Golly, sweetie, kudos to you for being such a caring mom, but really, kids that young barely understand what birthdays mean, let alone need a big birthday party bash.
With a One, especially, there’s no way he’s going to even vaguely comprehend what’s going on. With the Three, maybe invite one or two of her playgroup buddies, give them some cake, and leave it at that. Don’t make yourself crazy, okay?
Maybe we should have a short discussion of “the purpose of kids’ birthday parties”.
The purpose of kids’ birthday parties is the same as that of adult formal dinner parties–to pay off social obligations. It is not the same as adults’ birthday parties. An adult’s birthday party is more of a “come celebrate with me that I’m still alive!” kind of thing, not at all the same thing as kids. Kids invite each other to birthday parties because if Chelsea invited you to her party, you darn well better invite her to yours (I’m talking about the kid-to-kid interpersonal relations, not the parents).
Three-year-olds, however, frankly my dear don’t give a damn who didn’t get invited to whose party. They just plain don’t remember (unless of course somebody’s Mommy makes a Big Deal out of it). Threes are perfectly happy to assemble and eat cake and then go home.
Asking a One to comprehend the social obligation aspect of the birthday party is like asking a dog to understand it. Daisy the Beagle is perfectly happy to eat cake and go home, but she won’t understand why.
My advice: don’t sweat the games. Show them a Barney video if you feel you absolutely must provide entertainment. My WAG would be that you probably travel in a circle of people with a lot of over-achiever moms who DO provide the whole-hog entertainment package for their kids. Trust me, the only people who will be offended if you don’t play games at a toddler’s birthday party will be people whose opinions don’t matter very much anyway.
And P.S. I’ve got a 16-year-old, a 13-year-old, and a 10-year-old, so I know whereof I speak. Been there, done that…