I like the smell, and it’s subtle. My wife likes it, too, and it complements the whole “50’s Dad” thing I’ve got going on. I just picked up a bottle of Bay Rum after shave today at lunch time. I’ll try it this weekend - I hope I like it, since it cost $18. In the past, I tried (but did not like) Aqua Velva. I was at the drug store a couple days ago and took a sniff of Brut and instantly recalled that I occasionally used it when I was a teenager. Funny. There’s not much out there in the way of men’s grooming shops, so there isn’t much competing for my attention.
Anyways. How about you? What else is out there? I don’t use cologne, so my potential for new aftershave is boundless.
I suggest “Clubman” by Pinaud, both original and special reserve. Both barbershop soapy and old fashioned masculine clean smelling when used subtly. The special reserve dries up into a nice leathery note that reminds me of cold mornings in the pickup with grand dad, faint smell of coffee, aftershave and gasoline. Big band on a quiet AM radio station.
I use Nivea Post Shave Balm. It smells nice, but isn’t overpowering, as my wife can be sensitive to smells. I used nothing for a long time, but once I started shaving my head it feels soothing to the scalp if the shave irritates it, and I also have a sensitive area on my neck that it really helps to put the fire hose on.
Occasionally Nivea aftershave balm if my skin is a bit irritated, otherwise none. No cologne either. Between soap(shower gel), shampoo and deodorant I’ve got enough scents on me.
I don’t always use aftershave, but when I do, I tend toward the Fine Accoutrements American Blend splash in the summer, and the Real Shaving Co. Soothing balm in the winter.
Currently I’m using up a bottle of Aqua Velva Ice Blue. I thought a menthol aftershave would be nice for the summer, but I’m not happy with it. It has too much scent (although it dissipates completely in 30-60 minutes), and it takes maybe 15-20 seconds for the menthol to begin to kick in, and it does that gradually instead of what I wanted: a quick burst.
I’ve also tried making my own crude version: 2 parts rubbing alcohol, 1 part water, and a little glycerine. It was okay.
I have also tried the Nivea balm. It’s very expensive, but I liked it a lot. One large drop is a generous portion, it works very well, and there’s very little scent.