If I say “I had a tea cake after lunch” I would be referring to something that looks like this: a round, shortbread-like cookie with nuts and powdered sugar.
When my boyfriend says “tea cake” he means something entirely different. Something like a cupcake though with a coarser texture. I can’t find a representative picture, but maybe some others in SoCal will know what I’m talking about.
When I look at Google images, I see many things called “tea cakes.” What do you think of?
I’d never say tea cake, because I’ve never been sure what they are (I assume that’s what “fairy cakes” from Little House On The Prairie also are, though). I’ve certainly never been served one or seen one in a store.
I don’t think I would ever refer to something as a “tea cake,” but if I did, it would be a small, round, muffin-like confectionary like that what you linked to, not a slice of a full-sized cake (which seems to be what a lot of Google hits are showing.)
“Tea cakes” in our house are round & flat, like cookies are, are shortbreadish, and there’s a circular hole in the top layer which is filled with a fruit filling of some sort. (The bottom layer supports this so the bottom of the tea cake isn’t sticky & drippy in the middle.
Oh yes, those are both very acceptable versions of a teacake. I prefer the toasted version but fully endorse those that choose the way of the chocolate.
Incidentally, there is no funnier phrase than “Tunnocks Caramel Wafer” said in a very broad Aberdeen accent. Try it (the phrase and the caramel wafer)