Huge spoilers folks…
Well, I don’t put it in the realm of Pulp Fiction – it’s dialog just doesn’t match up. I won’t disagree that its eye candy and ear candy, but for my money, it’s the best candy out there.
As other’s alluded to, it’s one to like more for the “trees” than the “forest”. I mean, all it is is this: she gets screwed over so she goes out to kill the people who did it.
That said, I just liked every one of the “trees”.
I enjoyed the fight scenes.
I enjoyed her recovery scenes.
I really liked the anime.
Then some of it, I just like Tarantino being cool. E.g. when the cop drives up to the chapel with the sunglasses on the dashboard. Or his line (approx.) “Son number 1. . .this is one tall drink of cocksucker.” or the pussy wagon, or the non-anime introduction to Liu’s character.
I thought the scene with Sonny Chiba and his lackey was real funny.
The scene with Buck was funny. Sick, but you have to laugh.
And none of that requires anyone to know she’s walking the earth like Jules or that she’s wearing an outfit like Bruce Lee wore in something or that Elle Driver is whistling some theme from some movie.
A little deeper, I like the hints at the back story, and the “cliffhanger” adds something. I think Uma brings some weight and a touch of melancholy to her character. There’s a mystery about what led up to the massacre. There’s no joy in her at all so you wonder just what all of the revenge will bring. Bill is the baby’s father, so what went on with that.
I will say, the fighting started to wear just a little with me and I have a pretty high tolerance for it. Definitely the right decision to release it in two volumes.
Anyway, that’s my take. Its not something I expect everyone to like. I knew my wife wouldn’t like it (she didn’t see it with me in the theater) and she didn’t.