Maggie or Shelly? 90's obscura

I’ll bite.

Who?

Shelley in a heartbeat. I wouldn’t touch Maggie with a twelve-foot Lithuanian…too skinny and way too dangerous. :smiley:

Definitely Maggie. One wouldn’t necessarily have to have a long-term (and therefore lethal) relationship with her, right?

To drop a couple of names:

A close female friend got to see Janine Turner naked once. They belonged to the same health club here in Seattle while the show was in production. I’m told she looks as good unclothed as I always believed she must.

I once worked for a woman of Mexican descent who had been an extra on the show, playing a Native American. She once introduced me to Elaine Miles (Marilyn) when Elaine met her at work one day. They had figured that if Christina (my boss) could play to Elaine’s race, Elaine should be able to do Christina’s (and therefore get more acting jobs–this was after the show had been cancelled). So they were going to lunch to discuss how to best act like a Mexican-American.

Chris by a mile.

MAGGIE! Homminahomminahommina.

Ed Chigliak was always my Northern Exposure boyfriend. Pretty, and simple, but in a deep kind of way:)

You and I have to stop agreeing on everything. Chris in a goddamn heartbeat; no one else in Cicely comes close. It’s rare to find someone so attractive with such a great voice.

Oh, and if I were so inclined, Maggie.

I’m guessing the women are forgetting the episode where Chris had his penis chopped off in a tragic record-player accident. Oh, the blood! Oh, the humanity!

Shelly…

especially if her mom could be thrown in for good measure.

hell, why not get really twisted (on several levels) & throw in Holling’s daughter (Valerie Perrine)?

Thanks to BrotherC for bringing up that redhaired hypochondriac hottie Eve.

Innanna you were right.

Ed!! Ed!

Between the characters, I would go with Shelly. Shelly is more likely to say ‘OK’ to any, how shall we say, *unusual * request.
But physically I like Janine Turner better.

Even RuthAnne?

Maggie all the way. Maggie is smart, adventurous and feisty.

Shelly is shallow and ditzy. It’s no contest.

What do the ladies think of Holling, though?

Definitely Maggie. That short haircut is massively attractive. (As are those legs.)

Ed’s girlfriend (the one who poisoned the whole town with tainted buttered popcorn) was hotter than both Maggie or Shelly, but since she ain’t in the running, I’ll take Maggie. If I was in a room alone with Shelly, I would probably break a curtin-rod across her throat the first time she opened her mouth (to speak, at least :wink: ).

Now, if we’re talking Twin Peaks, give me Shelly all the way, with a side order of Norma!

No quesch: Meadow.

Oh.
Wait.

We’re talking about the other great David Chase series, aren’t we?

I’d still take Meadow over any Cicely lady. But I’d do Ruth Anne before Adrianna.

What about Chris’s black half-brother? What was his name? He was pretty cute.

Shelly is hot and if it were just a one night stand, then I think her. On the other hand, Maggie had a certain sparkle in her eye that made her attractive, even though I usually don’t go for women with short hair. I guess I’ll stick with Shelly.

What about the roving optometrist babe who was the only woman not affected by Chris’s seasonal mojo?

Since I never liked Chris, this made her all the more appealing.