Facebook: The surprising fates of your old high school/college friends

I was thinking the other day about my best buddy, Scott. I met Scott in the Army in 1989 and we’ve been best friends almost ever since. If you had asked me, in my circle of friends, in about, say, 1991 which of us was going to be the most professionally successful I never would have guessed Scott, and probably nobody else - including Scott himself - would have guessed him. He’d dropped out of community college, tried to get into university as a mature student and gave up during the test course. He seemed doomed to a life as a grunt. He was about as successful with the ladies back then as the L.A. Clippers are with winning NBA championships. Pretty smart, but not so smart that he could coast on overwhelming intellect; the kind of guy who’d probably score 115, 120 on a properly administered IQ test. He was a great guy but going nowhere.

Today he’s a director or something like that for one of the biggest tech firms on the planet. He makes more in a year than I make in three, and I make very good money, so that’s saying something. He’s married to a beautiful, wonderful young woman. His problems with self confidence and pessimism are long behind him. He just completely turned his life around, entirely on his own.

On the other hand, in our circle of friends was this other guy, who I’ll call Dave, who was one of the smartest human beings I have ever known, if not THE smartest. He was going to one of Canada’s finest universities. He was a hard worker. For some reason, he never graduated. He drifted away.

As I started racking up contacts in Facebook, I noticed the same thing over and over. If I had recorded my predictions on how people’s lives would turn out I would have been about as accurate as just rolling dice to determine outcomes from random chance. This one guy was the most nerdy, stupid, ugly goofball you could imagine; he’s married now, two kids, owns a garage. This one girl I knew was gorgeous, popular, and as bright as you could ask; her command of English was astounding - I still remember a poem she wrote, and marvelling that a person could write so magnificently, wondering how it was possible. Her life seems to have kind of stalled, and she’s single. I can’t even tell if she has a job. Her two best friends are single too, mid-30s, and I don’t understand why, they’re all hot and nice people.

This one girl, I stood for her at her wedding. I’ve never seen a more perfect couple. Their marriage collapsed eight years later. My sister used to date this absolutely hopeless loser - we called him Pizza Boy - who was ugly and, frankly, pretty stupid, and he went back to college, got a good job, and is married and successful. I knew this guy in high school who was really smart, knew more about computers than my buddy who I first described; he’s never really accomplished much in life.

I knoew this other girl in school. I am telling you here and now I have never in my life seen a more naturally talented actor; and I’m someone who’s watched a great many productions and knows his way around a stage. This girl was astounding. Her talent was almost blinding; she could have waltzed through a successful life as an actress. After high school she never acted in a single thing again. She’s successful, but not the way I expected.

Then there was this other guy. He was a complete goofball who barely passed everything, did nothing, and had the motivation of a slug. He had stoner loser written all over him. Today he’s a successful technician in the television biz. He was a wife and a lovely new daughter.

Some people did what I figured they’d do - but to be honest, just as many are so dramatically far from what I would have expected that I must conclude, from my anecdotal evidence, that it is flatly impossible to tell a person’s future from what they’re like when they’re 18.

Do you notice the same thing?

A few weeks (or maybe longer) ago, one of my high school teachers died. There was a guestbook set up and after I posted to it, I saw that an old friend of mine had also posted, and it listed the name of his wife as well.

Then I made a huge mistake. I googled them. I picked her name because it was the less common of the two. I was hoping to find a website or something to get an email addy to say “hey.”

Instead, I found an article in a newspaper that said, paraphrased, “Friend’s wife name lured married men into affairs and then recorded them in order to blackmail them.”

I was a bit shocked, so I read the article and discovered that Friend’s wife shares the name with a fictional character. Yet, I’ve discovered that I’m terrified to look anyone else up. :smiley:

Well… yea, I figured that I hope my life wouldn’t turn out like my peers expected it when I was 18 (and it hasn’t!). Similarly, I wondered what future they were going to have, if it wasn’t going to be the “expected” one.

There was a classmate who was very independent, and thought herself a bit above the rest of the classmates… She got a full scholarship to study college out of the island, and took it. Everyone thought she would make it. It turned out she dropped out after one semester, while some of us who were not supposed to last outside the island instead thrived and continued.

