Fruitcake!

Ok, last year my husband watched a special on how some monks make fruitcake. About that time, my mother mentioned that my dad, and my grandmother’s like fruitcake. One of my grandmothers was in ill health. I thought, well, now that I know some of the secrets, I will try my hand at it. It sounds neat, and what the hey, I don’t have to eat it. They fruit cakes turned out beautifully and after aging a month in bourbon, rum, and brandy, were a big hit with my grandmothers and dad. So, this year, I am making fruitcake again. I have one fewer grandmother (and no, she did not die of the fruitcake) but I do have another friend who likes fruitcake.

Since they need to age at least a month, I will be starting them soon. I bought the fruit today, all but the green and red cherries, and am gathering the rest of the supplies.

Do any of you make fruitcake? Do you have any tips?

Supplies (other than basic baking stuff)
Cheese cloth
Green Saran Wrap
Aluminum foil
Bundt pan
Tins that fit the cake from the bundt pan
Brandy
Bourbon
Dark Rum
Pecans
Fruit this year:
Pineapple
Papaya
Apples
Red sour cherries
Red sweet cherries
Prunes
Apricots
Candied cherries

The basic process is this:

• Gather your fruit together. Chop into bite sized pieces. Gather nuts to, I use only pecans chop some of these and leave others whole. Put the fruit and nuts in clean canning jars and add brandy until the fruit or nuts are just covered. I use separate jars for the nuts, light fruit, and dark fruit. Soak at least overnight.
• Drain the fruit, reserving the brandy.
• Mix the batter, adding the reserved brandy as part of the liquid.
• Except for the fruit that will be on the top for decoration, coat the fruit in flour so that each piece is coated and doesn’t stick to any other piece.
• Slowly add the coated fruit to the batter.
• Pour the batter in the pan.
• Arrange some fruit and nuts on top to decorate.
• Bake for hours in a sub 300 F oven
• Take cake out and glaze while hot
• After the cakes are cool, wrap them in brandy soaked cheese cloth. wrap again in cling wrap.
• Inject with at least 3 oz of bourbon and rum
• Wrap again in aluminum foil and place in tin.
• Age 1 to 2 weeks at room temperature and the rest in the refrigerator.
• Inject some more spirits while aging and resoak the cloths at least once.

This recipe is modified but based on the one for Regal Fruitcake
5 cups of dried and candied fruit
2 cups chopped pecans
1/2 cup brandy
1 cup butter, room temperature
2 cups firmly packed light brown sugar
5 eggs, room temperature
2 1/4 cups all-purpose flour
1/4 teaspoon baking soda
1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon
1/2 teaspoon ground mace
1/2 teaspoon ground cloves
1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg
1 teaspoon almond extract or Frangelico
Brandy, Bourbon, Dark Rum
Grease a 10-inch tube or bundt pan; line with wax paper or baking parchment and grease well. In a large bowl, combine brandy soaked fruit and nuts. Add ½ cup of reserved brandy; stir until well blended. Let stand 1 hour.
Preheat oven to 275 degrees. In a large bowl, cream butter. Gradually add brown sugar, stirring until light and fluffy. Add eggs, one at a time, beating well after each addition.
In another large bowl, combine flour, baking soda, and spices; gradually add to butter mixture. Add almond extract and fruit mixture; stir until well blended. Spoon into prepared pan. Bake 3 hours and 20 minutes or until a toothpick inserted into the cake comes out clean. Remove from oven and cool on a wire rack for 30 minutes. Remove from pan, peel paper liner from cake, Glaze cake, and then cook completely. Wrap in a brandy-soaked cheesecloth; store in an airtight container for one week. After one week, store in the refrigerator.
Makes 1 large cake.

Mmm… I am drooling, reading that. My mother used to make homemade fruitcake, and it’s not an insignificant undertaking. It’s more work than I am going to undertake, but I’m tempted, reading that. I don’t have any tips, I’m sorry.

I like fruitcake. A lot. Rich, moist, dense, delicious fruitcake.

I do have a tip! Don’t waste your divine fruitcake on the blasphemers and mockers of fruitcake! You will find true believers who will cherish your dark jewels of Christmastime.

I haven’t made fruitcake in a long, long time but the recipe we used to make included mashed up green peppercorns with the fruit and was astonishingly good.

I keep saying I will and then, bam, it’s December and far too late.

I’ve never made a fruitcake, but Alton Brown’s recipe makes me want to try. Of course, I’ve also never had a fruitcake, so maybe that’s what makes me more open to experimenting.

Susan

Hate to double post but I should amend that: The Christmas cake that we made had peppercorns and also all the unusual fruits and liquor. But on a regular basis Mum and I used to make basic fruitcake for eating because my brother and I could consume our weight in it and for cake it was deemed relatively healthy. I don’t have the recipe. I should bug Mum. It was much more straightforward. She had the recipe as John’s Camp Cake as my uncle John used to take it on sea scout camping trips. Ahh. And if we didn’t have cherries for that in the house she might make tea cake, which was fruit cake only using raisins, not other fruit, and the raisins were soaked in earl grey tea first. Lovely moist stuff.

Please do. Or at least ask her nicely, because all of that sounds wonderful. It would be fun to have those variations to try.

I always thought “tea cake” was called that because you ate it with tea, or at tea, not because it had tea in it. Learnin’ new stuff. Cool.

