Face Off, Season 4 (SyFy Series)

(Episode 5: Two Heads Are Better Than One**)**

Well, that was certainly the least surprising winner and elimination they’ve ever had.

When Eric F. was first talking about his concept, I thought “Ambitious…way too ambitious for you. You’re going to be fucked come Last Looks”. Color me way wrong – they killed this one. The foam heads lacked a little detail (the whitewash eyes weren’t a good choice), but other than that, that was an awesome design.

Jenna has needed to go for weeks now – if you can’t sculpt, then you have no business being there. Sucks, and I feel bad for her, but she can’t keep dragging others down with her like that.

The giants were my favorite so far this season. Nearly all the ideas were super creative and challenging. That 10ft giant was just amazing when you consider the limited time. Making that big actor look tiny and in the clutches of the giant was very cool.

I thought the idea of putting the heads on the giant’s feet was clever. There were execution problems. They looked a bit like fuzzy slippers from a distance. The judges didn’t seem to understand that this was supposed to be a comic character. Like in Xena or Hercules. The bad guy characters in those shows were always a little funny and camp too. Just imagine those feet heads complaining and whining at the giant. I think the concept could work with some refining.

Yeah, we knew who would win, and who would lose, immediately. Basically, whomever got Jenna. Like the judges said, they were sorry that her problems interfered with her talent, but results are results. I just would have preferred that she step out last week, though.

It was interesting that in Anthony’s design, they praised the faces he made, but not the main head - which was done by someone else. I think they could have done better if the head in the back was moved up so that it was immediately apparent to the viewer.

Personally, I really liked when Eric F did his sketch on the floor. It immediately gave them the correct proportions, they knew what they had to do, and I think it helped focus their design.

And the little guy stabbing the giant’s hand was funny as hell :slight_smile:

A good episode. Next week, when its 9 contestants, it will be interesting to see if its an individual challenge, or 3 teams of 3.

Glenn is hosting and judging the Redemption challenges. He says they are competing for a chance to get cast on the next season. I guess they won’t get back into this season?? That surprised me.

I like the redemption challenge. It’s scaled back and they show how the face appliance / makeup process works.

http://www.syfy.com/videos/Face%20Off/Face%20Off%20Redemption

By the time we got to the final reveal, I had forgotten who had been working on which one (except for the best and worst one). When the judges were examining that one and they showed all the detail, I said “Wow, the two extra heads look amazing – too bad they didn’t put that much work into the actual main face. Oh, wait…this is the one where Anthony did the extras and Autumn did the main one. Never mind – main face was doomed from the start”.

I really, really, reallyreallyreally hope she gets the boot next week. Nothing she does is anything above amateurish.

This episode was definitely better than previous ones, in that it gives us hope that there might actually be meaningful competition near the end of the season, as opposed to Anthony just trouncing everyone.

And definitely not sad to see Jenna go. Not that there’s any real reason to think she would have been great shakes even at 100% health, but who knows?

Fun episode.

My immediate reaction when the pairings were announced: poor Megan, getting Jenna. Dammit Autumn got paired with Anthony, that means she’ll be safe. And then her remark about not having to worry and just coast irked me.

Anthony’s remark that Autumn was a strong player confused me. Did he mean opinionated? He made a remark about the best way to handle her was make her think she had more control than she did. Honestly that face wasn’t horrible, though the paint on the cleft was a bit dark and overemphasized it. But he did some shaping and finishing on that one as well as the details on the body.

Great faces on the torso, judges loved them. Think how that would have turned out with someone with actual skill working with Anthony. Also, when Autumn turned to the costume and let Anthony work on the paint I thought that was an excellent split of labor, and probably a judicious misdirect on Anthony’s part. Maybe he was afraid of the sewing machine, or maybe he just said that to give her something to do.

I immediately thought Eric F and Chris were biting off too much. Eric has that problem of overestimating the time and underestimating the work. They both worked fast and hard and were racing at the end to assemble at last looks, making up the costume on the fly. Not a good strategy, but they pulled it off amazingly. The concept was excellent, the scope of work was staggering, and the creativity of the little guy and the stabbing of the hand was neat. The sculpt of the heads was great. The eyes could have used some detail, and a bit more effort in costume might have been nice, but you could tell from the judges’ reactions they loved it. When they actually pulled it together, you knew the win was that team and Eric because it was his concept and execution down the line.

Eric is going to face the same risk that Roy did last season, going too big and not getting done. If he can pull it in just a smidge, he will put a strong challenge to Anthony.

Poor Megan. The concept wasn’t spectacular to begin with, but the double-stacked head was at least creatively unique as opposed to two heads side by side. But Jenna’s injuries combined with inadequate design on how to mold the head/cowl so it would stay on, and they were headed for disaster. There was some good work in the face lost because of the edges and fail on the second head attachment, and just general incompleteness. And then there were the problems with the molding and the poor design that didn’t allow separation and then didn’t go back together well. At least Jenna took the heat. It’s sad that she can’t perform because of injury, but there’s no room for someone who isn’t up to the work.

House and Wayne’s tree giant was pretty good. I think the torso/head looked a little too much like a puppet. I’m not sure, maybe putting structure in the torso to make it less bendy. Having the actor stand with a bit of a lean and sculpt the torso a bit to move the actor’s head to the side a bit and center the heads a bit. Nice work overall.

