Is the original stocking-giver important as himself or herself? That is to say, would we recognize this person’s name? No.
Did this person choose the girl to give the stockings to:
randomly? No
by lottery? No
or by prior acquaintance with her (or her family)? Yes
Was the girl as the adult donor associated in some important way to the charity? No. Not that I know of.
Was the ca. 1800–1820 event significant:
On a national level? No
On a NE regional level? No
On a state level? No
Only on a local level? Yes. But not much even there. Yet today two hundred years later we all know about it. History is kind of funny that way.
Is the title of the later book about this topic known to most American adults?* No
Do we think of this girl AS a girl, even though she obviously grew up? Yes
Is she in the book under her real name? Yes
Interestingly enough, there is another book about this whole incident written by a very famous American and his wife, people not generally thought of as authors. That book alas is forgotten (though still buyable!). It is pretty amazing to me what this small incident led to in our culture. Those stockings should never have been torn up. But who could have foreseen the big names who would later be involved and that we would care still nearly a century and a half into the future?
Mary’s mother supposedly made the stockings from the little lamb’s wool. They were cut up and sold many years later for lovers of the rhyme. This helped raise funds to restore the meeting house in Sterling, Massachusetts. Mary’s story was believed by automaker Henry Ford so much so that he and his wife wrote a book defending Mary Sawyer’s version of how the poem came to be. How this lamb, nursed to health by Mary, one day in the early 1800s followed Mary to school. How the ensuing uproar was noted by a friend who wrote the poem about the incident. How the poem ended up in a book that became famous and made Mary famous.
Thomas Edison recorded the Mary poem on one of the first phonograph records. Just think what that pair of stockings would be worth today if whole and preserved!
Is this a factual case?
Are “Eli” and “Christy” their real names (or at least, approximations thereof)?
Is the present tense accurate (going to prison now, vs. some time in the past)?
Is Eli going to prison in a modern first-world country?
Did Eli commit a crime?
Did Eli commit a crime against property (theft, vandalism, etc.)?
Did Eli commit a crime against a person/persons (murder, rape, assault, etc.)?
Was Christy an accomplice to the crime?
Was Christy a witness to the crime?
Was Christy a victim of the crime?