Disney Animated Movie Madness ROUND TWO!

The Game Room
21

My choices are again highlighted in red.

  1. Cinderella

  2. The Sword in the Stone

  3. The Emperor’s New Groove (2nd round bye)

  4. Bambi

  5. 101 Dalmatians (I’d really appreciate it if you spell this one correctly if it survives to compete in the next round)

  6. Lilo and Stitch – although I’d like to see both eliminated

  7. The Rescuers

  8. Sleeping Beauty

  9. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

  10. Dumbo (2nd Round Bye)

  11. The Little Mermaid

  12. The Great Mouse Detective

12 Hercules
21 The Jungle Book

2 Beauty and the Beast
31 The Aristocats

  1. Robin Hood (2nd round bye)

  2. Mulan

  3. Fantasia

  4. Pinocchio (note spelling of this one as well)

  5. Brother Bear

  6. Aladdin

  7. Meet the Robinsons

  8. Peter Pan (2nd round bye)

  9. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

  10. The Fox and the Hound

  11. The Lion King

  12. Saludos Amigos

22 
  1. Cinderella

33. The Sword in the Stone

  1. The Emperor’s New Groove (2nd round bye)
  2. Bambi
    25. 101 Dalmations

9. Lilo and Stitch
24. The Rescuers

  1. Sleeping Beauty
    29. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

  2. Dumbo (2nd Round Bye)

5. The Little Mermaid
37. The Great Mouse Detective

12 Hercules
21 The Jungle Book

2 Beauty and the Beast
31 The Aristocats

  1. Robin Hood (2nd round bye)

7. Mulan
26. Fantasia

10. Pinnochio
23. Brother Bear

3. Aladdin
30. Meet the Robinsons

  1. Peter Pan (2nd round bye)

6. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
38. The Fox and the Hound

11. The Lion King
43. Saludos Amigos

23 
  1. Cinderella

  2. The Emperor’s New Groove (2nd round bye) (WTF?!?!)

  3. Bambi

  4. Lilo and Stitch

  5. Sleeping Beauty

  6. Dumbo (2nd Round Bye)

  7. The Little Mermaid

21 The Jungle Book

2 Beauty and the Beast
18. Robin Hood (2nd round bye)
26. Fantasia

  1. Pinnochio

  2. Aladdin

  3. Peter Pan (2nd round bye)

  4. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

  5. The Lion King

24

Cinderella
Emporer’s New Groove (This movie stunk up and down. how on earth is it getting a bye and some other way more deserving movies aren’t going to make it to round 3?)
Bambi
Lilo and Stitch
Sleeping Beauty
Dumbo
Little Mermaid
Jungle Book (Hercules has 1 good song. One. That is its only redeeming feature - the rest of the movie is awful.)
Beauty and the Beast
Robin Hood
Mulan
Pinnochio
Aladdin
Peter Pan
Snow White
The Lion King

25

Heretic! :wink:

Seriously, it’s one of my favorite recent Disney flicks. I find the way that it is continually refusing to take itself seriously thoroughly charming and endlessly amusing. But I can enjoy watching it again, where some of the other films that have made it this far are totally cringe-inducing for me.

26

  1. The Sword in the Stone

  2. The Emperor’s New Groove (2nd round bye)

  3. Bambi

  4. Lilo and Stitch

  5. Sleeping Beauty

  6. Dumbo (2nd Round Bye)

  7. The Little Mermaid

21 The Jungle Book

2 Beauty and the Beast

  1. Robin Hood (2nd round bye)

  2. Fantasia

  3. Pinnochio

  4. Aladdin

  5. Peter Pan (2nd round bye)

  6. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

  7. The Lion King

27

Choices are in blue. (Because voting in blue is the only real way to vote! :stuck_out_tongue: )

28

dotchan, I agree that the Stitch spin offs all sucked yak semen out of donkeys, they sucked that badly.

But the movie Lilo and Stitch is much, much better, and well worth viewing.

29

  1. Cinderella

  2. The Sword in the Stone

  3. The Emperor’s New Groove (2nd round bye)

  4. Bambi

  5. 101 Dalmations

  6. Lilo and Stitch

  7. The Rescuers

  8. Sleeping Beauty

  9. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

  10. Dumbo (2nd Round Bye)

  11. The Little Mermaid

  12. The Great Mouse Detective

12 Hercules
21 The Jungle Book

2 Beauty and the Beast
31 The Aristocats

  1. Robin Hood (2nd round bye)

  2. Mulan

  3. Fantasia

  4. Pinnochio

  5. Brother Bear

  6. Aladdin

  7. Meet the Robinsons

  8. Peter Pan (2nd round bye)

  9. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

  10. The Fox and the Hound

  11. The Lion King

  12. Saludos Amigos

30

Cinderella

The Emperor’s New Groove (2nd round bye)

101 Dalmations

The Rescuers

Sleeping Beauty

Dumbo (2nd Round Bye)

The Little Mermaid

The Jungle Book

Beauty and the Beast

Robin Hood (2nd round bye)

Fantasia

Pinnochio

Aladdin

Peter Pan (2nd round bye)

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

The Lion King

31

I second what OtakuLoki wrote. Don’t judge Lilo & Stitch by the sequels. The original movie was great. In my opinion it was the last great movie Disney has made.

32

I agree. At least the last great movie in that animation style, anyway.

