I pit over-the-top Anti-Trump hysteria

Turn it around.

I’m at a small town protest. Lots of USA flags, lots of people waving signs.

Those signs say different things. Some of them say ICE Out. Some of them say No War On Canada, or on Denmark, or on Iran. Some of them say Release the Epstein Files. Some of them say Protect the Constitution; maybe referencing the First Amendment, or the Second, or the Fourth, or the power of the purse. Some of them say No Nazis in the USA. Some say No Tariffs, They’re Raising My Bills. Some say, Protect the Air We Breathe. Some say, Protect Trans Rights. Some say, Stop Hiding Black History. Somebody’s got a sign about Ukraine, somebody’s got one about Palestine, somebody’s got one about antisemitism in the Trump administration, somebody’s got one saying Our Diversity Is Our Strength.

I think maybe you mean to say that we shouldn’t chase anybody out for not carrying all those signs at once. But what you’re coming across as is saying that we should chase out everybody carrying a sign that’s not about the Constitution. And doing that wouldn’t concentrate a movement into doing one thing better. It would instead shrink it into uselessness.