I’m not a baseball fan, but certainly have heard of Derek Jeter. He’s going out after 20 years on a high note. I like this sendoff video.
How will he rank among the greats in baseball? I assume he’s headed for the Hall of Fame?
I’m not a baseball fan, but certainly have heard of Derek Jeter. He’s going out after 20 years on a high note. I like this sendoff video.
How will he rank among the greats in baseball? I assume he’s headed for the Hall of Fame?
ABC report gives more information.
Never heard of him.
Quite a record.
Yup. He’s probably going in on his first ballot.
Definitely.
First ballot Hall of Famers are the real Hall of Famers. Everyone else in the HOF are merely great.
There’s no way this season is a high note. The farewell tour is nice but it’s been a pretty miserable season for both him and the Yankees.
And yes, he’s a first round HOF’er.
Relatively miserable for him. Well below average but not miserable. Last year when he only played in 17 games was miserable. At least he didn’t go out riding the bench.
The Yankees are in serious trouble. In the past 20 years they have been successful with a blend of home grown talent and well placed free agents and trades. Lately they have had mediocre farm system talent and manage to pick up free agents right after they peak. Combine that with lots of bad luck with injuries and you get what you have now.
In the case of Jeter, you have to ignore the statistics, because he was much more than a package of statistics. He is one of the rare players who brought intangibles to a level of greatness.
Statistically, here is a list of the ten players who came closest to Jeter, according to a complicated “similarity score” formula worked out by Bill James:
Craig Biggio (823)
Paul Molitor (805) *
Roberto Alomar (789) *
Robin Yount (786) *
Charlie Gehringer (756) *
Johnny Damon (729)
Ivan Rodriguez (723)
Joe Morgan (723) *
Ted Simmons (718)
Frankie Frisch (716) *
Personally, I am getting weary of the New York Yankees parading a player around every year doing a Farewell Tour (Rivera, then Jeter). Who will it be next year, A-Rod? Ichiro?
A-Rod would not get anywhere near the sort of reception that Jeter is getting on a farewell tour.
Jtur: Biggio has been on the ballot 2 years.
It’s not the Yankees. It’s MLB. Do you think the Yankees can force anyone to give their players gifts? There are few players that have that kind of universal respect. It just so happens it was the Yankees two years in a row. Before that it was Chipper Jones and Cal Ripkin. It is certainly not a Yankee thing.
I tend to be very skeptical of “intangibles”. In the case of Jeter, ISTM that his “intangibles” are:
[ol]
[li]A lot of great teamates[/li][li]Not being a jerk[/li][/ol]
What else have you got?
Agreed.
Though, to be fair, he’s good statistically, just not as good as Yankee fans like to make him out to be. Jeter is 88th all time in Wins Above Replacement, which is actually fairly impressive. Though Adrian Beltre is 68th and is only 35… I wonder if we’ll have this sort of pomp and circumstance for him.
And A-Rod is 17th all time in WAR, though the juicing will hurt him (as it did with Bonds, 4th all time, and Clemens, 8th all time).
I’ve got that I hate the Yankees with a singular core passion, but I admire Jeter every time I see him play and I wish he played for somebody else.
But that also applies to, for example, Paul O’Neill, but I don’t have any pretension that he’s better than his stats.
There are hundreds of intangibles in the field that do not reflect statistically. Knowing when you can advance to second on a ball in the dirt that the catcher blocks, and thus avoid a double play on the next hitter, that’s an intangibie that does not show up in the stats. Except for the GIDP totals for the following batter, and make him the “great player” that surrounds our star with intangibles. Being positioned in the field so the batter chooses not to try to pull the ball, that’s an intangible that’s not in the stats. Outfielders with a great arm have no assists, but they hold a hundred runners. That’s an intangible.
The difference between a .250 hitter and a .300 hitter is one hit a week. A player who, once a week, benefits his team with an intangible, has offset the difference between batting .250 and batting .300.
I agree to that. The difficult part is identifying who has those intangibles, since they are not measured statistically.
What I’m saying is that since Jeter has been parts of winning teams for a long time, and has come off as a pretty decent person, people like to attribute to him these intangibles, even if there may be little basis for doing so.
Some of the tributes to Jeter have been great. I enjoy this video and ‘Re2pect’ was even better. It’s also gone over the top, sure- just as it did with Mariano Rivera, who was also an all-time great. This is going to happen with every retiring great player from now on, I guess, which will only get more ridiculous. And it could be embarrassing because if the Yankees don’t improve next year they might have to bring him back just so he can retire all over again to keep the fans interested. As far as his intangibles, I think this is instructive: a lot has been made of Jeter’s clutch qualities, and he provides a nice illustration of what a clutch player actually looks like. His career batting average is .309 in the regular season. In the playoffs it’s… .308. On base percentage: .377 regular season, .374 playoffs. Slugging percentage: .439 vs. .465. OPS: .817 vs. .838.
So basically, Jeter built his reputation as a clutch player by being about as good in the playoffs as he was in the regular season. That’s very good since in the playoffs you face better competition. And not that you can quantify this, but the guy does have a knack for memorable moments. There’s the 5-for-5 game that brought him his 3,000th hit, and then last night he hit a home run in the first game of his last homestand. It was only his fourth of the year, and his first at Yankee Stadium.
I agree in general with the last sentence, but it’s not so simple. Because it’s possible that the Yankees tended to get into the postseason more often when Jeter was in his prime.
You need to compare his numbers in the postseason against his numbers in the regular season for those same years.
Stick around long enough and you’ll have a lot of memorable moments. Also a lot of non-memorable moments, but people will remember the memorable moments more, on account of them being memorable.