33
  1. Cinderella
  2. The Emperor’s New Groove (2nd round bye)
  3. 101 Dalmations
  4. The Rescuers
  5. Sleeping Beauty
  6. Dumbo (2nd Round Bye)
  7. The Great Mouse Detective
    21 The Jungle Book
    31 The Aristocats
  8. Robin Hood (2nd round bye)
  9. Fantasia
  10. Pinnochio
  11. Aladdin
  12. Peter Pan (2nd round bye)
  13. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
  14. The Lion King
34

  1. The Sword in the Stone

  2. The Emperor’s New Groove (2nd round bye)

  3. Bambi

  4. The Rescuers

  5. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh (Likely won’t win, but I dislike the ‘disny-fi-cation’ of many classics, the opposing movie being one of them)

  6. Dumbo (2nd Round Bye)

  7. The Great Mouse Detective
    21 The Jungle Book
    31 The Aristocats (Tough choice in a different way- didn’t really like either)

  8. Robin Hood (2nd round bye)

  9. Mulan (Underdog power, activate!)

  10. Pinnochio

  11. Aladdin

  12. Peter Pan (2nd round bye)

  13. The Fox and the Hound

  14. The Lion King

35

  1. The Sword in the Stone (wow, no contest over the #1 seed!)

  2. 101 Dalmations

  3. Lilo and Stitch (crap beats crappier)

  4. Sleeping Beauty

  5. The Little Mermaid

12 Hercules

2 Beauty and the Beast

  1. Fantasia (man that was tough, but I have to give the edge to the movie that affected my life)

  2. Pinnochio

  3. Aladdin

  4. The Fox and the Hound

  5. The Lion King

36

So I take it we just pick one in each bracket?

{{

  1. Cinderella (This is an edit, the more I thought about it, the more I decidedly do NOT like sword in the stone when I watch it nowadays)

  2. The Emperor’s New Groove (2nd round bye)

  3. 101 Dalmations

  4. Lilo and Stitch

  5. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

  6. Dumbo (2nd Round Bye)

  7. The Little Mermaid

12 Hercules
(To be honest, I actually like the story of the Jungle Book more, as it doesn’t screw up Greek Mythology, but I like the music in Hercules so I’m tilting it up)

2 Beauty and the Beast

  1. Robin Hood (2nd round bye)

  2. Mulan

  3. Pinnochio

  4. Aladdin

  5. Peter Pan (2nd round bye)

  6. The Fox and the Hound (this one was really tough…)

  7. The Lion King
    }}
    Go ahead, try and find a pattern in my voting, I dare ya, I sure can’t.

37

Cinderella

101 Dalmations

Lilo and Stitch

Sleeping Beauty

The Little Mermaid

The Jungle Book

Beauty and the Beast

Fantasia

Pinnochio

Meet the Robinsons

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

The Lion King

38 
  1. Cinderella

  2. The Emperor’s New Groove (2nd round bye)

  3. 101 Dalmations

  4. The Rescuers

  5. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

  6. Dumbo (2nd Round Bye)

  7. The Great Mouse Detective

21 The Jungle Book

31 The Aristocats

  1. Robin Hood (2nd round bye)

  2. Mulan

  3. Pinnochio

  4. Aladdin

  5. Peter Pan (2nd round bye)

  6. The Fox and the Hound

  7. The Lion King

39
  1. Cinderella
  2. The Emperor’s New Groove (2nd round bye)
  3. 101 Dalmations
  4. Lilo and Stitch
  5. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh
  6. Dumbo (2nd Round Bye)
  7. The Little Mermaid
    21 The Jungle Book
    31 The Aristocats
  8. Robin Hood (2nd round bye)
  9. Fantasia
  10. Pinnochio
  11. Meet the Robinsons
  12. Peter Pan (2nd round bye)
  13. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
  14. The Lion King
40

1. Cinderella
[del]33. The Sword in the Stone[/del]
Tougher than some might thinnk

17. The Emperor’s New Groove (2nd round bye)
BOOM, Baby!

8. Bambi
[del]25. 101 Dalmations[/del]
A seminal work versus a not-great adaptation… Bambi wins.

9. Lilo and Stitch
[del]24. The Rescuers[/del]
Lilo and Stich saved Disney animation post Lion King.

4. Sleeping Beauty
[del]29. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh[/del]
The sentimental favorite unfortunately gets paired with the greatest ever.

13. Dumbo (2nd Round Bye)

5. The Little Mermaid
[del]37. The Great Mouse Detective[/del]
Menken and Ashman bring the Broadway musical to a new world.

[del]12 Hercules[/del]
21 The Jungle Book
The Jungle Book is not the best adaptation, but Hercules was just plain bad.

2 Beauty and the Beast
[del]31 The Aristocats[/del]
Beauty and the Beast could beat The Aristocats even by a long-distance call from a Fiji vacation while drunk, getting a massage and sending the instructions through the massuer, who, despite not speaking English, would still be able to lay a massive beat-down on that crap movie via phone.

18. Robin Hood (2nd round bye)
lucky

[del]7. Mulan[/del]
26. Fantasia
Mulan wasn’t exactly bad, but true art should beat a relative yawn-fest any day of the week and twice on Sundays.

10. Pinnochio
[del]23. Brother Bear[/del]
Pinnochio has its own scary ride at Disneyland. Brother Bear doesn’t actually exist.

3. Aladdin
[del]30. Meet the Robinsons[/del]
Really, the battle is for the fourth spot in the final four.

19. Peter Pan (2nd round bye)

6. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
[del]38. The Fox and the Hound[/del]
How in Og’s name did both The Aristocats AND The Fox and the Hound get anywhere beyond a prison cell?
Both are such unmitigated dreck it’s an insult to Treasure Planet that we even acknowledge them as animated features.

11. The Lion King
[del]43. Saludos Amigos[/del]
I love the song, but the movie ain’t great. Adios.