Interpersonal conflict resolution? Boss/subordinate issue, kinda sorta

I have an odd issue. I do some tutoring work and came into conflict with a superior (who is not really my boss, as it’s basically freelance). I work at a university.

Work has been slow (nonexistant) spring and summer semesters. No problem. I have caused no issues other than wanting a time sheet restored after a third party changed it, and wanting to make sure my contact information was updated. In fact, that was the only reason I was there today.

This man came in to a brief (as in, 3-minute) update on procedure and information, after updated informationw as requested. He immediately acted as if I was causing trouble by asking for tutoriung assignments and lectured me (at length) that they were overstaffed for tutoring and they would decide what assignements were there yada yadda. I did in fact interrupt (which may not have been wise) with increasing confusion to say that I knew that, I understood, and simply was there to update my information. To me, this behavior was un-called for and in fact nakedly insulting. I know the facts. He had previously given almost the exact same spiel (and I had no problem with it… the first time).

He then immediately took offense and demanded to know if I had a “sharp attitude” [His word] with students, which only incensed me further. I simply do not understand why he butted in, acted as if I were an idiot, and then got offended when I was upset by that attitude. I responded that his speech was seriously talking down to me. I also offered that we should let the issue go. He then got really huffy and asked me to leave. I was *extremely *offended by that as well as his questioning my tutoring.
Now, it’s possibly I may not have handled that as a saint, but his manner was, frankly, unprofessional and insulting. I responded rather mildly and in confusion, particularly since he has little direct authority over me (he can probably bar me from tutoring with that service, but I don’t really care now). Frankly, I probably won’t get any more tutoring contracts since another individual (the one who changed my timesheet against policy and ethical conduct) also affects this and did not want to change it back.
My question now is if I shoudl send him an email, and cc or bcc his boss on the matter, so as to protect myself, even if it ends up that I get nothing substantial. I sort of wrote up a letter, although it’s a little overdone, I though more formality better than the alternative. Plus, I’ve been reading civil war diaries.

[To Mr. Guy, titles etc.]

"Dear Sir,

I do not entirely understand why we came into conflict, and the conversation utterly confuses me. I certainly do not wish, did not wish, and have no interest in offending you, and therefore write this letter in the hopes of healing any such wounds.

Whether your recognize it or not, your manner insulted me gravely, and I responded as mildly as I felt I could, and only to inform you that I was not there for such purposes, but only to update my information and double-check procedure on that. I have made no complaints at all over not having tutoring assignments. I do not understand why non-question this required your answer on that topic, which deeply hurt by responding as if I had.

I hold you in the highest regard, and it was that this came from someone I respect deeply which wounded me, as was your refusal to speak further. If I have given offense in any fashion, I hope you will forgive me, and if not, that we can thereby eliminate that problem and chalk it up to simply different modes of communication that did not mesh well."

Your proposed email sounds a little over the top, and I wonder whether it might actually escalate things. How much do you know about this guy personally? Is he usually kind? Is he under stress? It sounds like he was on some kind of power trip.

What are you trying to accomplish? Because that letter doesn’t sound like “Sorry”; it sounds more like “You need to admit that I was right!”.

My advice is to write (in a word-processor, not your e-mail) a much more strongly worded e-mail, describing in explicit detail how you were horribly wronged, and what the offending person would do to apologize if there was any trace of human decency and intelligence anywhere in their body. Then delete it and get on with your life.

I have no idea. I’ve only met him once, really, apart from the odd nod as I pass in the hallway and saying “Hello.” He’s very soft-spoken, and from my brief impression very nonconfrontational. Today, he started out blatantly passive-aggressive and then escalated way up from there.

Perhaps I did not make myself clear. I am trying to cover my ass as formally as possible.

Sometimes people get the wrong impression of you and NOTHING you do can set the record straight. They will always come out of the gate assuming the worst and attacking you for it.

You can either persevere, keep your mouth shut and hope they eventually wise up, or you can approach a third party who is well respected by that other person and hope that they can convince that person that they’re wrong about you.

I once was in a similar (sort of) situation. Just as in your situation, my situation involved a superior who was not really my boss, but whose department I worked with on a few small tasks.

One day, she suddenly started being hostile to me (publicly - it was awkward). But her complaints to me were off the mark: several times she took me to task for something I was not doing, but she assumed I was doing before storming off in indignant glory while I was sputtering and saying ‘But, no, I’m not…oh, you’re gone.’

In my case, I was being bad mouthed by another girl in her department - a coworker and one who reported directly to her. I would normally assume the coworker was just trying to cover her ass, but no, that coworker was simply a malicious bitch who loved trauma.

Could this be your case? Could the third party who changed your time sheet be hostile and have an in with this supervisor?

Regarding the situation:
If I were in your shoes, I would go to a trusted and liked supervisor and ‘ask for advice’ to deal with this situation that is causing me concern. You’re not complaining, you’re asking what this supervisor thinks you can do differently.

Or I would ignore it (but I’m a wimp). :slight_smile:

‘Trauma’ is supposed to be ‘drama’ (and sorry about my grammar sucking too!)

^ These.

It’s business, which means that if you want to repair this breach, you are going to have to eat shit and smile, even if you think (know) you’re right and this person was absolutely out of line. You should not say *anything *about his behavior being offensive–if you comment on it at all, you can say something like how you understand how frustrating it must be to deal with the overstaffing, and that you apologize if anything you said led him to believe that you were trying to wrangle more hours for yourself.

Concur. But put it in an email to said trusted advisor so there’s a written record.

The email is tragic, smiling bandit. Maybe that’s what you’re aiming for? Not to make light of your exchange with the tutoring man, as I can see his sort of condescension being extremely irritating. But if you want to be taken seriously you should have a fresh go at it tomorrow and write a plain English, coherent email that looks to smooth things over.

OTOH, if you’re intent on capturing the drama of this grave incident, could you not challenge him to a duel?

Do you know any of the other tutors at all?

My suspicion would be that he’s had other people bugging him for tutoring assignments, to the extent that now he blows up if he thinks a tutor’s looking at him funny. You could put out a couple of feelers - “hey, does it seem to you like X has been a bit touchy recently?”

I doubt if it’s you, specifically. Also, he’s clearly not going to listen to a word of any explanation you give him - you tried that already - so just let it go. He’s not your boss, you don’t have to CYA against him getting mad at you, he’s just a co-worker with more seniority who decided to be a prick one time.

Well, thanks. Now that I’ve had some time, the whole event does seem more mystifying then it did even at the time. I still can’t figure out, but perhaps just ignoring it is for the best. I don’t have to do any work there - I’m not dependant on it.

Unfortunately, I really know no superior. I get (or got) to pick my assignments, do them with a simple check-in, and did not have to report to a soul. There may well have been somebody complaining to me or somebody elsebugging him about tutoring assignments.

I guess I will simply let it alone and ignore the whole thing, and simply never speak to him again.

Rat’s Rule for Interpersonal Conflict Letters:

If you feel the need to ask someone to look your letter over, you’re better off to not send it in any form whatsoever.


The guy was probably in a bad mood and/or is a fascist overload of his personal mini bailiwick. Either way, you gain nothing by bringing the issue up. Avoid him, let him blow his wind till he’s deflated anytime you must talk with him, and just do your job as well as you can.

But I liked thinking about someone who lived for the Trauma. Especially since I spent an exasperating half hour being annoyingly perky so I would keep a pain in the neck customer happy and so that she would buy $75 worth of product rather than return it and complain to all her friends, and never shop there again.

(The product in question is supposed to have kind of a natural, unfinished look. But the customer wanted stuff which was more perfect and uniform than was realistic. So most of the product is back on the shelf waiting for some other–hopefully less fussy-- unsuspecting soul to buy it.)

Well, it sort of might fit as she did enjoy causing pain! :wink: Your job sounds rather stressful (dealing with people with too much time and unrealistic expectations) hopefully today will be better!

Smiling Bandit,
Best of luck! Heck, maybe he’ll apologize, though usually people don’t realize they’ve been offensive (at least it seems that way to me.)

Most days my job is not stressful. Yesterday was an exception.

Although, yes, I encounter people with unrealistic expectations every now and then–most of them are not quite so time-consuming.

Wow, mighty strong sense of yourself, huh? :stuck_out_tongue: Just kidding :wink:

I think you should just wait and see how things go next time with this person. It could have been a one time Really Bad Day and sending an email makes it more than it needs to be. I also agree with the idea of informally sending out feelers to see others’ perceptions.