If LotR Had Been Written By Someone Else!?

I must say, I loved the Joseph Heller ones, since Catch-22 is one of my all time favorite books. And the Gilbert and Sullivan parodies are truly inspired. This is one hell of a thread! =)

Now my own contribution for any of those who happen to listen to punk rock.

Ring Bearer, by MxPx

Well he’s a ring bearer, if ya know what I mean
The way the Nazgul flock to him, well ya should have seen
The guy yeah, he’s got style and it’s plain to see
He’s best dressed in a mithril vest and he’s only 3-foot-3

Too bad he split up with Strider
Off to Mordor, can’t let nothing stall 'em
He’d better keep that ring off
And keep a pretty close eye on Gollum

He knows when orcs are around thanks to his sword, Sting
It glows blue and he knows to go hide and protect the Ring
All he has to eat is lambas and the water’s not the freshest
Still he pushes to go on to Mt. Doom and cast in the precious

Too bad he split up with Strider
Off to Mordor, can’t let nothing stall 'em
He’d better keep that ring off
And keep a pretty close eye on Gollum

Ring bearer
Ring bearer
Ring bearer
Ring bearer, yeah

Thought of another good one but I don’t know if it’s been done yet…didn’t have the time to browse all 28 pages (geez this thread is LONG!!!)

Anybody care to do one by Nostradamus? =)

The Battle of Helm’s Deep, as told by Col. McBragg from Rocky and Bullwinkle.

”So there we were, ten thousand Uruk-Hai heading up the walls, and me with just my handy elephant gun ten cases of bubble gum, and case of fizzy drink.

“My Goodness, how ever did you survive?"

"Simple! I took the bullets out of my gun and started to chew the gum. At the same time I shook every bottle of fizzy drink I could find as hard as I could! When I had all ten cases of gun chewed I placed great gobs of it into my gum and used the now nearly exploding drinks to shoot huge bubbles at the Orks.
The Uruk-Hai attacked the great pink bubbles and they exploded, showering the enemy with sticky pop and bubble gum, sticking them fast to where they stood!
And that is how I won the Battle of Helm’s Deep!”

And now the Isengaurd Highschool Marching band with our High School Fight Song!

Uruk-Hai! Uruk-Hai!
Watch the Whitehands as they fly!
And the human’s are all gonna die!
Uruk-Hai!Uruk-Hai!
We’ll get those hobbit and they’ll fry!
And the human’s are all gonna die!
Well it’s Hi Hi HO!
Rohan’s got to go!
Watch our bloody banners flying High High High!
Well it’s Hi Hi Hee!
We’ll kill 'em at Old Helm’s Deep!
And the Humans are all gonna Die!

Monolog of the Rings.

Johny Carson. :“What about that Suron? Is he a nut or what? I head that in Mordor it’s so dark…”

How Dark Is It?

“It’s so dark in Mordor that even if he had a hand Suron still couldn’t see it in front of his Great Big Eye!”

Ed McMan "You are correct sir! Huh Huh Huh!

Johny: “They say those Hobbits are something else too. They say in the Shire all Hobbits do all day is eat, drink and sleep. With Qualifications like that they could run for Congress.”

“Now the Nazgul have me a little worried. Scary fellows. I saw one yesterday giving an L.A. Cop a hard time.”

“And is that Arwyn a babe or what? I tell you, I almost called Leonard Nemoy and asked to borrow his Mr. Spock Costume just to get the ears.”

“And you never see Arwyn’s mother in Rivendell either. Judging my the look on Elrond’s face she got the better of the divorce.”

“But I kid the elves. I love the elves. How can you not love someone that remembers Dick Clark in Diapers?”

“We have a great show for you tonight. Tom Bombadill is here with his new book, and we have a brand new comedian with us tonight. Gimli, son of Gloin, so stick around.”

Classic golf swing and cut to commercial.

Cor, juice, gloat!

Curses, curses, shoud hav thort of doing the classics myself.

i can’t see if anyone’s done a Neil Gaiman version yet. no way am i up to that standard. i usually dont do this sort of thing, but here’s my attempt.

