I was hoping someone would admit to being one of these people. Darn.
Yes, it happens all the time, indirectly or directly. By directly, I mean what everyone else has said. “It’s not that bad! Smile!” or “You’d look so much better if you’d smile just a little!” After a long day of work, I got on a bus and the bus driver took the liberty of touching my forehead and telling me “smooth out those lines”. I keep my brow crunch up like that constantly. So telling me to smooth it out requires me to actually think about which muscle groups need to be coordinated (plus, she had no right to touch me like that, but whatever).
By indirectly, I’ve had people come up to me and say “What’s wrong?” There’s this one co-worker who seems to enjoy coming to my office and telling me, no matter what time of day it is, how “tired” I look, even when I’m primed up with energy and feeling great. And the thing is, SHE’S the one who always looks tired, with a face that’s to’ up from the flo’ up. But of course, because she’s not a stranger and I want to keep the peace, I just say, “I’m actually feeling fine today, but thanks for your concern.” But it peeves me out.
Another time, I was once riding an elevator and a jerk of a co-worker (who’s been written up for sexual harassment before) was in there with me, and he exclaimed, “Damn, you look sick! How much more weight are you going to lose!” I was so flabbergasted (didn’t even know I had lost all that much weight) all I could say was that I wasn’t sick, I just walk a lot. But I kept thinking, “What if I WAS sick, like with terminal cancer? What an inconsiderate thing to say to someone!”
If you’re very close to someone, then you’re in the “zone” to be able to negatively comment on someone’s looks, and even then it better be pretty damn tactful. But if you’re just another face on the office floor, I don’t want hear a damn thing out of you about my looks except for maybe, “Girl, you got it going on today!” Telling me I look tired when I don’t feel tired is just going to make me feel weird, at best, and make me feel childishly defensive at worse (“I might look tired, but at least I’m not UGLY like you are!”)