[QUOTE=A.R. Cane]
While an insurgency doesn’t necessarily imply militant opposition, it often leads to that. When it does the militants are commonly referred to as guerillas. Your description of an insurgency seems a bit
biased and naive.
[/QUOTE]
No, let’s review again. Guerilla warfare is a strategic and tactical manner of deployment and engagement, and has been for over two thousand years. It is small unit infantry hitting infrastructure and, if necessary, engaging opposition troops under set circumstances. It is nothing more than this. The United States trains and fields its own guerillas, we call some of them Special Forces. Take out a railroad, take out a telecom line, take out a bridge, and so forth. Find and train local friendlies to further support operations. Avoid direct contact with enemy forces in strength whenever possible. For the guerilla, local support is nice but not required unless an extended deployment is contemplated. For best effect, guerillas precede and/or supplement friendly conventional forces. The guerilla is a soldier, sometimes with a political bent, but sometimes not.
An insurgent may conduct guerilla operations, but often does not. An insurgent can be an unarmed woman in a wheelchair printing handbills. An insurgent can be a receptionist feeding intelligence back to the insurgency. The insurgent’s goal is political change, which may not even be much of a military task. Unlike the guerilla, the insurgent absolutely relies on some support from the local populace. The local populace is, after all, ultimately the insurgent’s objective. The insurgent is a political, sometimes with a militant bent, but sometimes not.
If we had a venn diagram, there’d be plenty of overlap, but the insurgents and guerillas would not be the same. Examples:
-
In fiction, the high school students in the movie Red Dawn are not insurgents, they are guerillas.
-
An intelligence operative sent to liase with and encourage local disaffected college students in a certain Middle Eastern theocracy is not a guerilla, he is an insurgent.
-
T.E. Lawrence and Che Guevara were both guerillas and insurgents.
Although the distinction is not in and of itself crucial to your original and incorrect point, the use of the terms interchangeably suggests a woeful misunderstanding of the larger Israel/Hezbollah situation…
[QUOTE=A.R. Cane]
Hezbollah, like Hamas, has been particularly successful in their insugency activity, providing real infrastucture as well as basic, life sustaining, services to the populous.
[/QUOTE]
…which brings us to the application portion. For Israeli purposes, Hezbollah are not even remotely insurgents. Their insurgency was directed against Lebanon, and has already succeeded. The rest of Lebanon is no longer sovereign over the south, which makes it a de facto breakaway state that has provoked a neighboring country into war. Israel has invaded what is effectively Hezbollahland, and is currently using conventional (and I assume, unconventional) tactics against the guerillas therein. The Hezbollah guerillas will lose, because they cannot do what a guerilla must do to win: avoid enemy forces in strength and cause ongoing damage to the opposition until the opposition capitulates. What’s Hezbollah going to do, blow up its own stuff? For the guerilla, the shit has most definitely hit the fan when you’re forced to be a guerilla in your own country, and the best you can do is ambush trained soldiers that kick your ass and then blow up your house with artillery.
[QUOTE=A.R. Cane]
I can’t imagine that being true, unless, of course, you think that diplomacy, compromise and negotiation are forms of retreat?
[/QUOTE]
I don’t think they’re relevant to your original points in this thread.
[QUOTE=A.R. Cane]
Of course it’s more logical, as well as moral, to seek compromise rather than dominate and supress.
[/QUOTE]
Such logic and morality leaves people dying today in the streets of the Lebanon, as it has for decades. I shall be forever in wonder of persons who seek compromise with fanatics and call it logic.
[QUOTE=A.R. Cane]
That last statement sounds like an excerpt from the Bush doctrine of world dominance. In case you have been paying attention, it ain’t workin’ to good!
[/QUOTE]
Don’t be ridiculous, George Bush can’t read a sentence like that.