Two points to add to our consideration.
A quibble, minor enough. I don’t think he was trying to pull the party leftward so much as to demonstrate that the party was already there. To demonstrate that it was the Clintonista DNC that was out of step.
IN(h)O, the Clintonista Republican Lite move was largely a matter of campaign contributions. The Pubbies were getting the lyin’s share of corporate contributions (très duh, mais non?). In an age of mass advertising, this was seen as a crippling disadvantage. In order to get a bigger share, Horndog Bill moved to placate and calm the corporadoes. Thus the “Business friendly”, broke-dick-blue-dead-dog, menshevik Clintonista DNC. It was a strategic retreat, fall back and re-group. As bitter as that pill was to swallow, they may have been right. (Pun regretted)
But that was then. There are any number of signs and omens that the old fashioned advertising scheme for campaigning my not work any more. Best possible example, the campaign of Jeb(!), who was declared the front-runner because he had so much of that advertising money. But couldn’t move the needle. Remember how they spent about forty million dollars in tiny little New Hampshire for their Republican primary and got nothing…nothing!…for it, not even a twitch!
The rise of the importance of the small donor is the biggest news ever ignored. Bernie wanted to demonstrate that, bless his pea-pickin’ heart. And I don’t think he was prepared for how well it worked, because nobody was! There was some sober discussion about how that affected Obama’s success, but passed over lightly, for the most part. But it was a big hairy-ass deal with Bernie Bed Hair! Yuge! Did Bernie begin to think he could actually win? The triumph of hope over experience? Dunno, maybe, an entirely human thing to happen.
And there is something very important about the small donation, it is a contribution, it is a commitment, it is participation. It draws converts not from the Republicans, but from the vast ranks of the Apathy Party. Of all my political goals, that is first and foremost. If he intended that, hurray for him. If he was just as surprised as the rest of us, hurray for us! 'Merica, fuck yeah!
The Clintonistas may have been right, maybe their strategic retreat did preserve the Party to fight another day. In the cold and icy light of realpolitik, they definitely had a point. Especially given the Pubbies’ demonstrated eagerness to legislate electoral advantages to themselves by voter suppression, gerrymandering, etc.
Shit happens, but shit changes. The Republicans are still depending on massive donations and massive business-as-usual advertising to make their case. But it could be…just could be, mind you!..that the advantage which used to be definitive is no longer. Bernie didn’t remove all possible doubt, but he sure as shit made a strong case.
Thanks, Bernie Bed Hair! And may the Goddess hold you close to Her bountiful bosom all the days of your live, aperson!
(Also, speaking as a person who does not like Hillary, I thought she personally conducted her argument with Bernie in a civil and respectful manner. She demonstrated that she was willing to listen, to negotiate respectfully. Which was, of course, the smart thing to do. Points given. Still don’t like her, but respectfully.)