Goodbye to a Good Dog

She was never the smartest dog, or the healthiest dog, but her heart was in the right place.

She became a part of my family at 9 months old, an energetic, seemingly happy bulldog juvenile, reddish brown fur, white neck ring, white socks, and darker fur around her eyes almost creating a mask type appearance. We named her Morgan. We already had a male bulldog, Charlie, and this was to be his playmate, his friend, his company when he was left home alone. We bought her from an ad in the paper. She was cheaper than she should have been for a bulldog. We were told by the man who was selling her that he was selling both her and her sister because he had had heart surgery and couldn’t care for them anymore.

It became obvious once we got her home that the man had kept her and her sister in the garage with little contact except to beat them. She was not the least bit house trained, and any man walking into the room caused her to urinate. My then husband was not the most sympathetic to her plight, at which point I said, leave her alone, let me handle it.

Within a couple of months, she was house trained and over the worst of her fears. She became my shadow – every where I went, she was glued to my side. She wasn’t the smartest of dogs – she never learned much beyond sit, lay down, give paw, and roll over. She would often get underfoot and would revert to scared puppy mode whenever anyone raised their voice around her. But nothing got her down for long. When anyone would walk into the house, she would greet them with a baying that sounded more like a beagle than a bulldog “Roo, roooooooooo!!!” she would declare at the top of her lungs. I would reply, “Hello, Moo Moooooooo!!!” and so she became MooMoo more than Morgan.

She loved ice cubes and ice in general. The second I cracked an ice cube tray, if she wasn’t already at my feet, she would be there, looking up at me expectantly. She hated remote control things. We had a remote control dodge truck toy, that she would attack to the point of foaming at the mouth, and it appeared to me that she thought she was saving me from it. We couldn’t have any toys with squeakers inside them. It was her personal vendetta to remove any squeaker immediately, and she wouldn’t give up until her deed was done. She became an expert at it as she grew, removing just the squeaker with near surgeon precision. She only chewed a couple of shoes when she was younger… but could devour an entire rawhide in one sitting.

When she was two and a half years old, we bred her and Charlie, our other bulldog. They had 4 beautiful puppies via C-section, but the strain did nothing for her health. The stress of it all caused her tear ducts to shut down, causing her to claw a hole in her cornea. So she had a corneal eye graft surgery during her puppies’ first weeks of life. After it had been ingrained in her so deeply that she should not have accidents in the house, she seemed to insist that the puppies belonged outside. The first few weeks I got no sleep as I would wake to a crying puppy she was trying to pick up and carry out to the dugout she had created on the side of the garage in the yard. From the moment she had had her own puppies, she was obsessed with babies. She watched over any baby with determination that entered our home – licking its feet continuously if permitted to. She would run hysterically between the child’s mother and the baby if it became upset.

When we had our own child, she saw it as her personal duty to watch over him. She slept under his crib whenever permitted instead of at the foot of my bed. She was patient and gentle with him through the ear pulling and poking phases that children go through.

But as she aged, her health waned. Her eyes were never right after her puppies (we never bred them again). She had allergies that made her feet swell. We had medication we gave her to try to control it, but as time went on, she became used to it and it helped less and less. Her allergies worked their ways into her ears, too, causing infection after in infection. She had alopecia, which made her look somewhat mangey and there wasn’t anything the vets could do to help us.

Her immune system seemed to be completely shutting down and there was nothing we could do. Her problems began to combine to be insurmountable. The last straw was when she lost the use of her hind legs.

And so today, just over 9 years since she first came home with me, I must give my friend some peace. I must free her from this world of pain that has become all she knows. I hope there is a doggy heaven, so she can run free again, caring for all the children there, welcoming the new ones with her enthusiastic “Rooo Rooooooooo!!!” She was a good dog, a dedicated friend, a great spirit, and I will miss her so.

And Charlie, don’t you dare join her, not yet… you’re doing good, hang in there old boy.

I’m sorry that you’re going through this. It takes both courage and love.

I’ve loved bulldogs since I was a small boy, but have resisted the urge to get one because of the health problems to which they are prone. Every time I see one in the street or at someone’s house I make a complete fool of myself over the dog and think, “Damn, I would just love to have one of these mugs…”

I am so sorry for your loss. To me the phrase “It’s just a dog” when dealing with a beloved pet’s demise is about like saying “It’s just a really close friend”. I’m so happy that you had 9 good years with her, though, and even moreso that she had 9 years with you after getting off to a bad start with her first home.

She sounds like she was a very good girl. I hope you find comfort in the fact that you gave her a happy life.

I am going through something similar and I just posted about it in a thread called “On Death, Dying, Dogs and Dreams”.

I am so sorry to hear your news. The loss of a loved pet is a deep sadness. She sounds like a good dog and a good friend. Sending warm thoughts your way.

You know that you’re making the right decision but it still hurts like hell, doesn’t it?
What a good dog.

Thanks everyone… I wrote that at work, and just couldn’t keep it together. The appointment is at 4pm (two hours from now). As I walked in the door, crying, as I had been the whole drive home, she welcomed me with a roo-roo, something she has hardly done in the last few weeks since being so sick. Then when I sat by her, she licked my face and my hands, trying to make me feel better. Here she is the one in pain, and she is trying to be the brave one. She always put everyone else first, to the last.

