[QUOTE=t-bonham@scc.net]
In our church, the Parish Council did its best to put a stop to this when it was first suggested by a ‘Faith Minister’. A long-time parish leader said quite bluntly “This is a Catholic church. We don’t do that here. If you wanna do that holy-roller crap, go down the street to the damn Baptist church.” There was significant agreement from others on the Council. That kind of killed it for a while.
Again, only if you have a weak-kneed, rubber-stamp Parish Council. After the above incident, our young priest tried to smooth it all over, saying “well, let’s just let people do whatever they choose to do, and see what they prefer”. But then he kept trying to sneakily push for it, like instead of introducing the Lords Prayer by reading “Let us pray” as the missal said, he would say “Let us join hands and pray”.
So eventually people from the Parish Council confronted him, along with the senior priest, saying that the Parish Council had already decided that they did not want this practice introduced at our Parish, and that it was not part of the official Roman Missal. He argued that “but many people seem to like this practice”. They responded “and many other people do NOT like it. And the people who don’t like it are the ones whose offerings keep this parish in the black!” That woke the senior priest up, and he immediately jumped into the discussion. The eventual decision was that the Mass would follow the Roman Missal, no more, no less.
That worked for a while, but that senior priest is now gone, and this practice seems to be creeping back. Lots of new people moving in are coming from parishes where it was done, and seem to just think that’s the way it is supposed to be.
Probably a losing battle, I guess. Maybe in a couple hundred years, a Vatican III Council will come along and clean all these kind of ‘attachments’ off the Mass, like Vatican II cleaned out a bunch of the junk added onto the Tridentine Mass over the years.
[/QUOTE]
This is so funny to me, because at my last parish it was the opposite…an overly-controlling parish council, and a pastor who couldn’t or wouldn’t stand up to them. There are several people on the council who are very involved in liturgy…one of them is a former nun who is some kind of expert in Children’s liturgy (that’s another whole topic that drives me nutty, but I won’t go there…) And they are always coming up with ideas to liven things up and make it more “welcoming.” I joined the liturgy committee to help put the kibosh on some of it, but it was like swimming upstream. I ended up leaving that parish, but my new one seems to actually be a little worse…the priest tends to make up his own Eucharistic Prayer, for instance. But, I have decided not to get involved this time. It’s too frustrating, and frankly, a little heartbreaking.