Anticipation…
Anticipation…
It’s making me wait…
Sorry to get these in right under the deadline. I do take these quite seriously (especially after seeing how seriously the Chefs take it), and I always want to give insightful, intelligent responses.
I must say for an overtime battle, I was much more impressed with this menu than the one with the full-time lobster battle. Everything sounds delicious. I must say that of all the presentations I’ve judged, these dishes seem to me to be the best tasting IRL of any. I still have to deduct points for presentation and creativity, but damn these sound good.
Chef Troy:
Consomme: Fantastic. Normally I would agree with many of the other judges and say I prefer heartier soups, but I think given your other dishes and the theme ingredient, I must say this is an excellent start. A great introduction to the theme ingredient. I think the medley of different wild mushrooms would work wonderfully together.
Ragout: Garlic, butter, mushrooms. Hmmmmm. I think you have seen into my soul and created a dish that will make it sing. Great dish.
Pot Roast:: Very Good. I was wondering why you would trim the fat and the connective tissue from the cut? I would think you would want to keep them there to help the flavor and texture when you are cooking the cut for as long as 4 hours. The gravy sounds very earthy, and again, right up my alley. The presentation also screams: Classic Comfort Food, to me. I also agree that the mashed potatoes could use a little something, and I think truffle oil would be a perfect addition.
Fajitas Ahhh Portabellas, the substitute for meat for vegetarians everywhere. This dish sounds good, but, IMHO, could’ve used more spicyness in the fajita itself. A little bit bland of a dish. The guacamole sounds great though.
Risotto: Back to making my life wonderful. This dish sounds fantastic. I may question it’s place in the tasting, but I can’t question that it sounds wonderful, and is a great articulation of the theme ingredient.
Morels: At this point, you would have to serve me a candied twig (oops sorry Scylla) to rouse my anger. I’m not sure how this dish would hold together or taste, but I will defer to your wisdom.
After the lobster battle, I harangued you for the lack of expression of the theme ingredient and the paltriness of your menu. With these dishes you have fully redeemed yourself in my eyes. I would have liked a bit more by way of description of the presentation (i/e how the consomme was put into tiny little white cups with a fluffy top), but overall one of your best efforts.
Fenris
Mini Mu Shu Sounds very good. Being a big fan of hoison sauce, I especially like this dish. I’m not sure I’d have used the portabella here, but they should work just fine. A good start.
Truffle Fritata This sounds like a fantastic dish. Normally, I am not a big fan of truffles, but I think with this dish, they would be great. I disagree with some of the judges, I think “mushrooms” and eggs can mix very well together in a single dish. Again, my experience with truffles is somewhat limited, but you have earned my respect enough to trust you. Great dish.
Beef Wellington Well smack me on the ass and call me a cab. This sounds to die for. I’ve gone over the recipe twice and I can’t think of a single bad thing to say. WOW! The meat is fantastic, but then you add the mushrrom/burgandy gravy and you sent me to heaven. When I first saw the theme ingredient, I was hoping somebody would combine mushrooms and a hearty red wine. Mmmmmmmmmmm.
** Dessert** A simple, tasty ending to the tasting.
Fenris, I also harangued you for what I saw was a lack of spine and creativity. You also, have redeemed yourself. Perhaps another dish to show a more earthy side of the theme ingredient, but all in all, fantastic. Can I have a nother piece of the Wellington please?
Both the Challenger and the Iron Chef have truly outdone themselves. Again, here are my scores:
Iron Chef Troy: 19
Fenris: 19.
I regret I couldn’t pick a winner. Well Done both of you.