I do it because I must - I have already put it off longer than I should have.

Although bulldogs are more prone to health problems, it didn’t and wouldn’t deter me from the breed. That is to me like saying I wouldn’t marry someone I love just because they have diabetes. Love is love. Any love is a gift, even if it is of short duration. I wouldn’t take back the years we had. I wouldn’t regret it if she had lived half as long. There is always the chance you get a healthy one, like my Charlie has been, knock on wood. He is almost 11 and aside from some bad teeth, he is still healthy as can be.

But the transition isn’t easy…

Your beautiful tribute to your bully had me crying but I think she’s trying to tell you that it’s okay. She’s tired and ready to go. Oh, and I can’t imagine a heaven where my beloved doggies aren’t there to greet me when I get there. Be strong! {{{{{Thinks2Much and Morgan}}}}}

I just gave her a last meal of fried chicken - all to herself that Charlie didn’t get any of (he has always thieved the better portions of food from her.) She was pleased. :slight_smile:

Thanks Tupug… that was what cliched it for me over the weekend - she has been asking to go. She can’t even sit up anymore, and when she fell outside, she just lay there, didn’t even try to right herself, she sighed, and looked at me as if to say, “Please, don’t put me through this anymore.”

My last dog also asked to be released from his pain Thinks2Much.
He’d been at the vet for two days in a final attempt to see if anything could be done.
He couldn’t walk anymore and as he lay on the floor, he pissed himself.
He looked at me as if to say “Please spare me further indignities.”
I had him euthanized that afternoon.
I think it’s the least we can do to say thank you for loving us so much.

HUG

I’m sorry for your loss. I know it’s hard, but you are doing what’s best for her.

I’m so sorry you are going through this. I really enjoyed hearing about Morgan’s life. She was a good dog, who knew she was loved, and she will live on in your memories of her.

So, as of 4:20pm central time, May 2nd, 2005 Morgan is no more. I held her in my arms as she received the injection. She groaned and slumped, so I lay her down gently. Her tongue stuck out as often happens with bulldogs when they sleep - we called it “the sleepy tongue”. I looked into her eyes as her heart stopped beating, and told her I would see her again, somehow, if I could help it. They let me stay in the room as long as I wanted, but as her tongue turned gray and dry, I felt it was better for me to leave.

Thanks one and all for reading - it has been very cathartic for me to write this out, and helpful to hear others touched by her story.

::major eye leakage::

A touching farewell to a beloved companion. You did the right thing for her. My heart breaks for you.

I lost a beloved dog last November, and the pain is still too fresh to write about her. I hope that Delia is teaching Morgan The Happy Dance at the Rainbow Bridge right now.

<sniff>
I am so sorry for your loss. It is never easy. She’ll be waiting for you at the bridge.

Years ago my cousin, a devout New Ager, took me to a psychic channeler she believed in. The “channeler” asked me “Who that you have lost would you most like to make contact with this evening?” and I gave him the names Dudley and Bebe. I wasn’t being sarcastic- they were the first names that came to mind. He finally asked me (since I was pretty skeptical and not being very responsive) “I’m feeling something but I can’t be certain… did Dudley have a lot of pain in his chest when he died?” to which I answered “I don’t think so… he was hit by a car and died instantly”… He was surprised and asked “What about Bebe?” and I told him truthfully that “I don’t think she felt any pain… we had her put to sleep when she was old and in pain.” It was only then that he realized, and only then that I realized that he hadn’t realized before, that I wasn’t talking about relatives but about dogs. (I’d lost relatives including cousins, my grandparents and even my father, but it was the Pekingese and St. Bernard I missed most.)

I’ve posted this story before, but it is always worth repeating.

Central VA Public Television has a show called “Virgnia Currents,” where the hostess travels the roads of the Commonwealth doing stories on interesting folks or events. She may visit the Eastern Shore for a crab picking contest one week, and then do a story on the peacocks at a bed and breakfast in the Mountains the next. You never know what the sujbect’s going to be.

A few years ago she did a story on a man in Charlottesville who claims to be able to communicate with the dead. The man doesn’t come across as a New Age, crystal-gazing psychic - he’s about as ordinary as you can get (except he’s about 7’ tall, but that’s not relevant). The hostess of the show brought along a friend that the man had never met before and did not know as coming on the segment shoot (all of this according to the hostess, who has a great deal of credibility in the community). At the end of the shoot, totally unscripted, the hostess asks the man if he’ll speak with her guest and he agrees. The man proceeds to tell the guest all about her grandfather, who had dies the previous year and how he (the grandfather) has been present in her life. At the end of the segment they left the cameras rolling and as everyone’s taking off their microphones the man says, “Oh, by the way, your grandfather asked me tell you that ‘Of course there are dogs in heaven.’” According to the host, the guest had intended to ask the man that question but forgot to bring it up during the taping of the segment.

So there you have it (sort of) - dogs do go to heaven.

Thanks **plnnr ** - that does help, and I had not seen you post it before. :slight_smile: