Og, I love the SDMB!
I grew up with F&S, who were great favorites of my parents, and as a child I naturally took them completely for granted. It was only when I rediscovered them as an adult a few years ago, bought the complete CD set, and listened to them again, that I realized what amazing composers, writers, and performers they were.
Flanders’ lyrics are witty, erudite, and yet playful. Consider corresponding lines from the three verses of “Have Some Madiera, M’dear.”
*And he said as he hastened to put out the wine, the cat, his cigar, and the lamps
…
She lowered her standards by raising her glass, her spirits, her eyes, and his hopes
…
When he asked, “What in heaven?” she made no reply, up her mind, and a dash for the door. *
I challenge anyone to name another song that uses three examples of parallel construction like this. (Or the word “antepenultimate,” for that matter.)
Swann’s music mates with the lyrics perfectly, always helping to express the meaning of the words.
They were also exemplary, if somewhat unlikely, performers: a wheelchair-bound polio victim and a former language student. Swann’s piano playing is remarkably delicate and expressive, and Flanders’ lovely tenor voice keeps up with him at every turn. Flanders was also a wonderful raconteur and his anecdotes and patter between the songs were unfailingly amusing.
At its best, their music is civilized and sophisticated light entertainment. It’s not Wagner, but it’s a damn sight better than 99.9% of what passes for entertainment these days. At its worst, it is simply trivial, which is still better than 99.8% of today’s entertainment.
As a child, I found the songs Swann sang, like “In the Desert” and “To ko ko ri,” rather tedious, and even now, I don’t consider them among the pair’s best. But I do have a greater appreciation for the dry humor of the former, and the fact that the latter is actual Greek, and not just nonsense.
I also regret somewhat that F&S focused so heavily on animal songs, which IMO pegged them as children’s performers. But this is nitpicking.
Here’s to Michael Flanders and Donald Swann:
The English, the English, the English are best!
I wouldn’t give tuppence for all of the rest!