Mark Twain was right; God is a malign thug. (Long and personal)

I’m sorry if this offends anybody, but I am so furious I can barely see to type this.

I have in past posts occasionally referred to my wife and her health problems. In the last ten years her health has steadily deteriorated to the point where she is all but confined to the house. Going out to do anything is a major project, with any plans subject to last minute changes due to how she’s doing at the time we’re ready to go. But the news we just got is the last straw.

Before I go into the latest assault on her, let me give you some idea what her life has been like:

When she was born, there was some complication (she says she was told it was Harm’s Palsy) that left her right arm semi-functional at best. It has almost no strength and she cannot lift it higher than her shoulder.

Her mother died when she was very young. When her father remarried a few years later, her stepmother hated her (partly because she was the image of her mother) to the point where the bitch persuaded her father to have her put in a foster home rather than live with them. Her father died when she was seventeen, and her stepmother even tried to throw her out of the funeral home during the wake.

She hasn’t talked much about her life but I know that she was involved in several Chicago theater groups, drove a cab for a while, and had various office jobs. A relatively non-descript life, from what little she has said, full of the usual joys and sorrows. Then one day she was riding in a cab and when it stopped for a light somebody opened the door and tried to grab her purse. When she didn’t let go right away, he started beating her on the head. And what does the cabdriver do while his passenger is screaming for help? He sits there; doesn’t even turn around or try to drive off even after the light changes. Of course, the mugger was never caught; there was some suspicion that the cabdriver was involved (gee, you think?). As a result of the beating, she starts having blackouts and has to miss a lot of work; her company uses the convenient timing of some scheduled layoffs to dump her without looking it’s related to her illness. This leaves her with no health insurance while she’s supposed to be getting CAT scans and taking expensive medication for her seizures and migraines.

At about this time we met. All right, maybe that wasn’t such a disaster. I was looking to get out of where I was living, she was trying to find an apartment, so we decided to split a two-bedroom to save expenses. Shortly after that, she gets laid off so suddenly she’s living on unemployment and the occasional odd jobs. Of course she can’t get a permanent job because nobody will hire a forty-eight year old woman who can’t type more than 30 wpm and has occasional seizures. Eventually her unemployment runs out, but by this time a friend is able to get her work on a part-time basis as “contract labor” (hourly pay stuffing envelopes, sorting and filing on a flat hourly basis, with no company benefits) which at least keeps her off welfare. Somewhere during all this, our relationship shifts from “friends” to “why don’t we get married” which in addition to the obvious also solves her health insurance problems.

In time the seizures stop and she’s taken off the medication. Unfortunately she then develops adult-onset diabetes and is put on oral medication and told to lose more weight (she had already dropped about thirty pounds in preparation for the wedding). Then the arthritis kicks in on the hands and knees; not too bad, just enough to be an annoyance.

For a few years everything seems to be under control, until in the space of three years she gets hit by:

Diabetic retinopathy, which requires semiannual laser treatments to seal broken blood vessels in her eyes.
Diabetic neuropathy, which causes shooting pains which start in her feet and gradually work their way up her legs.
Sores and blisters on the soles of her feet, culminating in a bacterial infection which costs her half her left foot.
Cataracts, which is complicated by the retinopathy so that treatment keeps getting deferred and when they finally do operate she ends up losing most of her eyesight.
Kidney stones which do not respond to the initial ultrasonic treatment, requiring a second visit which still leaves her with some minor loss of kidney function.

So now she is sixty-eight. She can see just well enough to avoid walking into walls; in order to watch TV clearly she has to sit 4-5 feet from a 32” set, and even large print books aren’t always readable. Reading was one of the joys of her life; she used to joke about how she’d never be able to get through my library. She can walk around the house but going anywhere else requires use of a motorized scooter, and since she can’t see well enough to navigate herself she’s stuck in the house all day with nothing to do but listen to the TV. She used to love just getting in the car and going for a drive, another thing she’ll never do again. Between the arthritis, the neuropathy and the bursitis in her left shoulder she’s in constant pain that can only be partially relieved because of interactions with her other medications.

