I have a pretty good idea of what I think the Israelis are really up to.
As a couple of people have pointed out, Hezbollah could simply fade away.
To prevent that you have to put troops on the ground to draw their fire.
Yet it is absurd to expect to be able to conduct urban warfare without heavy casualties, and the Israelis don’t like casualties.
They need to appear to be having a hard time, they need to appear to be weak, then when they have enough Hezbollah concentrated (and as few non combatants in the area), draw back fast and carpet bomb the place. I would do this about 3am.
Cutting off routes to Syria is logical.
The only bombing in non-Hezbollah residential areas that I heard of was about a week ago, when they bombed two trucks parked up, the trucks had water drills on them.
Partly, I think this was symbolic, demonstrating that they will go anywhere to destroy rockets, but mainly I think that they really were rockets.
Yelping about cutting North Lebanon off from Syria is a bit daft, anyone who supplies aid by land is naive in the extreme. If trucks come in from Syria, they are guaranteed to contain munitions. If anyone wants to supply aid, then there is a perfectly good port, if you can take Westerners out, then you can take food and medical supplies in, subject to a little negotiation with the Israelis.
I’m slightly at a loss to understand Gonzomax’s position, if the Israelis wanted to turn Lebanon into a bombsite, they could have done so on day one.
That the Lebanese government has not disowned Hezbollah indicates just one thing, that the Lebanese government is scared sh*tless of Hezbollah. The Israelis know that, or rather if they don’t they have wasted a lot of resources on intelligence.
I suspect that the Israelis would not mind negotiating with anyone who appeared reasonable, but negotiation for those two soldiers would be a bit silly, for a start Hezbollah wanted about 1000 people in exchange, and the second thing is that Hezbollah would twig that capturing Israeli soldiers is rather a good game.
What really hacked off Israel was those Katyushas. You can be sure that they knew that they were there (their estimate was 12,000 against Hezbollah claims of 17,000 I can’t cite, I heard it on the radio).
My guess is that after they have carpetbombed S Lebanon, they will drop incendiaries (interesting that they have not done that yet), they’ll use helicopters at dawn, to plant paratroops at escape routes and drive armoured columns in to break up the area.
I reckon that then they’ll sit and wait, it would be foolish to conduct a house to house search.
It is very possible that the Maronites will fall on Hezbollah in the North, their best chance is to get marched over to Syria, but many will be shot ‘resisting arrest’.
I’m not sure what will happen to the approx 1m non combatant refugees, N Lebanon is not going to be that keen on letting them breed a new generation of Hezbollah.
Probably the road to Damascus for them. Shame we have no space … :-}
After Israel is certain that they have cleaned up S Lebanon, they’ll pull back, and the border will be covered by probably French troops, with some of the Lebanese army and a token (and utterly useless) UN presence.
North Lebanon will be quietly pleased that they have rid themselves of Hezbollah, who were and still are more of a threat to them than to Israel.
Vast chunks of aid will come in, S Lebanon will be rebuilt using Syrian labour, and it will be repopulated with N Lebanese that don’t like Hezbollah.
It will be interesting to see what becomes of Hamas in Ghaza and the West Bank.
- if individuals had any sense they would switch allegiance to Abbas, and get on his payroll
Predictions, but that is the way I read the runes.