If LotR Had Been Written By Someone Else!?

*With apologies to the late Freddy Mecury and Queen. Here is the first half. I’m too tired to finish the rest today. I’ll see if I can get it posted tomorrow unless someone wants to finish it…

Is this the One Ring?
Is this just fantasy?
Just formed a Fellowship
No escape from prophecy
Open your eyes
Look up in the skies and see
I’m just a dwarf, don’t need any sympathy
There’s Legolas with his bow
Aragorn brooding more
Anywhere the Ring goes, the Nazgul will be searching, for me

Frodo, just killed an orc
Put a dagger against his head
One thrust and now he’s dead
Frodo, you are the One
But the Ring is such heavy weight
Frodo, ooo
You very nearly died
That cave troll gave us cause for sorrow
Moria, Moria, we really shouldn’t be here

Too late, balrog has come
Sends shivers down my spine
Gandalf’s shouting out a rhyme
Goodbye everybody – I’ve got to go
Gotta leave you all behind, so save the world
Frodo, ooo – (anywhere the Ring goes)
I just want to cry
I sometimes wish Bilbo had never fallen at all

Oh, hey! Wow, I’m totally sorry. Missed that one. Your’s is great, To Eat or Not To Eat…

laughs

Sorry for copying your idea, though!

By the way, to those who were talking about the secret diaries, if you want to know more about them, you can check out the author’s (Cassandra Claire) LiveJournal. She posts all of her new VSDs on this site. http://www.livejournal.com/users/cassieclaire/

~Aya~
http://www.livejournal.com/users/limmenel
http://envisioning.cjb.net

While I liked that earlier e.e. cummings version, it wasn’t the type of e.e. cummings poem I wanted to see – maybe just a matter of different periods in his work. This one bubbled around in my brain until I let it write itself down.

precious) downward
my) the heat rises
O) the mountain rises

like a mouth the earth
swallows
greedily

a finger without its hand
a body without its soul
an evil without its power

bright sun on us both)
remembering(
bobbing forth and back)
my birthday(
he was greedy like the earth)
one life begins(
one life ends)
river like a mouth, cold, hot
ring like a mouth, devouring
consumed i must consume

(Sméagol?)

the ring (O
and the body (my
are consumed (precious

“It’s 200 miles to Mount Doom, we’ve got a full pack of lembas, no pipe-weed, it’s dark and we’re wearing elf-cloaks.”

By the author of CASEY AT THE BAT:

It looked extremely rocky for the Moria nine that day;
The orcs were hot upon their trail, a chasm barred the way.
Though Aragorn had drawn his sword and Frodo pulled out Sting,
Still a pallor wreathed the features of the bearers of the Ring.

Upon the stricken Company a deathlike silence fell;
The Balrog burst across the flames like something sent from Hell.
A fiery mane streamed backward from his bony eyebrow ridge -
But Gandalf, mighty Gandalf, was advancing to the bridge!

The Men ran back to lend support, the Hobbits raised a cheer,
And Legolas and Gimli felt a lightening of their fear.
To all, the Balrog seemed but just a pesky little midge -
They’d put up even money now, with Gandalf at the bridge!

And now the wizard lifts his staff, and now he lets it go,
And now the bridge is shattered by the force of Gandalf’s blow.
The Balrog fell adown the deep, with fiery whistling breeze,
But as he fell, his curling whip caught Gandalf by the knees.

Oh, somewhere else in Middle-earth the sun is shining bright,
And somewhere elves are plinking harps, and somewhere hearts are light.
And somewhere dwarves are singing songs, and hobbit-children shout -
But there is no joy in Moria; mighty Gandalf has struck out.

In my younger and more vulnerable years my uncle’s friend Gandalf gave me a ring that I’ve been turning over in my hand ever since.
“Whenever you feel like giving up,” He told me, “Just remember that all the people in this world aren’t as able to resist its power as you are.”

(Pages of observation and acquiantance-making. Proceed to very obvious references to T.S. Eliott’s poetry.)

About halfway between The Shire and Mordor, the road hastily joins a another, so as to shrink away from a certain desolate area of land. This is a valley of marshes.
But above the gray land and spasms of murky water, you perceive, after a moment, the eye of a Dark Lord Sauron. The eye of Sauron is red and gigantic. It looks out of no face, but, instead, a huge tower. Evidently put there to scare the crap out of me everytime I stick that ring on my finger.

(Again, later.)

“We feel far away from Precious,” Gollumsby said. He wanted nothing less of the Ring that it jump from the chain around my neck and return to him. After it had, he could obliterate years of lisping melodramatically in his cave. “It doesn’t understand. It used to be able to understand. We’d sit for hours—”
He broke off, stumbling around the weedy growth of the marshes.
“We’s going to fix everything just the way it was before,” he said, nodding determinedly. “It’ll see.”
He talked a lot about the past, and I gathered that he wanted to recover something, some idea of himself, something that he had lost along with the Ring.

Samuel R Delany

The door to Bag End deliquesced, and the derelict lurched into the hall.

He was an old man. He was a strong man. Must be Gandalf, Frodo thought. Dresses like Gandalf, grey robed, a rope holding up his torn grey pants. And his eyes. (Orcs’ eyes?).

“You , boy. Are you Frodo Baggins?”

Frodo fingered the dirt between his hairy toes. Wanting to say “no” he began a “yes”.

The codger flapped out a hand (a sack of magic-ruined knuckles) and caught a chair. “We were moving out, boy, the lights of Minas Tirith like a puddle of molten mithril on our left, the black of Mordor on our right. We’d turned off the palantir so we were flying blind. Then, centred on the dark, an Eye! It reached out, brighter than the elven-glass of Galadriel, grabbed our attention so we couldn’t look away.”

Frodo got the words ready in his mouth, excuse me, huh? I gotta go.

Gandalf coughed, spat red. “The Eye was Sauron’s. He took us this close” - his thumb brushed his forefinger (nail bitten to the quick) - “this close” - to Mount Doom. You can damn him, and damn the One Ring for that, boy, whoever you are!"

From the King James Version of the Lord of the Rings

v. 14. Verily, verily I say onto you, he that doth bear this ring in his own name has no part of me, and shall be cast off from the house of the Elven Lord, and there shall be much wailing and gnashing of teeth.
15. But he that doth bear this ring for the sake of others, even unto his own despair, unto he shall be given great esteem, and shall not be subject unto my everlasting vexation, but shall dwell in the halls of Valinor forever.
16. And Gandalf said onto them, Fear not, for behold, I bring you glad tidings, which shall be to all Elves.
17. For unto us is come this day, in the Refuge of Imladris, a savior, which is Frodo Baggins.
18. And this shall be a sign unto you, ye shall find the hobbit with three brethen, led through the wilderness of one Aragorn son of Arathorn, lying in a bier.
19. And all the Elves hearkened unto his voice and were pleased. And unto Glorfindal was given great burdens, to forsake the comforts of Imladris, which in translation is Rivendell, and to seek the hobbits in the wilderness.
20. And behold, Meriadoc, son of Seradoc, and Peregrin, son of Paladin, and Samwise (which is he who would be called Gardener) son of Hamfast, went forth, bereft of hope and joy, to seek some happy gospel as bequethed them by Aragorn (he who would be King of both Arnor and Gondor, and ruler of the same) known as kingsfoil, which in the Elvish tongue was athelas.
21. (For Aragorn, son of Arathorn, was wise in the craft of the wilderness dwellers, and lore of the ancient Numernoreans). Amen.

William Carlos Williams anyone?
This Is Just To Say

I have taken
the ring
that was on
your chain

and which
you were probably
trying
to destroy.

Forgive me
it was my precious
so bright
and so gold.

-Love Gollum

okay–giving credit where credit is due–this one comes from my rockin sister!! it’s pretty darn brilliant if i do say so myself. and… pretty darn BRITNEY! haha. yeah, so get ready for
Gollum’s serenade to his precious:

Slave 4 U
All you hobbits look at me like I’m a little freak.
Well did you ever think that it’s the ring that’s makin’ me so weak?

Always saying little freak don’t try and run and hide.
Well I’m just tryin’ to free myself from the villain deep inside
Get it get it, get it get it (NOOO!)
Get it get it, get it get it (NOOOO!)(Do you want it?)
Get it get it, get it get it (NOOOOO!)(You know want it!)

I know I may come off tricksy, I may come off sly.
But I feel like singing, feel like dancing when the ring catches my eye.

What I want’s what I can’t have. What the hell, who cares?
All I know is I’m so happy when I see it shining there.

I’m a slave for you. I cannot hold it; I cannot control it.
I’m a slave for you. I won’t deny it; I’m only trying to hide it.

Precious, don’t you wanna, come back to me,
To another time and place.
Precious, don’t you wanna, come back to me
Leaving behind my name, my face.
(Lets go!)

(Like that)
(You like it)
(Now come to me!)

Get it get it, get it get it (NOOO!)
Get it get it, get it get it (NOOOO!)
Get it get it, get it get it (NOOOOO!)
[Panting]

I really wanna own you for myself,
(Wanna see you on me)
I really wanna do what you want me to.
(Uh Uh Uh)

Precious, don’t you wanna, come back to me,
To another time and place.
Precious, don’t you wanna, come back to me
Leaving behind my name, my face.
(Lets go!)

I’m a slave for you. (Take it!) I cannot hold it; I cannot control it.
I’m a slave (It just feels right) for you. (It just feels good)
I won’t deny it; I’m not trying to hide it. (Precious!)

Get it get it, get it get it (NOO!)
Get it get it, get it get it (NOOO!)
Get it get it, get it get it (NOOOO!)
[Panting]

I’m a slave for you. (Here we go now)
I cannot hold it; I cannot control it.
I’m a slave for you. (Here we go) I won’t deny it, (Yessssss!)
I’m not trying to hide it.

(Want that!)

The Unfortunate Hobbits by Edward Gorey

Atop the hill from old Bag End,
Wandered a hobbit and his friend;
They’ve left with a ring,
They’ve gone with a sting,
A fellowship they must attend.

On Weathertop Frodo’s remark,
‘I wish that I did not embark’,
Was met with alarm,
Which led to his harm,
He was pierced by a knife in the dark.

We decided to greet Durin’s Bane,
But the Balrog failed to entertain;
He implored us to sit
By the edge of a pit;
Our guide fell and came not back again.

The world fell into a decline,
For the past all the creatures did pine;
In the fog of the gloom
We trudged to Mount Doom,
Our foes could do nothing but whine.

In the fire the ring burned and broke,
And we saw that our quest was a joke;
Our race is now ending,
So why keep pretending?
Our laughs echoed up through the smoke.

:smiley:

Thank you, AirBear!

Epigramcracker, tell your sister that one is hysterical.

That was damned good. Have I mentioned I love this thread? Anyway, I want to submit one more request. It is a fantastically difficult one, of course, so if no one is up to the challenge, I understand: LotR as a Chick Tract.
Also, of interest to visitors from theonering.net/SDMB newbies who also happen to be Simpsons fans: You might want to check out my thread, A Shadow Has Fallen On Middle Springfield-Who should be who in The Simpsons do LotR?

Epigramcracker, the William Carlos Williams one was absolutely brilliant. Kudos. :slight_smile:

Sonnets from the Elvish, by Elizabeth Barrett Browning

43

An Ode to a Ring

How do I loves theeeeee…? Letssss Gollum count the wayssss…
I loves theeee to the deeps and breadths and heights
Gollum’s soul can reach, when feeeeeling out of sight
For the endsss of Beeeeings and ideal Grace.
I loves theeeee to the level of everyday’s
Most quiet need, by nasssty Sun and candle lightsss.
I loves theeee freely, as men strive for Right;
I loves theeee purely, as they turn from Praise.
I loves theeee with the passion put to use
In my old griefsss, and with my childhood’s faith.
I loves theeee with a love I seeeeemed to loooose
With my lost saintsss - I loves theeeee with the breathsss,
Smilesss, tearsss, of all Gollum’s life! - and, if Master chooses,
I shall but loves theeee better after death…my precioussss…

Apocalypse Vow

– A Francis Ford Coppola adaptation of Lord of Darkness, by Joseph Conrad

Weathertop, I was still at Weathertop. It’s been weeks now, on the mission, and every minute Sauron gets stronger and The Ring feels heavier. I wish every day this ring had never come to me. I was going to the worst place in Middle Earth, and I didn’t even know it yet, up the River Anduin and through the wretched swamps directly into Sauron’s lair. It was by no accident that I got to be the caretaker of Sauron’s manifestation. There is no way to tell its story without telling my own.

My mission was to proceed up the River Anduin, pick up Sauron’s trail in Mordor, follow it, and find Mount Doom, The Ring’s birthplace, infiltrate it, and terminate the Ring’s power, with extreme prejudice.

[much later … ]

The more I got to know the Ring, the more I admired it. I was at the far reaches of Middle Earth. It was devoid of life, a place of decay and melancholy, as if all living things had forsaken it. He is dead, thought I about Sauron as I toyed with the ring–wondering whether I had been striving against someone completely without substance, or whether his substance truly did manifest itself in The Ring. Sauron discoursed, a subliminal voice, “We must appear in the nature of supernatural beings—with the might of a deity—we can exert all of our will and all of our power upon them for might, and great things unbounded.” The eloquence covered the malice of his dark dark ring. The wastes of my weary brain were haunted by wraith-ish images, obsessively revolving around this ring of noble expression. A burning eye … he was very little more than a burning eye glaring out from an impenetrable darkness. I began seeing very clearly what needed to be done … but had difficulty thinking clearly enough to be able to do it. I am beyond caring. The Horror.

This thread is great!

My apologies if this has been done already…

Whose swamp this is, I think I know
He lives up in that tower though
I hope he doesn’t see me here
To watch his marshes all aglow.

My Sam and I have much to fear
Especially with Gollum here
He wants my pretty ring to take
But promises to lead us near.

