Imaginarily recast a great film with horrible choices

Richard Simmons as Ebenezeer Scrooge

How about Georghe Mueresan instead of Andre the Giant in The Princess Bride?

No large man can hold a candle to Andre!

I’m kinda surprised you haven’t gotten slammed for this one, but I wholeheartedly agree. He is the most overrated actor of modern times.
I personally despised Barfly, almost entirely to his acting. “Drinks for all my frieeeeennnnds!” The friend I saw it with said that the only explanation for his horrible performance was that Rourke is a Method actor, and was therefore downing a fifth of cheap scotch before appearing on the set.

Anyhow …, my choice Robert DeNiro as Weslesy in The Princess Bride. Yes, the man is God, but I still can’t see him playing the light-hearted swashbuckler.

Sua

I can totaly see see this. Not only do I think Paul Rubens may have enough depth to play a pretty creepy Frank, but Pee Wee as Frank could be funny. Using his smarmy Pee Wee voice in the same tone as “I know you are but what am I.”

“Do you want me to pour the beer Frank?”

“No I want you to f*ck it…duh.”

Britney Spears as Sally Bowles

John Wayne as Joel Grey’s Master of Ceremonies

Steven Seagal is Hamlet!

With
Katie Sagal as Gertrude
David Spade as King Claudius
Sylvester Stallone as Polonius
Bette Midler as Ophelia

“Philadelphia Story” with:

Tom Cruise
Brad Pitt
and Courtney Love.

The musical remake, “High Society” with:

Harry Connick, Jr.
Ricky Martin
and Courtney Love.

Oh, I know! In “The Bonfire of the Vanities,” the judge is supposed to be a Jewish conservative- let’s give the part to Morgan Freeman! And the reporter is supposed to be a left-wing, intellectual Englishman- perfect part for Bruce Willis! And the part of… wait a second…

I’m afraid we just aren’t silly enough to keep up with the REAL Hollywood casting directors.

Let’s remake The Third Man with Jerry Lewis instead of Orson Welles and Dean Martin instead of Joseph Cotton. And Ann Margaret as the love interest, what the heck.

The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly with:
The Three Stooges

Star Trek V is my least favorite Trek, because of its horrible storyline, bargain-basement effects, an overweight, bored Nimoy, etc. etc. It is truly bad.

But… was Shatner’s direction as horrible. There are some nice composition shots (the mountain climbing, on the “God Planet”). I’m not a devotee of directors, nor am I really very knowledgeable about lighting, frame composition, editing, what-have-you, I just know if I see something I like.

So, experts in the areas I am not, I ask your opinion. Was Shatner’s direction bad?

Sir Rhosis

No, no! Fran Drescher! Come to think about it, pretty much any movie with Fran…can you just imagine her as Maria in “Sound of Music”?

YEEEEEEK!!!

The Wizard of Oz with Rosie O’Donnell as Dorothy, Jim Carey as the Straw Man, Louie Anderson as the Cowardly Lion, and the Harlem Globtrotters as the munchkins.

I think this could be made into a terrible movie with these guys and some others.

I think I’m starting to feel sorry for Jake Lloyd. You know he’ll never get another acting job in his life, plus he’s forever doomed to be mentioned in threads (and conversations) like this one.

Dijon Warlock:
You’re absolutely right about Fran Drescher. I tried to think of her name until my eyes crossed. No luck, so I went with Rosie.

“The hills are aloive with the sound of muuuuuusic! Enh-henh-henh-henh-henh-henh!!!”