I wouldn’t be here if it weren’t for that Gandalf wizard. Everyone knows he’s a pimp to us hobbits. My uncle was his favourite a generation ago; his memoirs include a tale about an orgy Gandalf had him do with a dragon and a bunch of dwarves (oh, right, dwarrow.) Gave my uncle a nice, shiny ring for that, and he never had to turn another trick. Then there’s me, apparently my uncle’s heir, and there’s a party in Rivendell i’m supposed to service, and pawn the ring for some elvish pipeweed, which is better than what some of us grow, but it all gets you high.

Well, I wasn’t high when he rounded us up for the trek. I guess he didn’t pick any girls because we all know elves are fairies. Well, mostly.

On the way there, we stopped at a hotel in Bree, without the big guy, and I decided to try making a little money on the side, with this ranger fellow who’d been eying me all night.

Turned out, he was one of Gandalf’s lieutenants. He got laid, but I didn’t see any money. Well, such a run-down place, likely they all had a venereal disease or something…

-Watch where you’re going, son!

With my nose deep in my father’s thumbed special Mordor edition of “Scientific Shireman”
I hadn’t seen the elder Took and bumped into him in Main Street.

-I’m sorry, Sir!, I exclaimed, hiding my merriment. I had just won the Shire Soap contest - a trip to Mordor!

It all started with an ad in the morning paper:

Want adventure? Seek fame and fortune?
Enter the Burma Shire Shave contest and win a free trip for two to Mordor - all expenses paid!
To enter, just collect 100 Shire Soap wrappers and write a short (700-1000 words)
essay on what you expect life in Mordor may be like in 50 years from now.

I couldn’t wait to tell my best friend Sam…

Excerpt from the first book in the Ring trilogy; Have Ring, will travel. The other books are The Ring is a harsh mistress
and The hobbit who sold the Ring, all now available in paperback by Robert A. Heinlein.
Also by the same author: Fingolfin’s Freehold, Time enough for ale, Hobbit in the sky,
Starship Uruk-hais, Hobbit in a strange land, Bilbo: A comedy of justice and To sail beyond the sunset.

When a Dark King will arise again
A halfling will enter the scene
Fordo, Glandaf, Glime, Striding and the Rohirrim
Goes forth, far away from their homes

Within Moira, the Bolrug will claim it’s victim
A great sadness will wash over the lands
The survivors will lead a long train
Of the nine few will remain in the world

Smoke, soot and blackness in deep furnaces
Hammers fall and towers crumble
The grey one will turn white
A great battle ensues

Two of the fellows go astray
Doom awaits, spider and Gullem
The circle burns forever in the mountain
The Dark King lies still again

  • Prophesies of Nostradamus

I’m only up to page 12 so far, so someone may have already done the Beatles’ Norwegian Wood. But I was moved to write this… so here’s my humble addition to this magnificent thread.
I once had a ring,
Or should I say,
It once had me.

My present it was,
A lovely thing,
My precious ring.

I kept it safe and I went off to live in a cave.
Then nasty Bagginses stole it and I had to leave.

I followed it from
Rivendell halls
To river falls.

Then Frodo caught me,
This he did say,
’Show me the way’.

He said he was looking to get into Mordor somehow.
If I take them through via Shelob it won’t break my vow.

Now here we both stand,
At Orodruin,
The Crack of Doom.

I’ll chomp on his hand,
A lovely thing,
My precious ring.

One of my friends sent this to me after he got inspired on the first page of this thread while reading The Illuminatus! Trilogy by Robert Shea and Robert Anton Wilson. I wish I could take credit for it, but alas it is not to be so.
The Eighth Trip, or Yod

Sauron strode into the room with the Witch King and his Ringwraiths around. Since losing the One Ring he had been without a great deal of his power, and planned on getting it back. “Has there been any progress?” he asked.

“We think we’ve tracked the ring to the Shire,” said a Wraith.

“Good, good,” Sauron replied. “Do we have anyone there?”

“No,” said the Witch King.

“But we have plenty beneath Isengard,” said another Wraith.

“Then get someone over there!” Sauron yelled. He was an older being, years of dark plotting making him cynical beyond his years. Because of his 20-hour work day, he was more on edge than most and needed to use tranquillisers to keep himself under control from time to time. All of the attempts at locating the ring and his caffeine intake allowed his schizophrenia to approach levels which sometimes let him function in the real world. In other words, he was exactly like the leaders of Rivendell and Isengard.

On the corner of 10th and Brentwood, the squirrel scurries down from the tree. Eyeing a nut, he bolts into the yard and creeps back into the tree.

“The ring must be destroyed,” Gandalf told the council at Rivendell.

“But who can undertake the mission?” asked Elrond. He was an older being, years of dark plotting making him cynical beyond his years. Because of his 20-hour work day, he was more on edge than most and needed to use tranquillisers to keep himself under control from time to time. All of the attempts at locating the ring and his caffeine intake allowed his schizophrenia to approach levels which sometimes let him function in the real world. In other words, he was exactly like the leaders of Mordor and Isengard.

Various arguments were had, when Frodo Baggins, already the ringbearer, volunteered for the mission. A fellowship was soon formed, and Frodo was sent to Mt Doom in order to destroy the Ring. And a young Elf muttered something which sounded suspiciously like, “Ewige Blumenkraft!” though nobody was able to prove this was the case.

Twelve large rhinoceroses, Glorfindel thought as he focused his power to wash away the Ringwraiths and save the Hobbits. It helped him to focus. Thirteen large rhinoceroses, fourteen large rhinoceroses, and the water was getting higher now.

(“You won’t believe this,” the post reviewer said. “Totally unoriginal. Just going ahead, and consciously imitating an obscure author he happens to be reading at the time. Absolutely no sense of decency, either, in making the parody, always asking questions about details. Listen to this one, ‘So long winded, he moved Columbus’ fleet.’”)

“You have one chance to join me,” Saruman the Wise said to Gandalf the Grey.

“You would plunge the world back into darkness,” Gandalf replied. “I cannot allow that.”

“Then you will not leave here alive.” The two wizards glared at each other fiercely, before Saruman began the battle. He was an older being, years of dark plotting making him cynical beyond his years. Because of his 20-hour work day, he was more on edge than most and needed to use tranquillisers to keep himself under control from time to time. All of the attempts at locating the ring and his caffeine intake allowed his schizophrenia to approach levels which sometimes let him function in the real world. In other words, he was exactly like the leaders of Mordor and Rivendell.

I haven’t made it the whole way through yet, but since I haven’t seen a tribute to Bennett Cerf so far, I thought I’d add this contribution:

There once was a powerful ring,
Who Frodo to evil will bring.
It must leave the Shire
And be thrown in the fire,
Or Aragorn will never be king!

I continue to love reading this stuff. Can anyone do Dickens - not Christmas Carol but “A Tale of Two Towers”:
It was the best of times, it was the worst of times (you know the rest)
At the end Frod does a speech about it being a far, far better thing he does, and a far, far better rest…

I’m another one of “those” who was sent here by a friend, love this thread! Please forgive me if this one’s been done, but I couldn’t resist. :slight_smile:

LOTR as Girl Scout campfire songs

“The Ring-Bearer Song” [“The Girl Scout Song (On My Honour)”]
On my honour I will try,
There’s a Ring to bear and I say “aye,”
There’s a purpose I don’t clearly understand,
And I’ll likely not come back from that dark land.

Sauron’s trying to learn my name
If I fail my quest then I’m to blame.
If I stay my friends will end up dead
I must go alone to do this thing I dread.

Come with me to where the Eye burns bright
I must melt this Ring in the firelight
Never mind, I think I’ll keep it now—
That nasty creature Gollum bit my finger…OW!

I made a promise I did keep
But we’re out of food, so let’s just sleep.
We’ll lay here dead and when we’re gone
Old Bilbo will write us up in song.

“Frodo” [“Barges”]
Out of the bushes looking in the window
I can hear Mr. Gandalf talking low.
About a Dark Lord and somethin’ ‘bout a Ring
Please don’t turn me into an unnat’ral thing!
Fro-do, I would like to go with you,
I would like to be a ring-bearer too.
Fro-do, I would like to go with you,
Of the Elves I’d like to have a view.

“There’s a Land Where the Evil Dark Lord Dwells” [“There’s a Hole in the Bottom of the Sea”]
There’s a land where the evil Dark Lord dwells,
There’s a land where the evil Dark Lord dwells,
There’s a land, there’s a land,
There’s a land where the evil dark lord dwells.

There’s a tower in the land where the evil Dark Lord dwells…
There’s an orc in the tower…etc.
There’s a hobbit with the orc…etc.
There’s a hand on the hobbit…etc.
There’s a finger on the hand…etc.
There’s a Ring on the finger…etc.
There are words on the Ring on the finger on the hand on the hobbit with the orc in the tower in the land where the evil Dark Lord dwells…

“Oh You Can’t Get to Mordor” [“Oh You Can’t Get to Heaven”]
Oh you can’t get to Mordor (Oh you can’t get to Mordor)
With Gandalf the Grey (With Gandalf the Grey)
Oh you can’t get to Mordor (Oh you can’t get to Mordor)
With Gandalf the Gre-e-e-e-ey
Oh you can’t get to Mordor with Gandalf the Grey,
The Balrog got him & he fell a long way
Oh you can’t get to Mordor with Gandalf the Grey

Oh you can’t get to Mrodor with Boromir
He’d take your Ring and leave you here

Oh you can’t get to Mordor by the iron gate
It’s guarded by orcs and you’re too late

Oh you can’t get to Mordor with a Gollum guide
He’ll trick you then run and hide

Oh you can’t get to Mordor through Shelob’s den
She’ll sting you and eat you then
Maybe some other former Scout can do the “Brownie Smile Song”? The words lend themselves so well, but I just couldn’t figure it out.

Rivendell Psychiatric Hospital
Therapy notes re:patient Saruman D. White
Attending physician Dr.G.T. Grey

Patient suffers delusions of grandeur,marked tendency towards megalomania,and has serious self-control issues.In my sessions with him I’ve noticed an unhealty obssession on his part with acquiring a certain ring that belongs to one of my colleagues,Dr.F.R. Baggins.Several times during Mr.White’s stay at this facility,he has attacked hospital personnel and had to be confined to the violent ward;Dr. Everstar recommends increasing his medication dosage to control his more aggressive tendencies…

Bilbo had a ring. But Bilbo died. Now Frodo has the ring. And so it goes.

In 1964 I went see my old war buddy at his home in Ithaca, NY. We drank a fine bottle of Scotch I brought with me, and talked about war and death. His wife is a widow now. And so it goes.

[child-like drawing of of a hobbit’s anus]

I seethe with envy. Great meter, great content. Brilliant!

KathleenTheCritic

Rime of Middle Earth - by Samuel Taylor Coleridge

A Spirit had followed them ; one of the invisible inhabitants of this planet, neither departed souls nor angels ; concerning whom the learned Elf, Elrond, and the Wizard of Isengard, Gandalf the Grey, may be consulted. They are nine in number, and there is no climate or element without one or more.

And some in dreams assuréd were
Of the Spirit that plagued us so ;
Nine leagues behind he had followed us
From the land of mist and snow.

And every tongue, through utter drought,
Was withered at the root ;
We could not speak, no more than if
We had been choked with soot.

The Party, in their sore distress, would fain throw the whole guilt on the young Hobbit : in sign whereof they hang the One Ring round his neck.

Ah ! well a-day ! what evil looks
Had I from old and young !
Instead of the cross, the Ring of Power
About my neck was hung.


Andrew Bak

Thankyou alexfiles - nice to know I did Moorcock right. Alas I’m only familiar with his Elric novels myself. Perhaps I should get around to tackling a few of his other “heroes” one of these days?

Oh, and I really liked your “Lord Isildur’s Bane” (it’s always nice to know the fantasy writers of the old school are not forgotten :slight_smile: ). Been a while since I read Donaldson, but I think you got it just right.

On a completely unrelated note - anyone fancy tackling a Tennesse Williams version? I really don’t feel up to the task, but surely someone else has it in them.

From “Yowl” by Frodo Ginsberg:

I saw the best minds of my generation destroyed by madness, starving hysterical naked,
dragging themselves through the Shire streets at dawn looking for a missing ring,
angelheaded hobbits burning for the ancient heavenly connection to the starry dynamo in the machinery of night,
who poverty and tatters and hollow-eyed and high sat up smoking pipes in the elven darkness of cold-water barrows floating across the tops of Rivendell contemplating ancient lays,
who bared their brains to Heaven in the Wilderlands and saw Rider-like shadows staggering on The Prancing Pony roof illuminated,
who passed through Moria with radiant cool eyes hallucinating Gondor and Lothlorien among the scholars of war…etc