Dontgonearthe?
some morbid
Paul Bear Island
Sea Asket Isle
Coughin Island
Kree Maited Island
Decomposed Isle
Maggot Island
Obeliska Isles
Marrow Heart Islands
Greaves Cay
Albatross Rook
Truncheon Shoal
Bastille Island
Looms Isle
manavahë atoll
eta: manavahë is Tongan for fear
Cannibal Feast Island
Screaming Death Island
Malar Key
Stench Pit Island
Land Shark Key
Frequently Underwater Isle
Plague Key
Far Torture GAAAAAHS
Maybe look up the appropriate Patron Saint for sailors/ships/storms/what have you and name your island “Saint/San Something Or Other”?
Uwe Boll Island
That would be Saint Nicholas. Yes, That one.
If only “Christmas Island” wasn’t already taken, you could go the irony route! 
President Palin Island…that would scare the bejesus out of me!
Can you see Russia from there?
Nohope Atoll
Donner Island ----- No place for a party
Temporary.
Island Not Appearing In This Picture.
Medusa Island: The Raft of the Medusa - Wikipedia