Your options are really inconsistent and even within the so-called “groupings” (what are the groups supposed to be?) there’s no reason you couldn’t have multiple answers, or no answer.
I don’t think I’m inherently above average in intelligence, but I do think I am especially curious about things. I like to learn things more than most people. I’m also particularly good at some things (language) and particularly terrible at others (math). I spent a month and a half studying math, math, and more math before I took the GRE and I still scored 120 points higher on the verbal section (which I barely studied at all) than I did on the math.
I’m average in looks and athleticism. Nothing special.
I’m about average looking - I’d say on the high side of average, but I could be biased. I’m above average in intelligence. Definitely below average in sports, and I hate partying. Oh, and I’m female.
Way above average in intelligence. In looks, it’s hard to tell. I’m an overweight middle-aged man with wrinkles and graying hair; draw your own conclusions. In my prime I was probably still below average. Zero athletic talent. And though I’m no Sheldon Cooper, socializing is rather awkward for me. Among friends I know and love, I’m the life of the party. Among people I don’t know (or barely know), I’m a wallflower.
I am smarter than average at some things and way below average at others. I am good with machines and memorizing facts. I am terrible at math and can’t read peoples emotions worth a damn.
Looks wise, well my mom always said I was handsome.