Now that we are grown up too, some of my elementary and high school friends have come out of the closet, as I find them in Facebook. In most of those cases it was no surprise, more like “Finally!”, “I knew it!”, and “About time”…

I haven’t bothered to look on Facebook or the like since I don’t expect many from the class of '72 would be inclined to use it (tho I might be surprised.) But last month, I met 3 former classmates for dinner (the 4th got sick, but I still heard her stories.) What surprised me the most was that I was the only one married and with a kid. Two were divorced, two never married - they were all pretty outgoing back then while I was shy to the point of almost hiding from guys. On the other hand, I was the only one to leave the area, while none of them did (one is still living in the same house, which she inherited after her folks died.)

Sadly, at our stage of life, more and more classmates come up under the category of “Who died now?” Although there are a few “Wow, they’re still married??” which are the nice stories. But as far as I know, no one is famous or jailed… still, I may do a little googling, just because.

I’m probably a bit of a surprise to some people, in that I don’t think I was high on anyone’s “most likely to return to his home town” list.

Browsing through those from school who I hadn’t kept in contact with, there’s few where I hadn’t known what they were up to via friends or family, and there’s not much which comes as a shock. Our final primary school class photo has been put on the site, and there’s no real surprises so far, even though I’ve made contact with a few people I’d not been in touch with at all. There’s eleven people (out of a class of 25) of whom I know nothing about either on or offline.

You would be. Three of my friends on there are over 50. (Admittedly I’m related to all of them, but hey, they’ve got former classmates somewhere!)

Just looked in - there’s *one * guy supposedly from my school and my year. I don’t recognize the name. Oh well, I’m in there now.

I occasionally Google some of my friends’ names to see if they come up. What surprises me the most is how few of them I can locate - especially the ones who were academic whizzkids, were computer geniuses (back in the 80s), and just looked like they were on a steamtrain to success - surely there would be some mention of them online. I mean, if anyone looks up my name, it comes up all over the place, accurately showcasing my life and interests, so why aren’t my friends similarly locatable? It’s very odd.

There’s a provincial politician, quite well known, who has the same name as my best friend in high school. It’s not the same guy, but every time I see him mentioned, I wonder…

:: sraches facebook twice for names recalled from public school ::

No matches. Oh well.

Variations in names might be something to do with it. Tom might now only be Thomas, someone else might have started using their middle name or including their middle initial, etc. If they’d been doing this for 10 years, then probably anything online refers to them.
I did a few random tests, none with particularly unusual names (unlike mine, where every Google result refers to me):

Friend 1, always been in regular contact - first result is the ‘about us’ page of her employer, and the photo of her is the same as her Facebook profile picture (how original :stuck_out_tongue: )

Friend 2, occassional contact but not on Facebook - had to try two variations of his name, the second gave his Facebook profile, so I’ve added him

Friend 3, regular contact - an author with the same name swamps the results, but her Friendster profile appears on the third page

Friend 4, no contact since school - I think one or two pages might refer to him, but I’m not sure, there’s nothing concrete and clearly several people with that name.
What conclusions can be drawn? No bloody idea. :slight_smile:

I don’t use facebook. I have found some of my high school friends on the net, however. Some fates are surprising - others not. I admit a certain wicked enjoyment after discovering that a girl that graduated ahead of me in class rankings by taking “basket weaving” type classes did not go very far in life. Maybe she is happy & I really do hope so. She just never did anything to deserve the accolade & it shows.

Coincidentally, I was just doing this last night. I graduated in 1999, so we’re all 8 years out. What’s surprising to me is just how boring most people’s life courses have turned out to be. I hoped for a few big surprises–maybe one of the really unpopular, underachieving kids would be super successful and married to a hottie, or one of the stoner kids would be a college grad without any kids. But no, just about everyone has ended up where you would expect them to. The smart kids went to college, graduated, and now have neat jobs and stable personal lives, and the underachievers and stoners all still live in town, work in menial jobs, have kids out of wedlock, post pictures of marijuana leaves on their profiles. Sad.

The best stories I’ve found are about the kids who were gay and closeted in high school but have since come out, moved to a city, and restarted their lives. It was a very conservative place to grow up, so I’m not surprised that there were gay kids living their lives in fear and misery at my high school. :frowning: However, I am a bit surprised about who turned out to be gay, and I find myself wishing I’d been closer to some of them. Maybe a good friend would have helped. I’m glad to see that so many of them have worked things out by now.

I never really get many surprises when it comes to former classmates… except the deaths. I have a classmate whose brother (brother played clarinet in my high school band, he played trumpet) was killed a year or two ago in an automobile accident. The poor guy lost his father when he was 7, and how his brother is gone.

His Facebook profile is public, looks like he’s living a happy drunken frat-boy lifestyle and apparently we graduated in the same class from the same university as well. I graduated two years late, so it’s weird we graduated at the same time… guess he needed time off to grieve.

I have generally found that there are not many surprises when it comes to former classmates. The ones that did poorly continue to do poorly, the ones that did well continue to do well. I am probably not much of a surprise either, except maybe that I’m taking longer than originally planned to get all of the education I plan to get.

Not too many surprises for me, so far (not that I trust everything people have written in their profiles, or equate them with un/happiness. For example, at my age, the wedding albums are just a little creepy). Some anorexic girls succumbed to genetics, some unattractive people shaped up and/or got electrolysis. There are a few lawyers i didn’t expect, but there’s really no way to know who is happy and who isn’t.

I’m not that far out of graduating from high school (2002) or college, so there’s not a ton of change going on. Some people did surprise me with the “oh, they’re gay” or “oh, they got married” factor, but I’m still young enough that things aren’t a huge surprise.

This should tie in with the When did you realize you are an adult thread.

I went to my 20th high school reunion this summer. I was surprised by how small the turn out was overall. I’d say less than 25%

It was sad to hear a few had died of illness, and two car accidents.

The neatest thing was one fellow who I knew OK from school. His Dad’s buisness was floundering and begged him to help out after law school. He never did practice law but the party migrated to his 2 million dollar yacht. An extraordinary evening.

My favorite story that I’ve told here more than once is the smart, pretty, friendly cheerleader who graduated second in the class. She realized during her residency to become a doctor that she hates people. She is now on staff for the LA County coroners office, lives within sight of the beach and can wear flip flops every day of the year.

The people I really want to know how they turned out are the ones nobody has heard from.

Give it a few more years. Eight years out of high school I was in a dead-end job that was actually a lot better paying than all my previous dead-end jobs, and I wasn’t doing anything with my degree, but now, almost twenty-five years out, I have a great job and get paid a lot of money.
Hope I’m still in good shape at all subsequent phases of my life.

Wow, apparently I’ve failed at life. I had no idea.

I’ll definitely keep checking in over the years, what with the internet giving away all of our private lives these days. :stuck_out_tongue: I hope to see many more successful people coming from my hometown. It was a decent high school, but a town that’s just stuck in the backwoods. It seems to me, from anecdotal experience, that those who leave town (or better yet, leave the state) for more than a year or two end up more successful and more worldly. Those who stay end up divorced at 22, pumping gas, and using food stamps to feed their unplanned kids. It’s fear of the outside world that keeps them there, fear of having to live without mom and dad around to maintain their standard of living. But little by little, they just sink in deeper and deeper, before they realize just how much harder life is in a town with no opportunities.

So yeah, I think that if I give people more time, there will come a time when more of them are doing well in life. But right now, it makes me feel kind of sad.

(Full disclosure on myself, so I don’t come across as an ass: I do have a BA, which took me five years to get. No surprise to my classmates, though some might have expected me to be more successful by now. I’m getting a second Bachelor’s degree in nursing now, since I want to do something more rewarding/lucrative. Big surprise–I think people would expect me to do something more stereotypically brainy. I’ve spent my life since high school in big cities, no big surprise there. I’m married, though, which I think would come across as a surprise. Since I was a big nerd, you know.)

I’ve been resisting facebook for a long time. I finally signed up last week. It’s amazing the shock.

I was class of 1998, so it’s been almost exactly 10 years.

First of all, the girl I was in love with between 7th and 12th grade, but who I never saw or heard from again after graduation moved to Virginia and got married. Sure, I see PLENTY of people from my school are married, but that was the dagger through my heart.

It turns out that two people from my class are married to EACH OTHER…which isn’t shocking by itself (despite the unwritten rule in my high school that students from the same grade and school could NOT date each other) except that as far as I could tell, they barely even KNEW each other back then, let alone were on friendly terms.

On a related note, it’s also kind of weird seeing who is on whose friends list, since there are lots of people that I know didn’t like each other back then who are now listed as friends. I have a policy of not friending people I don’t actually like, so I’m not sure if some of them simply friended every name they recognized (so far, nobody has friended me. I’ve been sending all the invitations, and all but 3 have been accepted).

Aside from some interesting moves (one girl I used to know is living in Australia now), nothing too scocking yet. Of course, one of the problems with facebook is you can’t read most peoples profiles until you’re already friends.