“A bad plan, Frodo, and no mistake”
Says Sam, “it’s not the path I’d take.
All Gollum does is whine and weep
And I don’t trust the little fake.”

This swamp is smelly, dark, and deep.
But I have promises to keep.
And miles to go before I sleep,
And miles to go before I sleep.

aww thanks!!
(and thanks Arden Ranger–my sister and i bow. XD)

oh my god. i love this smiley: :wally :wally :wally

“You know there isn’t going to be any war,” said Arwen, bored. “It’s all just talk. Why, Glorfindel told Pa just last week that our commissioners in Minas Morgul would come to—to—an----amicable agreement with Mr. Sauron about the West. And, anyway, the Nazgul are too scared of us to fight. There won’t be any war, and I’m tired of hearing about it.”

“Not going to be any war!” cried the two Elves indignantly, as though they had been defrauded.

“Why, honey, of course there’s going to be a war,” said Legolas. “The Nazgul may be scared of us, but after Aragorn gave them a whipping day before yesterday up on Weathertop, they’ll have to fight or stand branded as cowards before the whole world. Why, the Council----”

Arwen made a mouth of bored impatience.

“If you say ‘war’ just once more, I’ll go in the house and shut the door. I’ve never gotten so tired of any one word in my life as ‘war’, unless it’s ‘Ring.’ Pa talks war morning, noon, and night, and all the gentlemen who come to see him shout about the One Ring and the spreading darkness and Sauron till I get so bored I could just scream! And that’s all the boys talk about too, that and their old Fellowship. There hasn’t been any fun at any party this spring because the boys can’t talk about anything else. If you say ‘war’ again I’ll go in the house.”
–<i>Gone With the Ring</i> by Margaret Mitchell

YES! I’M JUST IN TIME!!
Okay, guys, here we go. Seasonal and everything. I give you:

The Night Before Christmas, LOTR Style

’Twas the night before Christmas and all through the Shire
Not a hobbit was stirring, save one, near a fire.
A tension he felt growing strong in the air,
And suddenly Gandalf was standing right there!

The wizard looked scared, like he’d just seen a wraith,
But he said, “Is it secret?” and then “Is it safe??”
And Frodo, attending with much less than glee,
Pulled out Bilbo’s ring for the wizard to see.

Gandalf ran to the fire, his purpose pursuing;
As he threw in the ring Frodo cried, “What you doing?”
But Gandalf ignored him, for he was no fool;
He pulled it right out and said, “Here, it’s quite cool!”

Outside on the lawn Sam was trimming the verge,
But to eavesdrop on Gandalf he soon felt the urge,
But what to his listening ears did unfurl,
But a plan laid by Sauron to take over the world!

Inside the old Wizard explained to young Frodo
That the terrible ring was a definite no go.
Some words had formed on it in quite a short time,
And Gandalf to Frodo repeated this rhyme:

“Now One Ring! To rule them!
Now One Ring! To find them!
Now One Ring! To bring them!
And in darkness bind them!
In the dark land of Mordor
Where the black shadows lie,
It is there you must go!
It is there you must fly!”

Frodo looked on in horror—was not the ring safe?
They could hide it right here with none knowing its place!
But Gandalf said old Gollum’s tongue had been waggin’—
He’d said only two words; they were “Shire” and “Baggins!”

Little Frodo did know as he stood there in pain,
There were Nazgul abroad cutting hobbits in twain!
He tried his Plan B: Gandalf should take the ring!
But the wizard refused the abominable thing.

So our hero had only one thing left to do.
He must “Leave, and leave quickly” ere Black Riders got through!
A bundle of food he flung onto his back,
And the ring, to keep safe, in his pocket he packed.

His eyes—how they blinked! He was nervous for sure.
The quest would be deadly, and the ring’s taint, impure.
All at once his heart jumped as a clunk came outside—
Gandalf pulled in old Sam, saying “I’ll tan your hide!”
Samwise stammered and stuttered and made comic quips,
But the wizard looked wary and pursed his old lips.
So for spying, young Gamgee got a fate worse than death—
He must ditch his dear garden and come on the quest!

Though quite chubby and plump, with a love for things Elf,
Samwise gulped with suspicion in spite of himself.
And as Gandalf rode off, he looked straight on ahead,
With a look that said, “Yeah. Well, I’d rather be dead.”

He and Frodo spoke not but went straight to their work,
Bringing Merry and Pippin along as a perk.
But a wraith found their trail, and, unable to tarry,
They took off like a shot for old Buckleberry Ferry!

They ran and they ran, leaving Frodo for last,
And he flew off the dock for the ferry right fast,
And I heard him exclaim as they rowed out of sight,

“Some Christmas this is! Gandalf’s presents sure bite!”