Didn’t you?
No, that most certainly doesn’t mean that. I was saying there that his foreign cultured accent/language would turn away Americans listening to his possible critiques. That doesn’t remotely imply that Americans need to “[understand] the unspoken class-system implications of non-American accents” to get his jokes.
The more I think about it, the more I love the choice. Go big or go home.
As Stewart described Stephen Colbert after the infamous Correspondents’ Dinner where he gleefully skewered Bush 43, it’s “Balls-o-licious.” 
I think Noah has the humor chops and the gravity - like an Oliver and Colbert along with Stewart. It will be interesting to see how many folks see him “laughing with” or “laughing at”.
Apparently some people are getting a bit concerned about some of the stuff Noah has tweeted in the past:
He does a skit about being mistaken for the Black Hitler in Germany - I don’t think his tweets are really going to be any worse than that … there’s going to be some lame fat lady jokes and some Jews control the world jokes, which are not great but not horrible either.
The worst reaction any of his tweets got here is the “And the Oscar goes to … jail!” one, and I thought that was hilarious.
If it’s not what you meant, then your “perfect committee decision” remark fails.
I wouldn’t worry about the hire. As with any show of this nature, if it falls flat he’ll be replaced in a damn hurry. Stewart himself might decide after some time away that he didn’t want to leave after all.
Remember the Conan/Leno situation?
But even if Stewart really does want to stay out, there are plenty of other directions to go if Noah fails.
Not entirely sure what you’re saying. Americans are not at all good at tellings Brit/Australian/South African accents apart, but we’re just fine at telling New York/New Jersey/Appalachia/Alabama/Texas/Ohio accents apart, distinguishing between black, white, Latino, etc. accents at the same time. I suspect he’ll use accents as part of his Daily Show act. I doubt that people will listen to his natural accent and think much about it beyond, “Ooh, he’s British, I love British accents!”
A comedian who has never made anyone “concerned” would be pretty boring and would make a terrible host.
And by “concerned”, I mean “pretend to be concerned”, because it would take a pretty tortured reading of this tweet:
“So I must make my woman fear my penis? RT @UberFacts: The more you fear something, the bigger it appears.”
or this tweet:
“So she gets fat? RT @missdanibagel: When a woman is loved correctly, she becomes 10 times the woman she was before”
to make the case that the guy is anti-woman as your link states.
Comedy is still the one area where you can say anything you want, as long as it’s just for laughs. Those who say things like “cancer is not funny” need to just stay away from comedians that joke about cancer rather than sending them nastygrams or starting campaigns.
The Daily Show is edgy at times, but Jon Stewart is not. This does not bode well for his future.
I’m sure if we mined all of Jon Stewart’s stand up comedy from the 80s and 90s before the Daily Show, we could find some tidbits that someone could pretend to be offended by.
Two minutes of googling:
“You wake up and you’re still a little drunk and you can’t believe that hot girl from last night actually has a beard and a penis.”
Jon Stewart, Cosmopolitan, January 1999That’s not really the same.
Probably. But that’s the thing about becoming mainstream in an age where all your shit is easily searchable (like Noah.)
Of course it’s not the same, it’s much more controversial than the sort of hacky joke Trevor Noah told about his penis. I don’t even get how that can be contrived to be offensive, but I guess I’m not trying as hard as some others to be offended.
But it shouldn’t be. Comedians should be edgy. They should say things that piss people off. They should be permitted to do so without being edited.
Had we collectively decided that Jon Stewart was too “edgy” based on a few sentences about the transgendered, we would have missed out on 20 years of a great show.
I don’t understand why the penis joke was offensive either (I don’t understand it at all), but the Jew jokes and some of the fat chick jokes are. You only quoted the two inoffensive ones.
No, his standup is not built around accents. No. Flat no. It is built around race and culture. That can possibly involve accents, but does not have to do so and 99% of the time doesn’t. The fact that he has an accent is not meaningful. His accent is is no way a signifier of cultural position to Americans.
In short, your every statement in this thread about Noah has been wrong and your every statement about Americans has been wrong. I don’t know where you live or what your background is, but I can guarantee that Noah understands Americans better than you do.
Is that clear enough? You’ve denied what seems to the rest of us the clear meaning of your own words, so I don’t want more misunderstanding.
“South Africa knows how to recycle like Israel knows how to be peaceful” is not anti-Jewish. If it were, any criticism of Israel could simply be negated by crying anti-Semitism. Criticizing Israel is perfectly acceptable material for a comedian. Jon Stewart does it pretty routinely.
Seriously, we’re going to stop the Daily Show over pretending to be offended by this:
“A hot white woman with ass is like a unicorn. Even if you do see one, you’ll probably never get to ride it.”
or this:
““Oh yeah the weekend. People are gonna get drunk & think that I’m sexy!” - fat chicks everywhere.”
(I’ve now quoted every single supposedly offensive quote from that link, and none of them are more offensive than the single Jon Stewart quote I found in two minutes of googling)
Haha. Look, I am not the executive in charge and we are not in GD. Good thing because you Noah boosters aren’t even coming close to changing my mind. You guys are desperate for your favourite choice to be the “best” choice as well. So we can only wait and see. When this all goes down the tubes I promise not to say “I told you so”.
It doesn’t matter if he’s the favourite choice of anyone here. He’s the choice of the people in charge and the one who is getting the job.