Most songs in rock music (and its various subgenres) follow a verse–chorus structure, characterized by the alternation of two sections with distinct melodies (and often also distinct rhythms, dynamics, etc.). Many such songs shake things up with a third distinct section called a bridge.
Of course, in other musical genres other structural patterns predominate, and even within rock music there are plenty of exceptions. Consider, for example, Jimi Hendrix’s “Purple Haze”, which has a verse and a bridge but no chorus, or Queen’s “Bohemian Rhapsody”, which has several distinct verse sections but no chorus. Then there’s Gordon Lightfoot’s folk-rock “The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald”, which has only a single verse section, just four measures long, repeated over and over with very little melodic variation for six minutes.
My question is, how unique is “The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald” among chart-topping rock music hits in having such a simplistic structure? Can anyone think of any other rock songs that both (a) employed only a single verse form, with no chorus or bridge, and (b) were a number-one (or let’s say at least top-ten) hit?
Note that by calling the song’s structure “simplistic”, I don’t mean to disparage it; there’s certainly plenty of complexity in its other aspects, including its lyrics, instrumentation, and production. It’s a testament to Lightfoot’s skill as a songwriter and performer that he was able to craft such a compelling and successful piece of music without relying on the standard melodic and harmonic variations. I’m just curious as to how unusual a feat this was—offhand I can’t think of any other charting songs with the same structure, though I’m sure there must be others. Can we make a list?
Bob Dylan’s “Tangled Up in Blue” has no chorus, and no bridge to speak of; it just has seven verses, all following the same structure, and each one ending with the song’s title as its final line.
The song did chart, reaching #31 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart in 1975.
Rod Stewart’s “Maggie May” fits this description, as does another song from the same album - the title track “Every Picture Tells A Story.” I don’t know if that track hit the chart, but Maggie topped the charts in multiple countries including the UK.
Could Harry Nilsson’s “Coconut” also count? That song doesn’t really have any structure at all. There are arguably several distinct sections in the lyrics but there are no rhythmic changes to separate them and the song only has one chord. It reached #8 on the American Billboard and #4 in Canada.
I’m betting every other song mentioned in this thread will be less boring. I say that as a fan of Gordon Lightfoot’s songwriting skills (and his band’s musicianship)… on almost any other song of his.
.
Wouldn’t Dylan’s Lily , Rosemary and the Jack of Hearts also count?
I’m a big fan of story songs (with one exception), and I’d bet there are more of those out there… like the powerful Cold Missouri Waters.
“Leader of the Pack” and perhaps some other hits by the Shangra-las. Basically story songs with the closest thing to a chorus being the title in the last line of each verse and the closest thing to a bridge, some sound effects or spoken word.
Charlie Daniels’ “Uneasy Rider” was #9 hit in 1973 on the Billboard Hot 100 Singles chart. The song is strictly Daniels and the band strumming behind a series of three-line verses. No chorus, no bridge.
The Who’s “Pinball Wizard” (#4 UK, #15 US) and “We’re Not Going To Take It” (#37 US) - both from Tommy - don’t have choruses. I believe neither has bridges, as well.
Can’t Find My Way Home and In the Presence of the Lord, both by Blind Faith, are just one verse repeated three times with no chorus, as is Dear Mr. Fantasy by Traffic, with Steve Winwood being the common thread between all three.
ISTR that someone (CSNY, maybe?) did a cover of Dear Mr. Fantasy that had a second and third verse, but still no chorus.
Everybody’s Talkin’? Written and originally recorded by Fred Neil, later recorded by Harry Nilsson, featuring prominently on the Midnight Cowboy soundtrack of course. Would that qualify?
It’s got a bridge, but unless “that deaf dumb and blind kid sure plays a mean pinball” counts as a chorus, then it hasn’t got one.
I believe you’re thinking of the Twisted Sister song, not the finale of Tommy.
Come down off your throne and leave your body alone
Somebody must change
You are the reason I’ve been waiting all these years
Somebody holds the key
Well, I’m near the end and I just ain’t got the time
And I’m wasted and I can’t find my way home
I doubt it will qualify as rock music but this song reached Number 3 in the UK singles charts. A comedy spoken word monologue titled Capstick Comes Home by comedian and actor Tony Capstick.
