I got a bogus parking citation in the mail

I got a bogus parking citation in the mail today. It says my car was parked illegally in a location about 350 miles from my home on a certain day in June. That’s impossible; I was nowhere near that location on that day, or indeed this whole year.

Unfortunately I don’t know how I can prove that the citation is wrong. It has the correct license plate and make (Toyota). The model, VIN, and color are all missing.

Instructions are for me to write a letter explaining why I’m contesting the citation. I will do that, but with so little to go on I don’t hold out much hope.

Maybe you used your debit card somewhere that day? Or a timecard from work?

I had that happen – I was working in Boston, and my car was there, and the citation was in Miami. I called the number on the citation and explained that I had moved to Boston for a job and hadn’t been to Miami in five years.

It turned out that the meter maid wrote down the license plate number wrong. Apparently it happens.

I second turning in any proof that you and your car were elsewhere if you have it.

It is very likely a clerical error and your simple statement that you were not there will be enough to get it voided. I’ve seen it happen numerous times.

Unless they have an actual photo, I really don’t think you’ll have a big problem. The missing info on the ticket may also be points in your favor.

In the city where I live, they post pictures of the license plate on the city web site (if available). Have you checked if the issuer of the citation has such a thing available?

Toyota is a common enough type of car. Someone made a clerical error like getting a digit wrong or they wrote the wrong state or type of license plate down. I would also include in my written appeal as a separate issue, that the ticket was defectively written because the model, color, and VIN are missing and you would be unable to mount an effective defense.

I know that locally there is a very good web site for exchanging information about defending parking tickets in my city. Maybe you might try looking for a similar web site for the city that issued the ticket. Why don’t you post the name of the city? Someone might have some inside information.

I read about a guy whose license plate read NOPLATE because he couldn’t come up with a name he liked, so then it turned out that he was getting tons of tickets for illegally parked cars that had no license plate. He had to change his plate name.

Back when you used to get a whole new plate each year, with a new number, the police came to our house one March when my mother was in the middle of making Hamantaschen, looking for my father, the only adult male associated with a license plate that was on the car that had been stopped several hours earlier, and the driver had gotten out and punched the officer, then driven away. If you know that my father was short, wore glasses, was at the time pretty then, and very professorial in polished shoes and suits-- well, anyway, my mother showed them that Dodge Dart in the driveway, and it wasn’t the make and model they were looking for, but the plate was right.

Turned out that people who are willing to punch out cops at traffic stops are also not good about getting their plates renewed.

Anyway, they have heard it all. I once got a parking ticket because, and I am not making this up, the city installed a meter while I was parked there. Now, I was parked there for three days, and I probably should have checked on my car, but at any rate, I never thought that excuse would fly. It did, though, because they were able to look up whether or not there were new meters installed in the area where I was parked.

You may not even need proof-- just say you don’t live there, and wasn’t visiting on that day, or any other day. Send them a photocopy of your registration with your plate number, and address. Tell them it’s your real address. If you live in a no, or lenient inspections state, and the violation was in a strict inspections state, it may be a result of their cracking down on bogus registrations, which I can tell you happens, because my mother, without telling me, registered her car at my Indiana address for three years to get out of inspections.

I predict this will be easier than you think.

This happened.

As for the OP, we got a bogus citation like that once. I called in to contest it, and they brought up the photo of the car. “You drive a black Escalade?”

I said, no, we drove a shitty old red Hyundai. The lady at the BMV said, “It looks like they wrote the license number incorrectly.” They voided the ticket and all was well.

Thanks everybody, I feel a little more optimistic.

I don’t see anywhere on the citation where I can get any further information, e.g. a website with a picture of the car in question.

It could be a scam

Great, something else to be worried about.

The citation in question is from California, not Wisconsin. For whatever that’s worth.

Is it possible that somebody has cloned the OP’s license plate? This is a big problem here in the UK and has been for some years.

I don’t think it’s unheard of in the US, but I don’t think it’s as big of a problem, possibly because we can only get real license plates directly from the state. There are no mechanics with a stock of license plate blanks who will make anything if they’re slipped a $20 under the table.

It’s probably not relevant in this case, but there is a whole tier of “collection agencies” that follow up on minor traffic incidents, trying to collect. I have twice received very aggressive, intimidating letters from lawyers in this field about how I need to settle up this speeding ticket or this fender-bender charge from cities a thousand miles from where I’ve ever driven. A return letter to the effect that I’ve never even heard of West Horse’s Ass, Arkansas and certainly have never driven there and certainly didn’t last Thanksgiving weekend suffices. Adding an inquiry about the number for the local state bar usually gets a very polite and forelock-tugging response.

But if the OP’s note is from the state or jurisdiction itself, it’s a different case well-covered by the above answers.

it sure sounds like a scam. If it came through the mail, wouldn’t that and attempted fraud be a federal offense? You don’t mess with the post office.

StG

San Francisco?

Definitely call. In fact, look up the phone number for the city and department in question and call it directly.

My parents live near San Jose and had someone come to their door and try and get them to pay for overdue parking. They called the police. :slight_smile:

No, California State Parks, specifically Point Mugu State Park.

ETA: So far I haven’t found a phone number for their parking on their website. There is on the citation, of course, but it’s worthless for checking if it’s a scam.

We got a parking ticket from the city of Boston that was incorrect. The ticket was issued at 3 pm and neither of us work in the area where the ticket was written. I used their online system to send them a message advising them that we weren’t the ones who received that ticket and they sent us a message advising us to disregard it. They were really wonderful about it.

It’s those citations from Nigeria you have to worry about.

But if you send the money to me, I can fix it, I’m a Prince of a guy :slight_smile: