If LotR Had Been Written By Someone Else!?

LoTR by John Gray

On Mars, the men are interested in the goal of getting the Ring to the volcano. They may become depressed if they doubt their usefullness to the cause of the Ring. The character of Aragorn shows us the male tendency toward “caving”. He has withdrawn to objectively process what is going on in his life. Eventually he can return to process his feelings about the ring.

Meanwhile, the Venusians want to talk about their feelings regarding the ring. They don’t need to be given solutions by the Martians. They can support the Martians in their quest by Appreciating, Accepting and Trusting them.

LoTR by St. John

In the beginning was the ring. And the ring was with Sauron and the ring was Sauron. The same was in the beginning with Sauron. All things were made dark by the ring, and without it was not anything made dark that was made dark. In it was death, and the death was the darkness of men.

Think of this song with the theme to Spider-man cartoon in your head.

Saruman, Saruman
Does whatever a wizard can,
Casts a spell, serves an eye
Just an all around evil guy
Look out
Here comes that Saruman

Look out
The Ring is a source of power
Gandalf badly needs a shower
Here comes that Saruman

How about VH-1’s Behind the Magic: Frodo Baggins?

NARRATOR: Frodo Baggins thought he had it all… a spacious hobbit-hole, an inheritance to last a lifetime, even his own personal gardener. But years of travel and a pipe-weed addiction brought it all crashing down around him. Tonight, we’ll ask friends…
SAMWISE: …it was about that time he started hitting the lembas pretty hard. He’d be on his fourth cake before second breakfast, he would…
NARRATOR: …acquaintances…
INNKEEPER: …left me inn without so much as a word, with ‘orrible screamin’ goin’ on at all hours of the night and the sheets and pillows all ripped to shreds…
NARRATOR: …and enemies…
GOLLUM: We hatess tricksy hobbittses!
NARRATOR: …about this “Bad-boy of Bag-end,” his meteoric rise, and crashing fall.
I wanted to do a Jack Chick tract, but Frankd6 beat me to it with an outstanding one! I still think my favorite of the whole thread is Epigramcracker’s William Carlos Williams one… Just brilliant.

“Battlefield Middle-Earth” by Elrond Hubbard :smack:

No need for text as the style would be quite unreadable anyway.

myrthynn: kudos on the Verne, excellently done.

Here’s a shot at the first stanza of *To Arwen, *derived from Poe’s *To Helen. * The speaker is to be imagined as Aragorn.

*To Arwen *

Arwen, thy beauty is to me
Like famed Earendil’s ship of yore,
That over the dark, forbidden sea
The wayworn mortal messenger bore
To reach the Undying Shore.
Improvements/continuations welcome!

“Stopping by the Mines of Moria on a Snowy Evening”
by Robert Frost
Whose Ring this is, I think I know;
His tower is in Mordor, though.
His Eye won’t see us stopping here
To run away from all this snow.

Our pony Bill must think us queer
For taking our baggage off his rear,
Between the wall and murky lake
Outside these mines that Aragorn fears.

The Hobbits give their feet a shake–
No dinner?! There is some mistake!
The only other sound’s the sweep
of slimy tentacles breaking the gate.

The Mines are lovely, dark and deep.
But Sam’s got promises to keep,
And miles to go before he sleeps,
And miles to go before he sleeps.

:wink:

Elrond Hubbard, that was awful, I mean even without a single word of the text… elrond… it was there the whole time.

I salute you for your cleverness, although it is painful…:rolleyes:

This is so great. I love them all, especially Douglas Adams Mark Twain, Ayn Rand, Harry Potter, and most definitely the Terry Pratchett one. Too funny! :slight_smile:

Cause the DBZ one amused me… (though idea of an over-muscled Gandalf makes me shudder)

LOTR, as written by Naoko Takeuchi…
*
Fighting evil by moonlight
Winning love of Sam by daylight
Always injured in a real fight,
He is the one named Frodo Moon!

He will never turn his back on a friend,
Though the Ring has a wicked trend.
He is the one on whom we can depend.
He is the one named Sailor …

… Sailor Shire!
… Sailor Lorien!
… Sailor Gondor!
… Sailor Rivendell!

With his magic ring,
driving him insane
He is the one named Frodo Moon!

Fighting evil by moonlight
Winning love of Sam by daylight…
With his Sailor Fellows Nine to help fight,
He is the one named Frodo Moon!
He is the one named Frodo Moon!

He is the one… Frodo Moon!
*

Hehehhe Another n00b jumps on board the for the One Thread, with this humble offering by…

<center><b>They Might Be Dwarven <i>Moria</i></b>

Moria was Khazad-dûm, now it’s Moria, not Khazad-dûm

Been a long time gone, old Khazad-dûm

Now it’s orcish delight in the endless night

Every orc in Khazad-dûm lives in Moria, not Khazad-dûm

So if you’ve a date in Khazad-dûm, she’ll be waiting in Moria.

Even Lorien was once Laurelindorinan

Why they changed it I can’t say, people just liked it better that way

So take me back to Khazad-dûm, no you can’t go back to Khazad-dûm

Now it’s Moria, not Khazad-dûm, why did Khazad-dûm get the works?

That’s nobody’s business but the Dwarves. </center>

<i>Mercilessly filked from They Might Be Giants’ “Istanbul” </i>

<center>------------------------------------------------------------------ </center>
Or to take another track, theres the EULA…

This is a legal agreement (“Agreement”) between you (either an individual or an entity), the end user (“RingBearer”), and Sauron Corporation (“Doomsoft”). BY WEARING, DISPLAYING OR OTHERWISE USING THE RING (AS DEFINED BELOW), YOU AGREE TO BE BOUND BY THE TERMS OF THIS AGREEMENT. IF YOU DO NOT AGREE TO THE TERMS OF THIS AGREEMENT, DO NOT WEAR, DISPLAY OR USE THE RING.

DOOMSOFT CORPORATION LICENSE AGREEMENT FOR PRERELEASE HARDWARE

Doomsoft Mobile Invisibility Toolkit Beta 2 Accompanying this Agreement is a prerelease copy of the Doomsoft hardware identified above, which includes hardware and related documentation and information (collectively the “One Ring”). The One Ring is protected by copyright laws and international copyright treaties, as well as other intellectual property laws and treaties. The One Ring is licensed, not sold.
Keep up all this fabulous writing!

Terribly enjoying all the brilliant versions—
however the vast majority of could have been writers have been picked from the English speaking world

I have seen several Binary versions but real Geeks would write LotR in c, c++ or perl ( though a smalltalk version would be interesting ) but that is beside the point I was trying to make:

Obvious choices for Authors from Germany ( I’m not touching that with a citzen of Poland that is 3 meters tall ) are:

J.W.Goethe and obviously the “Faust”.
Friedrich Schiller: either “Wilhelm Tell” or “Die Raeuber”
Gothhold Ephraim Lessing: based on “Nathan” ( hey it contains ‘the Ring parable’ )
Guenter Grass either “Blechtrommel” or “Ritterkreuztraeger”
Heinrich Boell “Die verlorene Ehre der Katharina Blum” into “die verlorene Ehre des Smeagol”

Further fun could be found by rewriting Dante ( Inferno!) or Voltaire ( Samwise or ‘the best of all possible worlds’)
but I would not exclude “Cyrano de Baggins” either.
Flaubert could have written Madame Baggins-Sackville.

Also interesting could be a strict socialist rewrite in the fine tradition of the people who made out Shakespeare as a proto socialist.

I have never attempted to read Karl Marx but
“The Ring Manifesto” has a certain ring to it (sorry )
And it shouldbe possible to find parallels between the RED[!] book of Westmarch and the little red book of chairman Mao.

1001 Nights is full of magic rings so “Ali Baba and the 40 Nazgul” is not impossible.

One might also attempt exeedingly bad taste with “Sauron: My Fight” or even the musical version “Springtime for Sauron”.

Also (yet) missing is LotR in full buerocratese.

Hoping that this post - while not supplying actual rewrites - has at least given some inspiration.

awesome! i love tmbg! rock out. i’ll try “They Got Lost.”

They Got Lost (also ripped off from They Might Be Giants!)

Sauron down in Mordor thinks they’ll be here any minute now…
But He’s running out of patience and His eye is wand’ring anyhow…
They can feel Him searching for them from from out in Barad-dur…
But they’re in Emyn Muil and which way to go they’re not really sure…

I heard they might be down near the Anduin’s mouth…
Frodo and Sam got lost wandering down south!

Gamgee said to Baggins, “I think we make a left at this rock…
There should be a big swamp, assuming that the path isn’t blocked…”
Frodo looked over and he said, “We’ve been here before!
We’re just going round in circles and it’s getting to be quite a bore!”

I heard they might be down near the Anduin’s mouth…
Frodo and Sam got lost wandering down south!

<insert guitar riffs and repeats, etc>


Hooray for TMBG fans! XD
-epi

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by cerberus uberunderdog *
**IRON CHEF – LEMBAS BATTLE

I nearly fell off my chair! But the Witchking is at a severe disadvantage here; please accept my offering of 3 more dishes for him to serve.
Challenger Witchking is offering 2 dishes:

  • Filet of Fell Beast topped with a Lembas-crumb crust

  • Scorched Malice Cake Flambe – in the shape of Orthanc, with a ring of fire around it

  • Dead Marsh Watercress salad with Lembas Croutons

  • Warg Broth and Lembtzo Ball Soup

  • Shredded Roasted Steed of Rohan, in a cream sauce, over sliced toasted Lembas

There, that makes it a more even contest. <grin>

RE Joss Whedon’s-

is that Samya Gamgankya the ex-Balrog or Sammow Gamwistein the “homely nerd/undercover hottie/aspiring wizette & eventual lesbian” (who eventually hooks up with Tarosie)?

per request
–note, bishounen and all of its derivatives (e.g. bish-y, bishiness) means ‘general all-around pretty-boy’–

(by the way i bow down to all of you!!! you’re amazing!)

PART I. The Dark Forces and the Fellowship

the history of all of middle earth is the history of power struggle.

dwarf and elf, gondor and rohan, dark overlords and wizards, samwise gamgee and the gaffer, have stood in constant opposition to each other, carried on in both in secret and in open war for ages, over who exactly is the most bishounen of all.

in all of history, there has been an order of society: the elves dominate, making even pointy ears look hot. the men, while cute, spend too much time in the mud. plus they all fancy themselves prettier than the rest of their companions. the wizards, while not very bish-y, do lead around all the bishes and are cool by association. then the dwarves, well, we can just skip right on past them, can’t we?

so this little heirarchy of bishitude, while causing enviousness from basically everyone but the elves, and probably the wizards (although you never can tell with those maiads), was simply accepted as the way of middle earth.

then a gent called sauron came along and got together some evil friends, all of whom were incredibly ugly. and they wanted desparately to be bishounen, but just couldn’t see how ugly they really were. poor chaps. so they came around and stirred up some animosity by handing out rings to some elves, men, and dwarfs, saying that ‘the more your race got, the bishier you were’ which, of course, stirred up even more animosity, since they gave the elves 3, dwarfs 7, and men 9. so they all were used as pawns into the dark lord’s evil chess game of bishiness. all they had to do was beat each other up enough to make them all hideous beyond recognition, and the orcs could finally feel pretty.

but one man named isildur had his eye on a golden ring that the dark lord was keeping for himself. he cut it off his hand with a broken sword and took it for his own. and he pranced around gondor wearing his ring, but realised soon that it made him so pretty he was invisble to all other eyes. just completely beyond the bishy limits of the eyes of men.

so no one was surprised when he died and the ring disappeared. some ugly hobbit with a horrible grasp of grammar took the golden ring and turned into a frog-man. not very bishy. not at all.

meanwhile the rest of the races middle earth were just bishing about, hating each other. silly silly creatures.

the frog-man lost his golden ring to a hairy guy named bilbo who was not bishy at all, even without the feet. but he took it home and hung out with all the other hobbits for a long time. the ring, it seemed, did have a l’oreal effect after all, it was observed, when bilbo was the youngest looking hobbit at the hobbiton nursing home. but alas, he started to go froggy and gave it to his nephew, who was very very much a bishounen reincarnated into a hairy-footed hobbit for bad behaviour in a past life.

so he and some pals, who were not very fond of the ring and the company that came along with it when the dark lord (rising again to power) found out from frog-man that he had the golden ring and sent out some super-ugly wraiths to deal with him. so frodo and his non-bishy-but-heartwarmingly-loyal pals set off for the elves’ bachelor pad in rivendell to give them a birthday present. after all, they were bishy, now weren’t they? they’d know what to do with such an artifact.

well after much trouble they made it to rivendell and tried to pass it on to someone else. however, it seemed that there was a meeting of the middle-earth chapter of the u.n. going on at the same time.

so they brought the ring to them, but of course they just talked and talked and talked about it but didn’t actually do anything. something about vetos.

so the bishy-hobbit, now fully equipped with a stab wound and psychic ring-connection, snatched back the ring. jealous of the bishy air this hobbit could produce in spite of his giant feet, two men, a wizard, a dwarf, and an elf all said they’d help him destroy it for the sake of middle earth. so all the other hobbits got jealous and signed up.

and that’s how the fellowship was formed.

the esential condition for the existence, and for the sway of the fellowship, is the destruction of the golden ring; the condition for that destruction is hard labour and compromises of bishitude. the creation of the new dark forces, whose promoter is saruman, replaces the need for fellowshippers to feel pretty, due to the overall abundance of nasty orcs, and their association with the elf legolas, the bishiest of all bishounen. what saruman and sauron, therefore, are producing in these orcs and other evil alliances, is its own downfall (once someone finally decides to get them a mirror and they realize how hopeless their case is). plus, this is only the first half of three long-ass books. their fall and the victory of the fellowship are equally inevitable.

Arda. Middle-Earth. Elven planet.

To understand Aragorn Ellesar Telcontar, one must remember the land of his youth and the intense contrast to the land he eventually ruled. Ellesar did not become a king because he was a hero. He became a hero because he was a king.
-from Princess Arwen Perehil’s Ellessar Explained, FO 120

[sub]I couldn’t for the life of me remember if Dune had been done, so don’t jeer me if it has…[/sub]

Along the Iron Chef routine … for Shredded Roasted Steed of Rohan … you could have Hasufel Hasenpfeffer … but he’s the wrong breed of meat

well i just thought of this…

j.r.r. tolkien was born 3 january 1892, making today his 110th birthday! next year he’d be eleventy-one…someone should do a tribute

Hasulfel Hasenpfeffer leading me to request a Bugs Bunny routine (Gollum hunting wabbits) for anyone with the inspiration …