This has got to be the first show I’ve ever seen with NO positive response whatsoever on ANY of the message boards that’s managed to make it to a third season. (It’s currently running 71 on Metacritic, for whatever that’s worth.) That’s got to be some achievement. As for me…I like it. I enjoy watching intense action sequences, volatile personalities bouncing off of each other, and the unpredictability of where and how disaster will strike next. It’s pretty much that simple. I’ve never given much of a rip about “continuity” or what the Gotham City mythos “should” be like (seriously, anyone who’s paid any attention to the comics, cartoon series, and/or movies and still thinks there’s anything sacred here is seriously deluded). While I think there have been some missteps (should’ve brought in a predecessor to Mr. Freeze instead of reworking his origin yet again, dragged Jim Gordon through the mud a bit too much, really need to fish or cut bait with Fish Mooney), there hasn’t been anything I’d identify as a fatal, “that’s it, I’m done with this crap” moment. Thus far it’s working for what it is, and honestly, I don’t see anything better on Monday night.
Here’s three characters I’ll be keeping an eye on this season:
Ivy Pepper (the future Poison Ivy), who got aged up by one of the Indian Hill patients and apparently is going to attempt to seduce Bruce Wayne in the future. The Mary Sue was absolutely apoplectic about this. Me, I’m mainly concerned about whether this will finally give her some relevance. Let’s be honest, we know next to nothing about her; heck, Victor Zsasz has more depth right now. If it turns out she discovers a knack for making men weak in the knees, and she learns she can use this ability for her own ends, I can possibly see this working.
Fish Mooney. This is where the show really has their chips down; they HAVE to make this work now or else she could drag the whole franchise into the drink. In particular, one huge question is looming: Why did she spare Penguin’s life? Doesn’t matter what the payout is, but I want to see Fish as a real threat, I want her to face real dangers, and I want her motivations to ultimately make some modicum of sense. The premiere seems to be headed in the right direction. We’ll see.
Captain Barnes. First off, let me say how amazed I am by the sheer longevity of this character. We’ve had cops and captains and commissioners slaughtered or hounded into retirement left and right, and after well over a year, this stubborn, snarling hardass (who’s already been seriously wounded once) is still large and in charge. I don’t know about you all, but I’m certainly impressed. I have to think that the writers have something bigger planned for him, that he’s going to serve a greater cause, but he’s about the last person in the damn show I’d expect to have any ins with Hugo Strange or the Court of Owls. Just how long can this bull keep charging before he’s brought down?