I always use to confuse these two. They did look remarkably similar. Jerry Maguire hit the scene right around the time of Chasing Amy. I’d seen both in small parts before, but these films were there Big breaks.
There was a third actress coming up around that time (circa 96-97) who looked like these two. But I can’t remember who she was!
I recall there was a blurb in EW (96-97) about how people always confused the three. It basically showed their pictures and what they had done. I think I remember it being on the same page as the Hot Sheet.
You’re not alone. In a recent episiode of Dinner for Five on the Independent Film Channel, Joey Lauren Adams tells a story of how she was mistaken for Renee by the producer of Chasing Amy!!
I’ve never confused the two, and it surprised me to hear that so many people do.
Joey is definitely hotter than Renee. Once I actually saw Chasing Amy, I never got them confused. I think I must have just thought the girl from JM had a new movie coming out with Ben affleck.
She’s not yet famous enough to be confused with the other three, but Julie Benz (Darla on Buffy the Vampire Slayer and its spinoff Angel) also looks a lot like them. She even has Joey Lauren Adams’s helium voice to boot.