[Mafia game] The Realm of Phere

[Silver_Jan]

@Normal_Phase

Yeah, but I’m the one sitting here with two votes and I have about a million RL things to do that I need to be doing instead of this.

Ok, to just do the consensus thing, please note I am unhappy

Unvote gnarlycharlie

Vote Mosier

I really hope You lot have got it right

[choie]

If we’re wrong (and wow, this is the very first wagon I’ve ever started!) all we lose is a zombie, and I’d imagine gnarlycharlie will be toast during the Night from at least some of the people who think he’s guilty.

[Tanaer]

@choie

See, now, this is why it’s bad that Askthepizzaguy isn’t giving us EOD vote counts performed by him. We would have noticed [Mosier’s double vote – assuming he had it yesterDay – with an official vote count.

Normal, would you be willing to post that question in public, so askthepizzaguy will answer in public? Not a slight against you, but as I said, I don’t trust (nor do I think anyone else should) any words claimed to come from pizzamod that we haven’t read ourselves directly from his own posts.

How is the item vote going, btw? I think glee, IIRC, seems assured to get the teal harp. But if Tanaer wants to be a bard, I prefer the harp in her hands. What can I say, I’m a music lover and would rather hear someone talented than some knight with no apparent musical abilities. Also, Tanaer’s the only one who’s put the hurt on Phere so she deserves a reward.

Ergo, [bteal harp to Tanaer

And I look good with white, so I’ll:

white sceptre to choie

… though I don’t think anyone else has voted that for me, so it’s probably a lost cause.

Among the current vote list I see no Believerer, fubbleskag or Red Skeezix (quel surprise). The fact that Red hasn’t been NKed makes me suspect he is active somewhere, as in a scum board. I guess we’ll find out toNight.

Thanks Choie. It took me too long to fully register this then find this again, but in case we get an OED extension again,

unvote white sceptre; white sceptre choke

[choie]

Thanks, Tanaer. Unfortunately even with your vote, I think the white sceptre’s almost certain to go to Guiri, who these days is getting all the phat goodies. At least he’s trustworthy, but it would be nice to get some of the other likely town folks some cool swag.

[Astral_Rejection]

Is day over now?

[Silver_Jan]

@choie

If we’re wrong (and wow, this is the very first wagon I’ve ever started!) all we lose is a zombie, and I’d imagine gnarlycharlie will be toast during the Night from at least some of the people who think he’s guilty.

Gnarly will probably sup from Mosiers brains and relish his death cries

[Silver_Jan]

@Astral_Rejection

Is day over now?

Tis 1 am my time, yay for laptops

[Astral_Rejection]

Any ETA on Day end reveal, Lord Pizza?

[Astral_Rejection]

Also, with this post, I’m now the second most prolific poster in this thread. Good luck WoWing me, suckahs!

[Askthepizzaguy]

If you kind folks would be kind enough to kindly assemble for me a tally, I’ll be able to make an attempt at advancing the round after a nap.

“nap” read: Only a couple hours of sleep between shifts.

[Visorslash]

Tallying…

Guiri (scathach
Gnarly (Inner Stickler, Lightfoot,
Mosier (choie, Astral, Visor, Visor, [Tanaer], Normal, Normal, Guiri, Silver Jan
Visorslash (Mosier, Mosier, Septimus),
Sub Plank (storyteller)

Blue Bow (Normal, Normal, Normal, Visor, Visor, Normal, Normal, Lightfoot
Red Bow (Astral, Visor, Visor, Astral, Astral, Tanaer
White Scepter (Visor, Visor, Guiri, Guiri, Guiri, choie, Choie
White Staff (SilverJan, Visor, Visor, SilverJan
Teal Harp (choie, Visor, Visor, {glee}, Tanaer, Glee, Glee, Glee, Tanaer

[No unvote AFAIK]
{No bold}

[Visorslash]

@Visorslash

Tallying…

1 Guiri (scathach)
2 Gnarly (Inner Stickler, Lightfoot)
9 Mosier (choie, Astral, Visor, Visor, [Tanaer], Normal, Normal, Guiri, Silver Jan
3 Visorslash (Mosier, Mosier, Septimus),
1 Sub Plank (storyteller)

Blue Bow: 5 Normal
2 Visor
1 Lightfoot

Red Bow:
3 Astral
2 Visor
1 Tanaer

White Scepter:
3 Guiri
2 Visor
2 Choie

White Staff:
2 Silver Jan
2 Visorslash

Teal Harp:
3/4 Glee
2 Tanaer
2 Visorslash
1 Choie
[No unvote AFAIK]
{No bold}

Edited. Known double votes included. Going to do another without known double votes as well

Edit:

1 Guiri (scathach)
2 Gnarly (Inner Stickler, Lightfoot)
7 Mosier (choie, Astral, Visor, [Tanaer], Normal, Guiri, Silver Jan)
2 Visorslash (Mosier, Septimus),
1 Sub Plank (storyteller)

Blue Bow: 4 Normal
1 Visor
1 Lightfoot

Red Bow:
3 Astral
1 Visor
1 Tanaer

White Scepter:
3 Guiri
1 Visor
2 Choie

White Staff:
2 Silver Jan
1 Visorslash

Teal Harp:
3/4 Glee
2 Tanaer
1 Visorslash
1 Choie

Well, that’s my attempt anyway.

[GuiriEnEspana]

A few minor differences in my version. Tanaer never unvoted SuburbanPlankton and the unvote/vote of the item was after EOD.

----------Lynch Vote----------
Mosier (8): choie(2961), AstralRejection(2980), Visorslash(2981*), NormalPhase(3033*), Guiri(3038), SilverJan(3041)
gnarlycharlie (3): [del]SilverJan(2890-3041)[/del], [del]Visorslash(2891-2891*)[/del], [del]AstralRejection(2903-2980)[/del], InnerStickler(2914), Lightfoot(2985), glee(2991), [del]NormalPhase(3022-3033)[/del], [del]Guiri(3032-3038)[/del]
Visorslash (3): Mosier(2823*), septimus(2830), [del]SilverJan(2850-2890)[/del]
SuburbanPlankton (2): Tanaer(2853), storyteller(2905)
Guiri (1): Scathach(2806)
NormalPhase (0): [del]Visorslash(2821-2891*)[/del]
Tanaer (0): [del]NormalPhase(2807-3022*)[/del]
Scathach (0): [del]Guiri(2803-3032)[/del], [del]NormalPhase(2804-2807*)[/del]

----------Blue Bow----------
NormalPhase (5): Guiri(2803), NormalPhase(2804*), AstralRejection(2815), Tanaer(2822)
Visorslash (2): Visorslash(2811*)
Lightfoot (1): septimus(2838)

----------Red Bow----------
AstralRejection (3): Guiri(2803), AstralRejection(2815), Tanaer(2822)
Visorslash (2): Visorslash(2811*)
Tanaer (1): septimus(2838)

----------White Scepter----------
Guiri (4): Guiri(2803), AstralRejection(2815), Tanaer(2822), septimus(2838)
Visorslash (2): Visorslash(2811*)
choie (1): choie(3008)

----------White Staff----------
Visorslash (2): Visorslash(2811*)
SilverJan (2): Guiri(2803), Septimus(2838)

----------Teal Harp----------
glee (4): glee(2817), Mosier(2823*), septimus(2838)
Tanaer (2): Tanaer(2822), choie(3008)
Visorslash (2): Visorslash(2811*)
choie (1): Guiri(2803)

[Visorslash]

That’s a lot better. Thanks for clearing that up.

[Tanaer]

sigh. I feel like a total twit for forgetting the unvote. You guys all seemed to notice it though- could noone have mentioned it to me before eod?

[gnarlycharlie]

i see Day has ended without my knowing. i even failed to vote. it seems i won’t be lynched but that may just delay the inevitable. i may die at Dusk or toNight. seems some people don’t like players with a vig capability. scum could also think i’m too much of a threat to leave alive.

also as much as i prefer Mosier lynched over me, it seems too easy to lynch him. he comes back as a zombie so he might be scum. it may be meta but Pizza is rarely obvious.

@Silver_Jan

This whole game is a mess for me. I really didn’t like gnarly killing** Gad**. I know he said it was for self preservation but there are players out there that can protect and that is often exposed during the Day phase. Sorry but I’m not sure if I buy it.

Gnarly, would you have told us that you had killed** Gad** if you hadn’t been seen doing it? Who else have you killed?

i haven’t killed anyone else. you may have not noticed but there has been a discussion that my kill was the first that wasn’t from Phere. on prior Nights i had the watching ability.

@Astral_Rejection

Gnarly, If it looks like you’re going to be the lynch, would you mind PMing me and someone else you trust what you can tell us about your class? If you die, I’d like to maximize town’s information gains.

i wouldn’t mind communicating even if i’m not lynched.

[Astral_Rejection]

Cool! Shoot me a PM with whatever you’re comfortable telling me. I’d suggest sending it to someone else, too, so it can be verified later.

[choie]

I wonder if askthepizzaguy might solicit a co-mod for this game? Hoopy Frood for example? I hate to sound like Gadarene but I think the nebulous EOD and EON periods are wreaking havoc on both user participation and motivation. I totally understand that pizza is doing us a favor (and I’ve always defended his tough schedule) but I hate to see the enthusiasm for the game dropping steadily.

Plus, I really really really do not like that players are being asked to come up with the tallies ourselves. I mean, I don’t mine our regular in-progress vote counts, but official tallies should never come from players themselves. That’s just asking for trouble, especially in a game like this, where presumably it’s only the game mod who really knows who’s double-voting or single voting or half-voting or voting while doing the rhumba wearing a hat made out of fruit, or whatever the other options may be. If pizza opens up to a partner – obviously not one of the players (alive or dead, assuming the dead might be brought back as that’s obviously the game mechanism) – then perhaps with a partner or assistant, pizza will have an easier time of keeping track of stuff without having to rely on obviously biased and not-always-accurate players*.

• No offense to Guiri or Visorslash, but we’re all biased, and presumably most of us are in the dark one way or the other.

[choie]

NETA: “I don’t mine”? Well, this is true enough; I am neither a RPG dwarf nor do I even play Minecraft. But obviously I meant “I don’t mind.”

[Astral_Rejection]

@choie

voting while doing the rhumba wearing a hat made out of fruit

How did you know?!