Alam and Eric Z, just dull. The heads on feet could have been a creative concept, but the sculpt and paint was way too cheesy for the look. They were crappy, and that design decision limited the form changes that the challenge presented. Doing multiple heads up high allows some dramatic work (supergiant with 2 heads most demonstrative). Having your giant look essentially like a person with a morphed face and big feet kinda seems lame, even if the paint work had been much better. The face sculpt was just blah, the feet were dreadful.

Maybe next week Autumn won’t be able to coast on someone else’s skill.

This was the least surprising and most deserved, both in the winner and loser. It was totally obvious way ahead of time who did the best and worst jobs. Sometimes the judging decision is hard, but not today.

I thought the heads on the feet was awful and kind of not in the spirit of what was asked. They were asked to do a multiple headed giant, not a giant that used heads for decoration. Of course, it wasn’t even in the same ballpark of bad as the Jenna and Megan, a no-brainer on who has to go, i was actually hopeful that Jenna would just throw herself on her sword, but it doesn’t matter.

Eric F’s concept was fantastic and Chris helped pull it off brilliantly, one of my favorite all-time makeup jobs. I liked Autumn and Anthony, granted the main face wasn’t showy, but I did get the sadness they wanted to convey. The tree giant was a fantastically done sculpt and pretty much only suffered from the fact it didn’t really convey giant-ness (being so wide).

Good episode without a lot of suspense.

Am I missing something? Did everyone abandon this thread?

I thought they made the absolute right choice 100% agree with what they said, the firefly was fantastic, but failed ultimately the challenge and couldn’t win. Alam’s design was simply a horrible mishmash of poorly executed ideas. I liked Eric F’s makeup in the initial challenge, but he seems to do a lot of mid-transformation type stuff, mouth or eyes growing on the side. Still the concept and execution were very strong.

Just not much to say about last night. I would really have loved to see the firefly with the required texture on it, and I’m glad that the judges let it slide and put him in the top looks and not the bottom, though I agree with their decision not to give him the win.

Alam’s makeup was bad, but that moth was worse, and Megan should have gone instead.

I was surprised to see such decent work from Autumn, though she didn’t do much.

Eric F’s breast/spider-leg may be the most disturbing thing I’ve seen on the show.

While I agree the moth was horrible, I think Alam’s was worse. Alam’s was an incoherent concept poorly executed. While Megan’s was a coherent concept poorly executed.

Yeah, I was pretty unenthused from this episode. It was interesting to watch, but nothing really worth commentary.

What surprised me was how average it was. Not that I was expecting better from Autumn based on her track record, but rather on how secretive the producers were being about her design. They didn’t give her any in-shop camera time this week. Nothing about her sculpt, they didn’t show what McKenzie’s father had to say, nothing during her build, application or last looks. It was like she wasn’t even on the show this week.

Because of all that, I was expecting the producers to be pulling a “So, you think Autumn sucks huh? Well wait till we spring this on you!” moment at the reveal. But nope, a perfectly middle-of-the-road effort that, as I think back on now, I couldn’t tell you one thing about other than it was based on a beetle (personally, I’d have put a mop-top wig on it*****).

And yes, Alam’s was far and away the worst. Megan didn’t know how to stop painting, but her execution wasn’t all that terrible otherwise. For her, anyway.

Is it just me, or does it seem like the guys are about 20 times superior to the women this season?

*****Ok, maybe not really…

Sorry, haven’t made it to this thread.

Dammit, how did Autumn manage not to screw this one up? I was actually impressed that her work was average and decent, not crap.

I’m glad Megan wasn’t booted over this. Her execution on this was mangled, but she had a coherent concept. Alam didn’t know what she was doing. Honestly, I didn’t get grasshopper out of anything she did. She made design choices with no justification, she didn’t complete things, and it just looked bad all around.

I also agreed with the judges on the top looks. The firefly was an awesome profile, great work on the wings, good lighting on the body, great head and face. Can you say brilliant placement for the true eyes hidden in the pockets by the mask eyes? Though I think the paint in that spot could have been better. And I agree that by forgetting the element he couldn’t win because he didn’t complete the challenge as stated. The winner was also very good work.

And the breast spider leg was pretty disturbing, as well as the transforming leg out of the butt.

I think the reason they didn’t show anything about Autumn’s work is that it was solidly safe but not exceptional in either direction. Thus, time constraints meant it was least useful to show. Focus on the highs and lows, and the folks who have consistent records.

The most distinctive thing about a grasshopper is its long jumpy back legs. I didn’t see that element at all on Alam’s design, so it didn’t really look like a grasshopper.

Forgot to mention Anthony. The judges were less than impressed with his work this time. The head wasn’t bad, I didn’t follow the “army ant” motif till he explained it. They didn’t like the chest sculpt and especially paint coloring. Okay.

I told Hubster the moth wing paint job looked like the inside of a spray paint booth. TERRIBLE!

The firefly was absolutely awesome!

And Anthony needs to get his butt in gear!
~VOW

About. Fricking. Time.

Later Autumn…been terrible having you here.

I hope there was a zombie walk scheduled nearby that day, otherwise that seemed like kind of a waste of a nice foundation challenge.

I don’t think I could have listened to her whiny voice for another week.