There’s a new competition show on SyFy, takes up from Face Off. Instead of doing monster make ups, it is doing animatronic and puppet creature creation. 10 competitors are vying for a slot on the staff at the legendary Jim Henson’s Creature Shop.
Typical of a show like this, there are a set of contestants given a challenge to build, a limited schedule, and often teams assigned at random.
The first week was to design and undersea creature like never seen before, that might be caught on the camera of an undersea ROV. They divided up into teams of 2, and were given 2 days to design the creature that would be worn by a professional puppeteer.
There were some interesting challenges of how to design and build using foam and other materials. They had a decent amount of technical discussion.
But of course there was also the “oh my, we don’t have any time, will we get it done?” that these shows carry, and there was one pair that did not work well together. The girl, Tina, was domineering and opinionated and wanted creative, artistic choices without concern for how to build them and make them work in the time alotted. The guy, Russ, didn’t want to argue and so stepped back and let her run the show, but then he got frustrated because he didn’t like her ideas but wouldn’t stand up to make things better. He even lied. When the shop mentor came around asking how things were going and specifically asked how they were working together, he said it was great.
Then it came time for the screen test. Each creature had a short scene on a set made up like an undersea floor.
One team had a crustacean type thing that was very unique. One team was a pair of guys with very little foam work experience who made a crawly thing. The puppeteer had to crawl around on his belly, and really couldn’t act in position for long before he had trouble breathing. The mouth looked like a giant muppet - it was supposed to be realistic, but the sculptor went for comedic.
That team got the low ranking and the muppet guy got eliminated. The winning team was a duo that worked really well together, had good communication and division of tasks, and had the successful crustacean thing.
The team with the communication problems came up with a fishlike thing. It was pretty much a giant fish. It managed not to fall apart - it broke in preparation and had to be rush fixed together, due to a poor design choice to make the body out of two segments glued together and the glue didn’t hold. Anyway, when their review time came up, Russ started whining how bad their team was and how the girl didn’t let him get in any ideas, etc. The judges raked them over pretty hard for their lack of professionalism.
So week two rolled around. The challenge was from The Dark Crystal. They were divided into three teams of 3, and assigned to reimagine a Skeksis that was banished to some foreign landscape for hundreds of years before returning to the castle. And there were lots of props and puppets from the movie on display, including several Skeksis and for the screen test, the actual Dark Crystal.
The teams were randomly assigned, and Russ and Tina ended up on the same team again with a lady, Ivonne. Oh joy. They both made efforts to work better, but it still had issues. From what we saw, Tina was scattered and not really focused on anything.
So each team had to build a Skeksis from their selected environment (decaying forest, desert, frozen wasteland), work with a professional puppeteer, but also each person had to operate some puppetry themselves. They were given three days this time.
One team doing the frozen wasteland came up with the concept of finding and killing an animal and using the hide as a coat. They had a pretty good sculpt for the face, and animatronics for the eyelids and nose. They had puppet hands operated by a team member. But the eyes were a little wideset and the judges commented you couldn’t really see both eyes at once.
The second team doing the decaying forest had a very good facial sculpt and paint with animatronic eyes, eyelids, and eyebrows. The body was built extra lightweight, which made it far easier on the puppeteer carrying it around. They had a second puppet, a tiny creature (the “Chicken Bug”) to interact with. It went over well. One of the moving parts was a feathered crest that was supposed to pop up that was not very dramatic and easily missed.
The third team had the desert, and that was the team with Russ and Tina. Russ sculpted a pretty good face, but put the eyes deepset and they were a little too deepset, you couldn’t really see in to see the eyeballs and if they worked. Tina worked on the animatronics for the eyes, plus she built the puppet hands and worked the hands in the creature with the puppeteer. She had a decent concept, but the hand gestures didn’t really function right. Ivonne did the costuming and body shell, but she left the fabrics too pretty and intact, so instead of looking weathered and dirty in the desert, they looked pretty pristine. And then Tina built a secondary creature to accompany their Skeksis and they rigged it with a peeing stream, so the Skeksis could drink it’s urine. None of the animatronics really worked - the eyeball didn’t function and the hands didn’t really work and the peeing creature didn’t move.
But this set up one of the most brilliantly executed moves I think I’ve seen on one of these shows. So during building, Tina started the eye animatronics but wasn’t getting them to work so Russ stepped in to fix them. Well, they still didn’t work. So when it came time to tell the judges who did what, Russ didn’t mention the animatronics and let Tina say that she built the eye. Then the judges commented they really didn’t see it work, so Russ handed Tina the controller to operate. Tina had been in the puppet working the hands, so she didn’t know about the eye failure, so she tries to operate it and sees it not work, and then makes that observation. So boom she’s just declared she was the one who did the work, and now it’s not functioning. And even though Russ had the controller during their screen test, she was the one who pointed out the failure.
Anyway, the winner was the guy who did the operating Skeksis head with three sets of animatronics, a great sculpt, and great paint. And the eliminated contestant was Tina.
What I like about this show, though, is the judges are very good at pointing out the strengths and weaknesses for every contestant. They mention the good things and the bad things, and small details like the frill needed to be more dramatic, or the winning head had a ruffle under it that was unclear whether it was costume or flesh, or the eyes on the other creature being too wide-set and not able to see directly in front of it.