[QUOTE=ParadoxMan]
Which of these comics are recommended for someone newly getting in the series? Are there going to be another start over soon where there’ll be a issue#1 again? Are there any of the Superman comics which should just be avoided altogether, whether from being way to late in the series to understand what’s going or just plain bad writing/storylines/arcs?
[/QUOTE]
You’ve picked a good time. Next month, Superman and Action Comics (the third monthly Superman title is being discontinued), like most DC titles, will jump ahead one year in continuity. While the events will be connected to the current megaevent (Infinite Crisis), it should still serve as a good spot to start reading. The first arc is by Kurt Busiek (who’s a very well-regarded writer right now, so it should be quality work).
In the meantime, some of my favorite Superman stories aren’t canon, but still really let the character shine.
Red Son is the story of Kal-El landing in Soviet Georgia instead of Kansas. He grows up to become Stalin’s greatest weapon and later leader of the Soviet Union. It’s not knee-jerk anti-Communism (but neither is it a Stalinist apology), but it depicts Superman as basically a good man tainted by scary communist ideology. How Lex Luthor finally stops him is among my favorite comic book moments ever.
Secret Identity (also by Busiek) is the story of a boy named Clark Kent growing up in the real world (where Superman is fictitious) who suddenly discovers that he really does have the powers of his namesake. It’s the story of how he comes to terms with his place in the world. A more realistic look at what Superman’s life would be like, but without the cynicism and darkness that sometimes covers such treatments of superheroes.
Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow is the unoffical epilogue to the Pre-Crisis Superman, and for my money the best Superman story ever written. It’s the story of Superman’s last great battle against his foes. It’s an imaginary story, but then again, aren’t they all?
Grant Morrison is currently writing All-Star Superman, and it’s great! It doesn’t sync up with current continuity, but it’s a wonderful, weird, love letter to what made the Silver Age Superman so compelling.
In regular continuity, probably the most important story in recent years (besides perhaps Birthright, it’s good to find another fan of that, btw, it hasn’t been universally accepted by the fandom) is The Death of Superman saga (Collected in the Death of Superman, World Without a Superman, and the Return of Superman). It’s been condemned as a forerunner to event-driven comics, but taken on it’s own merits, I find it quite good.