Oh man, this.
When I was 11 a boy called me a lesbian on the street, and the friend I was with at the time said to me something like “it’s OK, you can be a lesbian, there’s nothing wrong with it,” which was very woke for the 1980s. But that actually made it worse - I’d been called a lesbian loads of times before, but so were loads of girls - it was just an insult, really. This girl really thought I was gay!
So I fought it for ten years. I had boyfriends, dressed in a girly way (still do, weather-dependant), etc. But every so often it would come up that maybe I liked girls, or at least liked girls as well as boys, and I’d fight against the idea because I wanted this one aspect of my life to be normal.
I walked round and round the tables at the LGBTSoc groups at fresher’s fair at uni but never found the courage to actually go and sign up. Went to the Lesbian and Gay Film Festival in secret, on my own. Basically I was hoping someone would come up to me and break the ice, see me as one of their own and invite me in to the group, rather than me having to be the one to ask for permission to join - but of course, that’s not how it works.
It didn’t help that I was attracted to men, sort of, although some of it was situational heterosexuality (people often talk about situational homosexuality in boarding schools and prisons, but it can happen the other way round).
And one of the first out lesbians I met in person, aged 17/18 - while dating a man who would now be called genderqueer - was so aggressive about “you MUST like sex with women!” that my teenage self said nuh-uh, I’m not doing what you tell me!
So basically it was gradual, the realisation that it’s only women that matter to me, sexually and romantically. Men can do it for me a bit, but it’s basically like masturbation using someone else’s body. And romantically… no, there was always something missing. I could never picture growing old with them, even if we were perfectly suited in every way, and got on really well.
Then I fell in love… with a woman who I’m pretty sure genuinely is straight, she just presents as gay. We had an oddly intense friendship. I could picture growing old with her. And it was too big a feeling to continue denying, so I came out to myself.
The first time I had sex with a woman (a different woman), which wasn’t even all that great, was still eye-opening. Oh, so that’s what they’re talking about!
Came out to most of my friends a few months later, and have been totally comfortable with my sexuality ever since.
I have occasionally thought about redefining as bi, because it’s not like I’m a Kinsey 6, but I think it would be misleading, and after 20+ years dealing with homophobia as the result of being in same-sex female relationships, I am not going to give up the term lesbian.