offer 2a on hold pending clarification from game mod It looks like there may have been a miscommunication, hopefully not.
Gad O-2: Oredigger, looks at my 3 and 16 for a look at your 1 and your Forever Yours heart.
First Update :
**Please Confirm. You guys were very eager to get started. Want to make sure I got this correct.
**
Scuba_Ben Holds:
A copy of rules: 6,8,9,14,17.
Has Seen rules:
1 Pink Conversation Heart
1 Pink Rose
6 Red Conversation Hearts
1 Vase of Water
3 White Conversation Hearts
2 White Roses
Antinor01 Holds:
A copy of rules: 1,4,6,7,8,12.
Has Seen rules:
1 Platinum Necklace
1 Pink Rose
1 Gold Ring
6 Red Conversation Hearts,
1 Vase of Water
1 White Conversation Heart
2 White Roses
**
Mahaloth** Holds:
A copy of rules: 5,13,15,16,18.
Has seen rules:
1 Silver Necklace
1 Pink Rose
6 Red Conversation Hearts
1 Silver Ring
1 White Conversation Heart
2 White Roses
Oredigger77 Holds:
A copy of rules: 1,2,5,9,11,19.
Has seen rules: [3,10,12,13,16,18]
1 Platinum Earring
1 Silver Earring
1 Forever Yours Heart
1 Pink Conversation Heart
1 Pink Rose
2 Red Conversation Heart
1 Red Rose
1 Vase of Water
1 White Conversation Heart
NAF1138 Holds:
A copy of rules: 2,4,6,7,17,20.
Has seen rules: [3,10,12,13,16,18,1,2,5,9,11,19]
1 Be Mine Heart
1 Gold Earring
1 Pink Conversation Heart
1 Pink Rose
2 Red Conversation Hearts
1 Red Rose
1 Vase of Water
1 White Conversation Heart
3 White Roses
Gadarene Holds:
a copy of rules: 3,10,12,13,16,18.
Has seen rules: [2,4,6,7,17,20,5,19]
1 Gold Necklace
1 Pink Conversation Heart
1 Pink Rose
6 Red Conversation Hearts
1 White Conversation Heart
1 White Rose
Pedescribe Holds:
A copy of rules: 10,11,14,15,19,20.
Has seen rules:
1 Box of Chocolates
8 Pink Conversation Hearts
1 Red Conversation Heart
1 Platinum Ring
1 Red Rose
2 White Roses
Whoa whoa whoa…the white rose in Gad N-1 was going from NAF to me, not the other way around.
…I seriously can’t believe I screwed this game up already as much as I did.
Wasn’t sure how you parsed this.
I asked chrisk how to handle this. Will get back to you.
Here’s the accepted trades I am party to:
Ben 1: NAF looks at my r8 and I look at his r7.
Gad A-4: Gad looks at my r17 and I look at his r12.
Ben 2a: Gad looks at my r9 and I look at his r18.
Ben 2b: NAF looks at my r9 and I look at his r4.
NAF2b -Maha sorry for screwing around like this. Rule 6 for rule 15 swap straight up
Mods- I parsed the trade with Gad the way you did, but would be happy to just cancel the rose action altogether since the rules have already been seen.
I mean, I was giving him a look at the one unique rule in the game…why would I be throwing in a rose on top of it?
(Let’s not talk about how one white rose is paltry compensation anyway. sigh)
I’m sure you would. 
Sorry, I’ve already seen 16 but . . .
** Digger 1: Gad I’ll give you rule #1 for a look at #3**
Withdraw Digger 1
Sorry, about that Gada I just got your rules from our last trade. I think that I can do better.
NAF based on rule 5, 9, and 12 you know this should be about even
Digger offer 2: NAF I’ll give you rule 1 for your Gold Earing
I will not be able to get back to this game until 5p EST.
Feel free to make trades, just know that I won’t be able to fill them until then.
NAF counter 1 - It’s a risk for me at this point. Throw in your conversation heart and it’s a deal.
Oredigger: How much for a look at rule 1 before you give it away to NAF?
Accept NAF counter 1 provided the heart is not used against me or I get all of your roses
Digger offer 3: I’ll trade you a look at 1 for a look at your 8 and 14
Obviously only good until NAF accepts
accept not to use heart against you.