a Sinner and who a Blackheart.
What an incredibly devious game setup! Think it was pure chance that scum managed to get a power role on the first go? I also wonder why combine the doctor role with the (de)conversion role in one player? Seems pretty risky. I can’t decide if that means there are fewer roles/less powerful roles for town than typical, or if there are more roles/powerful roles than typical.