I am not sure if this the right forum. Mods please free to move it to GD or wherever depending on how it evolves.
I came upon this website and was reading the biography of Mohammed, the Prophet and the founder of Islam.
What I am going to write or the questions that I have, are not any form of criticism of the religion of Islam. I am only curious as to why something so obviously illogical did not, and does not even now, stimulate the sense of rationality and logic that a normal man is expected to posses.
I also hope that, since it is only a biography, an account of his life, and not a revelation like the Koran, I am safe to assume that the standard defense of ‘it is not possible to comprehend the true meaning because a lot of what is written is *allegorical’ * does not apply.
After reading the biography, and with the given assumption that Mohammed is supposedly a prophet and a messenger, it is reasonable to conclude that he was someone specifically chosen by God to deliver his message.
Following are some odd and illogical things I found that I feel should appear as just that to any mind functioning normally. I say this because I am sure that if the exact same events were to happen to some person today, they would appear illogical and ridiculous, and not worth a shred credibility.
God waited until Mohammed was 40 before deciding to let the latter know that he was the one who had been chosen to receive the revelations and be the messenger to all mankind. Huh? If the purpose is to save mankind, isn’t the concept of ASAP applicable?
Mohammed received his first revelation when he was 40, and then there was nothing for the next three years. What happened? Why would God decide to suddenly take that long a holiday before resuming where he left off?
The biography says that the Prophet “started by preaching his mission secretly first among his intimate friends, then among the members of his own tribe…” .
Now, if I was in Muhammad’s position, and I was convinced that the revelations to me were from Allah himself, the creator of the world, the all powerful, why would I not go public with his messages straightaway? If I am doing someone’s bidding, working as commanded by him and secure in the knowledge that the person whose command I am executing is all powerful and protection is thus guaranteed, why would I be afraid? The only reason perhaps would be if I was not absolutely sure and lacked the actual confidence that I will be protected. But then, why would the one whose command I am obeying not provide adequate protection to me, especially when he can?
The verses of the Koran were not revealed to Mohammed all at once but it happened over an extended period of time. I can understand that it was too voluminous to expect it to be done in one sitting - though I have read the translation of the Koran and I am sure I could do it in one sitting if I wanted and would take me a day perhaps. It also adds that “the Quran was not revealed all at once, but in fragments as occasions arose.”
Assuming both God and Muhammed had somewhat busy schedules and were a little pressed for time, I would have understood if it was said that it took God and Muhammad a week, a month or even a couple of months to complete the transfer of the contents of a book. But years? Several years? And that too on occasions?? Why would God give revelations about how mankind is supposed to live so intermittently, and also have them relate to occasions or events happening in some particular person’s life? What bearing or relevance do instructions on subjects like how to live life, social norms and laws, description of how the earth and the universe was created etc. etc have with occasions or events happening in my personal life? By what stretch of logic do I tie them together?
I will not discuss the rest of it although it is replete with similar fallacies. Also, it seems that God in the case of Islam did not help Mohammed with a single miracle. Although there maybe just as many events defying logic in the case of Christianity and Judaism but there are at least a few occasions where we can see God trying to help his messenger, be it Abraham, Moses or Jesus by performing miracles. Not that I am in anyway hinting that either of these religions or the stories behind them are any more convincing, but one could somewhat believe that it was easier to mislead folks 2000 years by miracles than it is now. But here in the case of Islam, even that element is absent.
The question is therefore, how do the Muslims answer such questions? Or is it that their religious faith is so great that they are blind to such glaring contradictions of logic?