I assume because she was at full health. I can’t remember her being hurt before.
Then it’s probably the one you’re thinking of, with five PFKs. The Halloween game.
See, I don’t remember you operating that way in the one game I do remember playing with you when you were town. You were so all up in my business, right from the second I placed that stupid vote.
Assuming this is the case, I wish you would reconsider. Do you realize it’s day five (soon) and you’ve yet to place a real vote on anyone? That your entire history up to the not-valid vote on me consisted of a few questions and one post in which you managed to write a few hundred words without giving me a single new thing to think about? How are the rest of us supposed to judge you? If you want to discuss anti-town, what have you been, so far? I’m really not trying to be a (haha) bitch here, Story. If you’re a townie, please consider the rest of us.
See above.
All right. That part is fair.
Fine.
And yet she was attacked – the only reason she was not injured at the time was because I protected her. I have no idea what to think about that. Unless it was just someone doing a form of “protection” on spec so to speak, like I did. Never mind.
Why don’t you take any damage from attacks, Normal? Just curious
Night just started, man. 
Agreed.
I’d like to take responsibility for one of the attacks on him, by the way.
No freakin’ comment, Visor, but I’m finding it hilarious. It’s the best thing about this game so far.
Visor: still waiting for you to present a cogent, detailed explanation of why you think I’m scum. Thanks. 
I wish I had that power. grumbles
[OOG]May I just say thank you for being friendly in reminding me of this.[/OOG]
You’ve posted a crapload, much more then I am used to going through in a game. So I’ll just post my basic thoughts.
Besides the whole Third Party thing, which I think was inherently scummy, there is also a comment you made saying you refuse to believe that somebody could think you were scummy at that point (which is scumy IMO, because it seems like frustrated mafioso). You seem to be against a lot of the lynches, which while understandable in some cases, lynching tells us a lot about a person. And is vital for the town to win. Sometimes you just gotta lynch em.
Your anti fubbles attitute earlier for bargaining also pings me.
But, I generally have a lot of people in a game I am suspiscious of.
@ Story
I would love to change my role. But I can’t because I keep getting attacked. I need to be healed.
I will be voting for RealityTrip tomorrow, most likely.
I was attacking him prior to my PM to you, too.
If you had stuck with it, we might have been able to take him out. 
(And thanks, Visor. I don’t have time for a detailed response right now, but I appreciate you articulating that.)
Later today I might out a PM exchange between me and gnarlycharlie from earlier in the game that I thought was very scummy on his part, although I’m sure many people will disagree and not see why it’s scummy at all, because culture etc. etc.
If you have information that you think points to scum, then out it.
I’m about to shoot something for work, could you go ahead and out the one PM I sent you last night? I can’t dig up the relevant link right now.
It’s sort of thin, but okay. (Full exchange is below; this is my summary of it.) gnarlycharlie contacted me on the morning of April 10th, one day after I announced in-thread that I would be PMing Normal Phase details of my role.
He asks me to send him what I sent Normal Phase. I responded immediately, giving him some information about my role and then, because I didn’t have a townie lean on him in the same way I had on Normal Phase, I asked him to share some of his information with me (“what you are and what you do”) as a show of good faith before I provided him with more details about the mechanics of what I did. He responded back fairly shortly after that, playing off the question and sounding unwilling to share. He asked how specific the information I wanted was, and I told him it was up to him – but that “alignment, class, and some description of [his] powers (if any) would be good.”
He then didn’t contact me for over a day, which I found suspicious because it read like a scum being unsure how much to reveal to me and wanting to talk it over with his teammates. When he did contact me again, he revealed basically nothing, and I thought the way he couched it was odd – I had told him straight-up that I was a “Lawful Good archer,” and he took three sentences to sort of tell me that he was a lawful, level 2 soldier…I think. It was a really weird response on his part, and basically had the opposite effect of the show of good faith that I had been hoping for.
I didn’t respond to that PM, and we haven’t talked since – which I also found suspicious, because I felt that if he was Town he’d be more likely to follow up with me after I didn’t get back to him and ask whether I was satisfied with what he had told me, as well as trying to get me to hold up my end of the quid pro quo. But he didn’t contact me again at all.
In summary, I think the exchange makes gnarlycharlie look very scummy for the reasons above. Thank you.
[QUOTE=gnarlycharlie]
[QUOTE=Gadarene]
[QUOTE=gnarlycharlie]
[QUOTE=Gadarene]
[QUOTE=gnarlycharlie]
would you be willing to send me what you sent Normal Phase?
[/QUOTE]
I’m not quite sold on your townieness (I may have jumped the gun on being sold on Normal’s townieness too, but that’s neither here nor there), but I would be willing to do a good-faith exchange of information:
I am a Lawful Good archer. If you tell me what you are and what you do with some reasonable degree of specificity, I will tell you what I do.
[/QUOTE]
uhm, how specific? you might be disappointed. lol
[/QUOTE]
Up to you. Your alignment, class, and some description of your powers (if any) would be good, though.
[/QUOTE]
after some thought, i guess quid pro quo is okay.
i’m a military type of a plain persuasion. i abide by the law. my level is just above a novice.
there ya go. i tried to make it sound more interesting than it actually is.
[/QUOTE]
Here you go:
[QUOTE=Astral Rejection]
Gad,
I think we should attack Mosier. I’ve gone ahead and told pizza to change my attack.
I was rereading the rules, and I saw this:
It seems likely a zombie could fall under the latter category, yes?
I don’t want to announce this find into the game thread until after day breaks though, because I think there’s value in seeing who gets attacked/defended and so on.
If there’s somebody you trust, feel free to pass this on.
[/QUOTE]
Sorry I didn’t respond; I was out at dinner. I see what you’re saying about this, but I interpret that quote of Pizza’s as being more about changing moral alignments and less about rising from the dead, although I suppose it could be about both. I also have no real strong opinions about post-death Mosier one way or the other, so I feel like the leap you took in the PM is based on somewhat thin reasoning. And I preferred gnarlycharlie as a target because I thought gnarlycharlie was affirmatively scummy, so I kept my attack on him. (I also know the identity of the other person who attacked him, and it’s someone I have a strong town lean on.)
** gnarly charlie ** publically claimed Watcher and privately claimed Soldier
If I read the quote tags correctly.
Any Town soldier want to tell us how that is / is not possible
I’m happy to un-nest the quote tags if it makes that exchange easier to follow, LightFoot.
I think I got it
The phrasing of the “reveal” isn’t suspicious in itself; that’s just bending over backwards to avoid the appearance of quoting. Well either that or he didn’t have a plausible role to claim – he obviously wasn’t a soldier if he was capable of watching someone that first night.
What would you do, Gadarene, if you had an affirmative night power like GC seems to have, and someone asked you for a role reveal?