Is Yellow Cake With Chocolate Frosting, Chocolate Cake?

[Gyrate]

@Batsinma_Belfry

But since none of you have gone to the trouble to make me a cake

Well, in our defense we didn’t know you were coming.

Chocolate cake is cake that is chocolate, even if it has vanilla frosting on it (which can be nice, although not as nice as devil’s food cake).

[MegaBee]

Just pray to god you don’t drop that shit.

[Markxxx]

@kaylasdad99

I wondered about that myself, so I went to the wikipedia page for the program. The picture they had was a screen capture from the show, and it was in color.

OP, were you watching in color?

Only the first two seasons were b&w so I was watching the color episodes

[Nunzio_Tavulari]

Putting sugar on top of your Special K doesn’t make them Frosted Flakes. Putting chocolate icing on yellow cake won’t make it a chocolate cake.

[Quimby]

@RandMcnally

There was actually a thread seven years ago (God, I’m getting old) that asked this question due to Spiderman 2.

I totally remembered that thread when I saw this one. Hearing it was 7 years ago makes me want to yell at a cloud.

[Elendil_s_Heir]

@Nunzio_Tavulari

Putting sugar on top of your Special K doesn’t make them Frosted Flakes. Putting chocolate icing on yellow cake won’t make it a chocolate cake.

Agreed. Good analogy.

[Annie-Xmas]

Is chocolate cake with white frosting white cake?

ETA:

@me

Oh, for Chrissake! Slap those yellow cake layers together with some custard, put on the chocolate icing, and when come back, bring Boston Cream Pie.

I don’t remember posting this, but it’s worth saying twice
]

[TBG]

@Quimby

I totally remembered that thread when I saw this one. Hearing it was 7 years ago makes me want to yell at a cloud.

If not for the fact that polls weren’t enabled back then, I would’ve thought this was a zombie thread from then.

And yeah, chocolate cake refers to the cake, frosting flavor (or even existence) is irrelevant to this.

[OpalCat]

@Annie-Xmas

I don’t remember posting this, but it’s worth saying twice

Bleah! Why would you ruin a perfectly good cake by contaminating it with custard? Ewww!

[Bosda_Di_Chi_of_Tricor]

@Bosda_Di_Chi_of_Tricor

Yellow cake, even with chocolate frosting, remains a radioactive compound, & should not be ingested.

@ZenBeam

Dibs on Bosda Di’Chi of Tricor’s piece!

Yellowcake, despite being radioactive, will not transform you into the Incredible Hulk, Zenbeam. We’ve explained this before.

[Morgyn]

@SeaDragonTattoo

I have my grandma’s recipe for chocolate cake. It is chocolate through and through and doesn’t even need frosting. My mom and I rarely frost this recipe.

So when are you sharing the recipe?

[Autolycus]

It tastes like chocolate, so I call it chocolate cake. I seem to find myself in a despised minority on this issue. Y’all can go eat cake.

[Batsinma_Belfry]

@wheresgeorge04

Sure. But irrelevant regarding the poll question.

Joe

What are you, the Poll PoPo?!?! :rolleyes: