Your problem probably is upturned toes and/or long or sharp/ragged toe nails. Ask a podicurist if this is the case. It that is so, be religious about keeping your toenails short and smooth.
I have every pair of knee-high and over the knee sock that Payless sells. I wear them all the time with my boots and my slip on shoes. They are definitely not too thick and I haven’t had a single hole in any of them yet.
(Yes I do work for Payless but that doesn’t change the fact that the socks are good socks). The only Payless socks I have holey issues with are the no-shows, which aren’t what you’re looking for anyway.
The no shows? Yeah, they’re 97% nylon and they’re great for their intended purpose. I actually have to put the heel over the toe because I can’t get them to stay on otherwise. The toe part is deeper so it stays on my heel better. I’m glad it’s normal sock season again though because I love socks. I actually started wearing the boot socks so I could give an honest assessment of them to my customers. I ended up buying them all. They’re comfortable and warm but not too thick so I can wear them over tights and still not have sweaty, cramped feet.
Many years ago, an expert hiker advised readers to wear two socks: a thin and close-fitting nylon one with a thicker padding one. All slippage would happen between the two socks and prevent blisters, and be more comfortable besides. Anyone follow this practice?
I like Smartwools too. They are pricey for me… but I’m on the low income range. However : They last, they wick away the sweat ( if your feet sweat) and they aren’t too thick but in
warm and surprisingly not hot, at least to me , in fairly warm weather, still wicking away the sweat.
I am going to check out what others recommend, I hope you find some that you like, because socks are as important as good fitting shoes … if your feet aren’t happy, you aren’t happy Good luck!
P.S. I love these kind of questions, this is where I have found the best brands of stuff , when people recommend what they have found to be great products ! It turns out one persons question./need helps a lot of people sometimes …
You can find SmartWools at places like TJMaxx too, marked down.
They can be washed and line dried w/o shrinking or pilling, they dont need any babying. And they dont get soggy, as others have said. They wick any moisture away and keep the tootsies toasty. Naturally cushy. So worth it.
I tend to agree that if you are literally seeing holes after one or, at most, two wearings, across many brands, you have something odd going on. That’s not usual. Could be toenails, could be your shoes, could be a habit of walking sock-footed across the gravel, could be gremlins. But I don’t think it’s the socks.
We were told to do the same thing when I played basketball in hs. The inner socks were called sanitary hose, and were white thin nylon, covered with regular cotton socks.