Lately she’s been having increasingly frequent dizzy spells and loss of balance which has been causing her to fall; she usually can’t get up without assistance, which can be really interesting if I’m at work when it happens. After falling three times in the last week she called her doctor Friday and he told her to go to the emergency room; he would call ahead and authorize a CAT scan. After all the fun and games of checking in and waiting around she finally gets the CAT scan, which shows no tumors or other obvious brain damage. So they decide to keep her for a few days and have her checked by a neurologist.

Today she calls me to tell me the neurologist has given her a preliminary diagnosis.

Parkinson’s Disease.

Fuck, hasn’t this poor woman been through enough? Wasn’t taking away the ability to enjoy everything she liked enough? This is a woman who cried for hours whenever one of her cats died, who paid to have a tombstone put on her father’s grave at the age of eighteen even though he had abandoned her when she was five, and who, when the foster mother who had treated her as little better than an unpaid servant for most of her childhood needed help, moved back in with her and put up with five more years of abuse and controlling behavior.

I’ve heard all the crap about how God isn’t responsible for every little thing, how He provides strength to get through your trials.

Fuck that shit.

And I can’t do a damn thing about it.
That’s the worst part. :frowning: :mad:

As the father of a 13 year old with Cystic Fibrosis and CF-related diabetes, along with other complications, I feel your pain and anger. And I have no answers.

I’m not one of those to posit endlessly about how “nothing ever happens for a reason” and all that hoo-hah. I believe that some good things can come out of any painful situation; however I find that all too often the good doesn’t offset the bad.

God never gives you more than you can handle. Until he kills you.

But there is still love in the world. And for me sometimes that has to be enough.

Sorry, that should read “Everything happens for a reason”

I dunno. I can think of some people driven batshit insane by what god gave them…

LurkMeister, I am so sorry for all the troubles you and your missus are going through, and have been through.

She sounds a wonderfully strong woman and is lucky to have such a loving man by her side.

Please take heart in knowing people are keeping you both in their thoughts.

Keep thee well LurkMeister. Wishing better for you both.

All I can say is, “I’m sorry. I’m sorry. I’m sorry.” :frowning:

CJ

Your wife sounds like an extraordinary and courageous woman.

Sending our good thoughts to both of you.

Parkinson’s Disease is a horrible thing. My mom got early Parkinson’s at about 48 or so.

I’ve found helpful information at this website:

All the best for both of you.

This is so sad, Lurkmeister. I also had a relative with Parkinson’s–a great-uncle who died a couple winters ago. It’s very hard on everyone involved, and I can’t really say anything to make it better. I’m sorry for the sad news.
If I’m reading your post correctly, you two have been married for over twenty years now? If so, wow–she’s lucky to have a guy like you with that kind of staying power. Think how much more horrid your list of her sorrows would be if it included…

“Marries a man who cares little for her and leaves when things get tough. Lives alone and unloved.”

You’re doing a good thing for her just by your very existence, I’d say. Best of luck.

bella

Thanks to all for your thoughts.

Anahita, that web site was quite useful; it answered a number of questions I’d had. Interestingly enough, a few years ago she had started having tremors in her hands, and the thought of Parkinson’s had come up but since she had no other symptoms her doctor diagnosed it as Essential Tremor. He prescribed treatment which seemed to be working, but recently the tremors had started to come back in the right hand.

belladonna, we’ve been married nineteen years as of last month (it only seems like thirty, as we’re always joking). Things have only gotten bad in the last five years; she actually worked at Great America the summer after the amputation, and was planning to work there again the following summer. But over the winter the cataracts developed and she lost her night vision, which made it impossible for her to drive back and forth. From then on it’s been all downhill.

I just tried to call her but she was off having an MRI. The nurse said the doctor had visited her again this morning, so there may be an update on her condition soon. They had said that they didn’t expect to keep her for more than a few days, so she may be home soon. We were supposed to be going to see The Fantasticks, one of her favorite shows, last Sunday, and I was able to change the tickets to this Sunday, so I hope nothing else comes up.

I’m sorry your wife and you are going throgh such a lot, LurkMeister, but blaming god for it makes no sense. If there were a “loving” god such things wouldn’t happen in the first place. Children wouldn’t have cancer and babies wouldn’t be born adicted to crack. Omnipotence (benevolent omnipotence, that is) would prevent it. The only way any of these horrors makes any sense is if there is no god at all.

I’m afraid I do believe in god, in the sense of a superstition at least, and I hate the god I was taught to believe in. But getting mad at god does no good. If he’s there, he is paying no attention to us mortals. If he exists, the devil is redundant. If he doesn’t exist, it’s a waste of mental muscle to contemplate him. We’re on our own.

My best wishes to you and your wife. That will do you as much good as prayer.


Geezer

I have to agree with DesertGeezer.

If God exists, his name is Satan. :mad:

God, if you’re up there:

May your holy ass burn with the pain of a thousand butt plugs!

:eek:
You dick.

God always came off to me as being bipolar.

And yes, your situation does sick. Best wishes to your wife.

I would suggest a new work up with a new doctor. Don’t give them all your present doctors records but instead force a new treatment and diagnosis. If it concurs with the first then you will need to deal with that. I am however familiar with several instances of misdiagnosis leading to incorrect treatments.
It is obvious at the very least that the maintanence of her diabetes is not having the desired results so a hard look at that is definitly needed. Diabetes is a condition that can come and go in some instances in particular adult onset types. Sometimes a change in diet is much more effective than insulin and sometimes the medications can interfere with the bodys own systems and a reduced or absent need for external insulin can be masked.
Diabetes is a horible disease but is able to be maintained pretty well, particularly with the help of home glucose meters and such.
Anyway I am not intending to criticize her care or her physicians but often people (doctors included) can “decide” something early on and spend the rest of their time clouded by that preconception. A fresh perspective from another physician (preferably not one in the same office), is always useful if for no other reason than to ease your mind that everything that can/should be done, is.

As for God, I can certainly understand your anger and frustration but I can not blame God for her suffering. I don’t think God does much actively in the world. He can’t really and still claim to allow us our freewill. If we know God will come down and cure us of all our ills or feed us when we are hungry or destroy our enemies, we would no longer be anything but kept animals. God did’nt set that purse snatcher on her, nor did he inflict the disease and injury she suffers. Genetics, environment, a pre-natal accident? Anything could have been the start of her road. It is a tragedy to be sure and unfair that one person should suffer so much while others don’t share the burden. But you might also consider that the freewill that God promises us has also made it possible for us to develop medicines and treatments that have obviously extended her life far beyond what it would have been if the disease or injuries she suffered were left untreated.
Anyway I always have believed that if there is a God out there, he mostly just watches us maybe waiting for the day when we learn enough about ourselves and our uiverse that we might be able to comprehend what “HE” is.

Yep, that’s God alright. I recognize his M.O.

It’s funny how you lot would instantly blame God for your woes, but in good times you’d forget he ever existed and think that you’ve gotten where you are of your own accord! I’m confused! I notice that the rant consists mainly of the bad that’s happened to her over the years, but mentions nothing (or very little) of the good! Did she ever pray and worship God? If she never acknowledged his existence, then why complain when things don’t go your way? It’s a bit like double standards to me!

Anaximenes - May someone help you on the day of judgment, God certainly won’t, but since you obviously don’t believe in him, you’ve got nothing to worry about, have you?
Unless you’re wrong, and you’ll have to spend 70’000 years in the lower levels of Hell - that would be quite amusing wouldn’t it? 1000 buttplugs would seem like a holiday in comparison of the pain.

It’s funny how some people give God credit whenever something good happens, but blame Mankind when when things go wrong. It’s funny that a supposedly benevolent diety would punish someone for eternity with no hope for for redemption for a finite sin.
It’s funny what beliefs some people will resort to in order to feel superior to others.

My sympathies, LurkMeister.

I’m also going through a tough time, but not as bad as your wife’s in comparison. When I talk to my mom, she tries to comfort me by saying things like “God has a plan for you”. Of course, even if I believed in God, his plan may be for me to be homeless or in some other bad situation. Obviously, that’s his plan for some people, since lots of people are indeed homeless!

I feel that when bad things at that level happen it really is just chance, and there is no person or deity to blame. The trick I suppose is it to try and deal with the problems without emotionally obsessing about how they came about. If I ever figure out to do that myself, I’ll let you know…

Just curious, where did the 70,000 years come from? I’ve usually heard that the “sentence” to Hell is eternity. Where do you go after the 70,000 years is up, some kind of Hell halfway house?

LurkMeister, all I can say is that I’m sorry. You and your wife are both in my thoughts and you have my best wishes.