Forbidden Randomness of the Unspoiled Mafia

[BigT]

@Alka_Seltzer

Yes, it would be anti-game if the scum didn’t know who each other were, nothing concrete for town to analyse. I’m not a big fan of scum not knowing each other’s roles on Day 1 for the same reason. Scum will tend to protect their power roles, and that’s something town can pick up on.

Peeker implying that he is a power role, and Freudian effectively claiming vanilla, not sure what to make of that.

@BigT - Where is Chronos suggesting he is a power role? I missed that.

It’s how I read this post:

@Chronos

If we were doing full role claims, I would have quoted. But we’re just doing names. I prefer to leave as much ambiguity as possible, at this time at least, as to whether or not I am a power role.

But that was because, for some reason, I was assuming he was Town. I would not think an actual Town power role would want to draw attention to himself. But, of course, that may be what a power role Chronos would want Scum to think.

But I actually think it would be pretty nice for Scum Chronos to later claim that he was implying he was a power role from the beginning, as it is a pro-town move if you are Vanilla to do so.

So, yeah, my first real attempt at figuring out a Mafia game ahead of time is probably just WIFOM.