Just finished it (on tape; was elsewhere earlier).
And, um, not to nitpick, but… Did anything actually happen in the show?
I mean, there was a lot of running around, and Cap’n looking manly, and the copious shooting of ray guns (and no I am not going there) and Trip bein’ disturbed and Travis not sayin’ a freakin’ word and yet another dark murky location in which dumbass Cap’n gets trapped and needs to be rescued again (Rocky: “A-gaaiiiin?”) and a bunch of aliens with bumpy foreheads and did anything actually happen?
What do we learn? Weird stuff happens in the Delphic Expanse. Check. We knew that going in. So maybe we haven’t had any “anatomically inverted” people, even though in last year’s season finale we were told a shipload of Vulcans hadn’t been in the Expanse more than a couple of hours before they’d gone all Aerosmith-in-a-hotel-room on each other, whereas Archer and crew have been there six whole weeks (according the clumsiest exposition scene yet, and that’s saying something: “Hey Malcolm, I’m gonna ask you some really obvious questions so we can catch the audience up. Just stand there and act surly”) and the only thing that’s happened is they’ve got a pile of boxes zooming back and forth in a cargo bay like they’re trying to convince JoBeth Williams not to pull her daughter out of that glowing closet. New information? Nope.
Okay, so what did they accomplish? Their whole objective is that they want to find the Xindi homeworld. They have a lead on a guy. They track him down but it doesn’t go well and he dies and what he tells them seems promising but they go there and what they find doesn’t actually tell them anything. So off they go, back to square one. By the way, a question: They travel at warp five. They get from the mine planet to what they think will be the homeworld pretty quickly. Then Archer says, “Let’s go deeper.” (Which makes me think of Jurgen Prochnow in Das Boot — “Tiefer… tiefer…”) How far are they in now, anyway? Is there any consistency to the stellar geography (to mix my terms)?
But we’re not done yet: we gotta have the panda. I laughed at “please disrobe,” but I was rolling my eyes at the same time.
Oh, and Malcolm’s still an insecure whiner, which is getting really old, since it’s his only real character dimension. One of these days Archer is going to order him to place a security detail around his own self-esteem so he doesn’t lose control of it entirely.
Anyway, I guess I’m wondering what, exactly, was accomplished in this episode? The only things that were different about this show, the only stuff we hadn’t seen already, were (1) the space marines, who were kind of eh, and (2) the alien council, which was kind of eh? At least the alien council scene gives us the sense that the writers actually have a plot point they’ll be driving toward this season, the lack of which has been one of my biggest complaints, so the reassurance that they aren’t just makin’ this shit up as they go is in my opinion a very good thing. But the aliens’ design just isn’t very creatively inspiring: Otter guy? Manatee dude? And a big freakin’ bug? Convergent evolution, anybody? There better be a rockin’ cool explanation for this.
Bottom line: Tonally, interesting, with the kind of dark, grungy feeling that’s been missing from Trek since DS9, but the characters are still lacking, and I fail to see what they’re driving at in terms of the new arc. But the fact that they seem to actually have something in mind is enough to keep me hanging on for another couple of weeks.
We’ll see if I make it through the insane zombie Vulcans, though. :rolleyes: