Fluiddruid, respectfully, you are mistaken

This is directed only to the mod, and not the poster, who had the good sense to the in the last word and move on.

I am not sure you read the post I was responding to. That seems a fair conclusion because all his post consisted of was calling me an “idiot” (a far more ancient insult) for posting my opinion that the confederate flag represented slavery, racism and treason (not in that order). This guy had more posts than most human beings live days, and he did not appear to know or care about this rule I didn’t see. Why no chastisement of him? Please don’t tell me you are going to buy “people with your opinion” is not a personal insult. And I no more hijacked the thread than he did. Apparently casting The First Stone is allowed, but The Second Stone isn’t? You didn’t even bother to tell both of us to know it off, but simply played favorites.

I didn’t drag out every old joke in book, and not everyone has had the dis/pleasure of hearing Gunnery Sgt. Hartman. I got in what? Three or four.

Had someone done this to me in a social setting, I would have invited him to apologize just as loudly. If he refused that, you’d better believe he would have heard more than a few choice jokes taking, what, 20 seconds? It would have gone on at least an hour, or until he left.

Now, I may very well be an idiot, as is often pointed out to me by my betters. But they had better be prepared to take what they dish out.

Now I have carefully considered your chastisement, and provisionally, it appears to me (assuming you read everything) to be outside the rules and nothing short of favoritism for a poster I strongly doubt complained, as he ended it with the last word on my atrocious spelling. After all, we both spoke the truth, and many hold the opinion that I am an idiot. Most have the good sense and manners not to call someone an idiot in a public place, even if it is true. So, I must very humbly and respectfully ask you to take the chastisement and reconsider it and put it in a dark place where no decent person is likely to see it.

If you are not prepared to justify this disparate treatment, or withdraw it, I want to assure you that if anyone insults me first, I will give them the verbal beat down they deserve, even if they are a favorite, and even if it gets me banned. In the absence of a logical justification, which I assume will be forthcoming, I have to ignore your well meant chastisement of yours truly. “Not even in the face of Armageddon. Never compromise.” Alan Moore, Rorschach.
Incidentally, people who in the distant past who have been called, “idiots”, “morons”, “cretins”, “retards”, etc. have asked to be called “developmentally challenged”.

For those who want to know what the hell this is all about, here is the relevant post in context.

The Second Stone, when you start a thread about another thread, or about a particular post, it’s generally considered good form to provide a link, so that every other fucker on the Board doesn’t have to go searching to understand what you’re complaining about.

Insults may be allowed but just using a series of insults with no rationale seems a bit weird. I can’t see what the Mod did wrong.

I can’t see what he did right.

Lib called him an idiot; he called Lib a shitstain back. This is the Pit; it’s what we do here.

Come on, this is bullshit.

Regards,
Shodan

I think the insults were dumb, but I don’t see how it violated the pit, either.

Daniel

Calling posters names is tolerated, but to use a series of insults seems to me somehow absurd. We may have to differ Shodan.

Look, calling someone an idiot for their opinion is fine. It’s not the insults that are the problem. But just responding to someone calling you an idiot with a bunch of unoriginal, parroted joke-book insults was stupid and distracting. It’s a thread hijack.

We’re adults here. If someone calls you an idiot, saying “I’m rubber and you’re glue” and reciting a bunch of yo-mamma jokes is retarded. Call them an idiot back if you want to, but don’t just cut and paste a bunch of stupid insults in a discussion. It’s dumb. If you want to have a thread where you just insult each other back and forth – with no reference to their argument at all – Pit the poster in question.

Do so within the forum guidelines or you will be warned, suspended, or banned.

Wait–so insults in the pit need to be nonstupid? Dang, that’s gonna cut things down.

I think it’s a stretch to call his post a hijack: it was a one-off response to someone being insulting to him. If it’d been GD, I could see treating it (or its equivalence) as a hijack. But in the pit, dumbass insults are super-common; I thought the initial point of the pit was to channel the dumbass insults here so they don’t infect other forums.

Daniel

I just can’t believe Liberal reported someone for insulting him in the pit.

Because they are super common does it justify them?

Yes, brainiac, at least so far as showing that they are allowed.

More out of the blue moderation by fluiddruid in the BBQ Pit. She just seems so clueless about the place, I really can’t understand why this was made her main purview. Shouldn’t she be an MPSIMS mod or something?

Because they are allowed justifies them. Thanks, I see your long suit is logic.

He claims he didn’t, but then you may know him better than I do.

Fine, ignore the “so far as” bit. Any reason they need “justification”, whatever that means to you?

You post a lot! Your mother had sex with your father! Maybe even in the ass! That means I’m smarter than you!

:smiley:

I thought it was justified at the time, but honestly, now that I’ve thought about it I don’t really see how you can warn someone for using insults in the Pit. Especially in response to an insult.

Yeah, I have to agree…this is the pit. Insults are pretty much what this forum is about…even stupid, inane insults. Perhaps ESPECIALLY stupid inane insults. This is the one place where people can go to blow off steam generated in the other forums (especially GD).

Even thread hijacks are ok here in the Pit. As long as you don’t threaten other people or otherwise break the rules you should be able to say pretty much anything you want in here…including stupid potty mouth jokes if that’s all you gots.

I’m sure Liberal can take that kind of heat in any case. :stuck_out_tongue:

-XT

Ahhh, the well known and clearly posted “insults in the Pit must not be lame” rule.
Wait… what?

That admonishment made me go WTF, too. Especially since TSS did make reference to Liberal’**s position (that he has an idiot). Now, that may or may not be true, but c’mon, we’ve all seen a lot worse in the Pit.

we’ll also leave aside the question of how TSS knew to tweak the Liberal/Libertarian button. I’m sure they’re a “long time lurker” :wink:

I did sort of wonder who The First Stone was.