Well, there was that too. Which made things confusing. I used to make a lovely tea cake that was basically a plain victoria sponge sort of thing, topped with melted butter, cinnamon and sugar. So we had to specify who was making which kind of tea cake. I do miss cooking with mum! I will ask her if she still has the recipes.

My husband’s family recipe for “pecan cake” produced a very dense batter that had to be pressed, not poured, into the tube pan. The only fruit was a boatload of raisins, which were not soaked in anything beforehand.

I always dusted the pecans and raisins with flour before incorporating them into the batter, the theory being that the flour would prevent those elements from sinking to the bottom. In truth, the batter was so thick, I don’t think anything could possiblly have sunk anywhere.

No liquor in the dough or to soak the fruit, but once the cake was out of the pan, I’d puncture it all over with a thin skewer and pour a teacup of warm brandy or whiskey over the top. Wrap in cheesecake. Tuck an apple slice into the hole in the center. Wrap the whole thing in foil and put in a tin.

These were baked at least 6 weeks before Christmas, so every week or so, I’d give them another dose of brandy/whiskey.

My husband thouight pecan cake was ambrosia. My opinion: meh

freckafree, I assume you mean wrapped in cheesecloth, not cheese cake? I have made that mistake verbally a few times last night.

I had to order the candied cherries as my store won’t get them until November, sometime. I have no raisins, but I may pick some up. I do not add as much of the prunes to the batter as I do the other fruit, mostly because I save them for Rugelach. The batter is almost too thick to pour, and preventing soaking to the bottom is why I coat the fruit in flour.

I will definintely add pepper corns to the recipe. I think I added some last year. I also remember ginger should be a part of a fruitcake, but don’t know how it is added. Anyone have any suggestions?

Why is the commercial stuff so horrible? That red and green stuff-it tastes like little pieces of rubber-gaack! I think I’ll try making one-sounds good!

My wife made an excellent fruit cake last weekend that can be eaten straight away without ageing; it contains condensed milk and is rich, spicy and fruity, but quite easy to make. I’ll post the recipe later

I use only enough of the red and green cherries, which do taste like sweet rubber, to decorate the top and add a little color. The bulk of the fruit I use is dried sweetened fruit that is nice enough to snack on by itself.

Bummer, mum no longer has John’s Camp Cake - she thinks, and she’s probably right, that she passed it on to me and I lost it. She says this one is close, and it looks about right to me. She did find the tea soaked fruit one, and the green peppercorn one and will be sending them to me.

The glace cherries in Australia are quite good and not at all sweet rubber (although you used to be able to get artificial cherries that were awful). Overall I’ve had a hard time finding the same kind/quality dried fruit here in the US - it’s just a baking aisle staple back home. Generally a bag of dried fruit is golden raisins or dark raisins, currants, a few glace cherries, larger dark raisins that I haven’t seen here, and proper crystallized citrus peel.

For adding ginger, we just chopped up crystallized ginger to the same size as our other fruit bits. Tasty!

Mmmmmmm… fruitcake.

Only thing is, I hate walnuts and pecans and it’s impossible to find a commercially-produced fruitcake that is nut-free. There used to be a brand, 25 years ago, but I haven’t seen it in decades.

So if I were to get ambitious and follow one of the recipes listed or linked above, but simply omit the nuts please don’t kill me for my sins, would I just want to substitute an equivalent volume of assorted fruit?

lee, are the assorted fruits you list all dried? e.g. the sweet/sour cherries, papaya, pineapple, apple?

Mmmmmmm… fruitcake.

Only thing is, I hate walnuts and pecans and it’s impossible to find a commercially-produced fruitcake that is nut-free. There used to be a brand, 25 years ago, but I haven’t seen it in decades.

So if I were to get ambitious and follow one of the recipes listed or linked above, but simply omit the nuts please don’t kill me for my blasphemy, would I just want to substitute an equivalent volume of assorted fruit?

lee, are the assorted fruits you list all dried? e.g. the sweet/sour cherries, papaya, pineapple, apple?

Yes, they are all dried. Some, like the pineapple are dried and sweetened. I think the brand is Regal. I am not opposed to nutless fruitcake per se, but I don’t think any on my list have an aversion to nuts. If it were me, I would just substitute more fruit. I do only use pecans because they are sweeter and I think absorb the brandy better.

I got the red and green cherries in the mail today. I put up 16 cups of fruit in brandy to make the fruitcakes this weekend. I think I will save the prunes for rugelach. I have sweet and sour cherries, cranberries, apricots, pineapple, papaya, and apples. I will also be using ginger and pecans and some mixed fruits and peels. I think this will be enough for three large cakes and 2 mini cakes.

How fine should the pecans be chopped? I have what said they were pecan pieces, but mostly they are halves.

Alton may come across nutty as a fruitcake, but his recipe is very good. The use of real dried fruit does make it a tad expensive, but it’s worlds apart from the dyed cherries.

Thanks for the nudge! I need to get started on mine!

Let’s see - I just happen to have our family fruitcake recipe in front of me here - our recipe has molasses in it. I assume that a lot of people don’t like a dark fruitcake, but I love molasses, and would put it in just about anything.

Your cake sounds heavenly, Lee (with molasses added). Our family recipe has almonds, raisins, currants, dates, mixed peel and cherries, along with a bunch of spices (cloves, nutmeg, and cinnamon) and flavoured extracts (almond, lemon, brandy, and rum). I love the idea of adding green peppercorns - sounds very interesting.

I don’t suppose you could share your recipe? I have a specific request for a dark fruitcake, and I do have molasses on hand.