Game of Thrones 7.01 "Dragonstone" 7/16/17 [Show Discussion]

Tough one: the legitimacy of power.

One thing we know for sure: Daenerys believes that she has a right to the throne and plenty of people support her claim. Whether she will therefore be called Daenerys the Legitimate or the Saviour or the Slaughterer will likely depend on the sponsor of the history books.

In other words, he can be placed by the writers wherever they want him to be when the plot asks for someone like him. :wink: But I get your point.
Added:
Your points are perfectly valid, imo, storyteller0910. It’s a bit clumsy. Call it an homage to an author we all know. :slight_smile:

Apparently the Internet hated Ed Sheeran’s cameo so much, he ended up deleting his Twitter account in response to it.

Fuck the internet. Fuck cable…and fuck Twitter.

Nah, he had already said he was going to do it a while ago.

Wasn’t he basically a prisoner in his own castle at the end of last season when they killed the Blackfish?

This Ed Sheeran thing is ridiculous. It was a freaking surprise for an Actress on the show. It’s a nice story. The Internet really does suck.

I think that Dany will eventually win the Iron Throne, but I think the key is the exchange between her and Tyrion when they are talking about the wheel. It’s an infinite cycle, but Dany claims she is going to “break the wheel.” I predict that the only way to break that wheel is to introduce a new form of government. She will transition Westeros to a republic with popularly-elected rulers. And that’s why Tyrion and Varys believe in her because they know her end game and support it.

Good to know Illyn Payne’s terminal cancer is gone! Maybe the tongueless old headsman will come back and teach his nephew Pod a thing or two about swinging swords. Certainly Brienne is having a hell of a time with that task.

Speaking of which, will we see a Tyrion/Pod reunion? Or is that phase of Tyrion’s life over, like the Bronn phase? And what ever happened to Sir Bronn of the Blackwater, anyway? Did he ever marry that Stokeworth girl?

(EDIT: I just looked him up, and apparently he was in the last episode of the sixth season, riding into King’s Landing with Jaime in time to watch Cersei’s 9/11-coronation. I guess I thought we had lost track of him after Dorne. …It’s been a long 13 months.)

On top of the that, he reunited with Pod at Riverrun.

This is what I’ve been saying but nobody has bought into my theory as of yet.

Ok thanks- missed that !

I think it’s possible; Varys, in particular, would back her in that.

I also believe, as I wrote in another thread, a the end of all of this Westeros will be completely transformed into something more stable and fair. This story will be the blood, sweat and tears it took for it to happen.

Is there anyone at Castle Black who actually knows how to send a raven? After Maester Aemon dies they weren’t able to send out ravens announcing Jon’s election as Lord Commander.

Yeah, Jon isn’t King in the North because he succeeded Rob, it’s because he was elected King in the North by the Northern nobility. He’s also be de facto Lord of Winterfell because Sansa’s stepped back and has no interest in pressing her claims, nor is Bran going to.

While it’s possible, instilling a democracy would be quite a stretch for someone with a God complex who feels she has a birth right to the throne and is willing to kill off half the world with dragons and eunuchs. Is she really all that different from Cersei? While she has gained compassion for the commoners while ruling Meereen, let’s not forget that she basically invaded another land and took over with force, just like the others on the wheel that she plans to “break”.

Khaleesi left Daario Nuncio behind in Merreen to implement a republic (I don’t recall the exact words, but that was the gist of it) Of course, she feels she has a hereditary claim to Westeros that she did not have to Merreen, so who knows?

“Breaking the wheel” could just as easily mean Lords Paramount system and turning Westeros (or at least the parts not made into client kingdoms) into an absolute monarchy dividing into a bunch of providers with non-hereditary governors answering directly to the Crown. She might have turned Meereen into a republic, but that’s just because she’s moving on to bigger things and setting it up as a vassal state would’ve been impractical.

I don’t see the people of Westeros being ready for true democracy. They lack education and the requisite civil society. Think Afghanistan.

More likely, ‘Just Rule’ would involve a council of kings who represent their regions, rather than a small council of loyalists.

Most likely, the threat from the walkers will become so obvious that alliances will have to be forged between warring factions, and Daeneris and Jon will become the leaders of the allied North and South, at least until and if the army of the undead is defeated. Then we are likely back to warring factions and might makes right - but the story may end before then.

What I would like to see happen is Jon and Daeneris attempt to make some kind of alliance with the Lannisters, but have crazy Cersei refuse and insist on fighting to the death instead. Jaime intervenes by killing her, and the story then becomes all the people in Westeros uniting to fight the White Walkers, with the last season depicting the war between the living and the dead, with Jaime and the Lannisters fighting alongside Tyrion, Jon, and Daeneris.

Hmm… maybe the scene with Arya and the Lannister squad is an attempt to show that the Lannister army is just people like everyone else, to set up our acceptance of the Lannisters as allies. Hell, maybe Arya plays a role in brokering that peace, either by coming to the aid of those soldiers or by killing Cersei…

Every time I hear someone complain about comments about the books, especially since that now the show is well past the published books, I see them as a gopher.

You know what I’ve just realized? What they don’t have at Eastwatch by the sea? Or anywhere NEAR Eastwatch? Mountains. The mountains are all at the Western end of the wall, near the Shadow Tower.

But that end is only near the sea, it doesn’t actually meet it. It ends at a river.

Sooooooooo, is The Hound’s vision contradictory? OR could there be two armies headed to the two ends of it?

I think you’re reading ten billion times too much into it than is warranted. They’re not basing dialogue off of maps. The most likely explanation is that the is a mountain somewhere between Hardhome and Eastwatch regardless of what maps say.