Chronos, what happened to your last scheme, the one where everyone was going to say whether they were third party or not?
I like schemes. Hell, I love them. But how could this **brewha **/Batman scheme work?
-
I think it highly probable that **brewha **is Town. **brewha ** as Scum making his switch claim makes no sense.
-
Batman would have to agree to go along for this scheme for it to work. That’s a big assumption. But ok, let’s say he or she does.
-
The other switch holder, if Town, would also have to agree, and hopefully not be among the 5 or 10 people not seemingly paying attention or not showing up to the game at all. If the other switch holder is Scum or 3rd Party, then **Brewha **likely dies. Perhaps we learn something about what happens to switches when a player dies. Perhaps we also give Scum or 3rd Party complete control over whether Batman’s future kills go through. Because if one switch holder dies, the other one controls the role switch until death of the power or death of the remaining switch holder, right?
4.Two Scum have the power to turn off all switches. One Town has the power to turn on all switches. Let’s hope they are all cooperating. Is there a master switch controlling 3rd party? Who knows?
-
Two Scum have the power to watch and see who targets a player. That puts a cooperative Batman in danger of being outed.
-
We give up any chance Batman actually killing any Scum tonight.
Maybe I am letting my deep suspicions of **Chronos **cloud my judgement. jsgoddess, you say you like the plan. Please tell me what I am missing?
For those of you who never have played in a game with switches, be sure to read storyteller’s Night 0, post#126. It gives a simple explanation, but is not easily found among the rules at the start of the thread.